geegel wrote:At this stage I realize that lynching is a good idea, but speed-lynching is not. If you look at the bandwagon vote I'm sure there are at least one or two mafia scum voting for it. OTOH there's also the possibility of catching the SK or the cult leader.
So... unvote
vote nag
Obviously FOS on Vodean and LV.
Just So you know, both of hem haven't really posted serious comments, their last posts are well within the joke vote stage. So I don't really understand your logic here.
Votes are votes and they got to the point where an actual lynch might come out of them. Random voting can be interpreted as joke voting, but a concerted effort to get a lynch going has to give you some pause.
geegel wrote:At this stage I realize that lynching is a good idea, but speed-lynching is not. If you look at the bandwagon vote I'm sure there are at least one or two mafia scum voting for it. OTOH there's also the possibility of catching the SK or the cult leader.
So... unvote
vote nag
Obviously FOS on Vodean and LV.
Just So you know, both of hem haven't really posted serious comments, their last posts are well within the joke vote stage. So I don't really understand your logic here.
Votes are votes and they got to the point where an actual lynch might come out of them. Random voting can be interpreted as joke voting, but a concerted effort to get a lynch going has to give you some pause.
Well, I believe your action can be seen as inexperience, but believe me, joke vote bandwagons ( as long as no one comes close to a lynch) are not at all uncommon or even scummy. If you look at them in a serious manner I can understand you think they look scummy though, but I don't think you'll get much support. The joke stage seems over now though so the posts being made now should all be pretty serious.
geegel wrote:At this stage I realize that lynching is a good idea, but speed-lynching is not. If you look at the bandwagon vote I'm sure there are at least one or two mafia scum voting for it. OTOH there's also the possibility of catching the SK or the cult leader.
So... unvote
vote nag
Obviously FOS on Vodean and LV.
Just So you know, both of hem haven't really posted serious comments, their last posts are well within the joke vote stage. So I don't really understand your logic here.
Votes are votes and they got to the point where an actual lynch might come out of them. Random voting can be interpreted as joke voting, but a concerted effort to get a lynch going has to give you some pause.
Any bandwagon can have scum on it, but it's very difficult to figure out who might be scum based on just 1 bandwagon. Can't find bandwagonners too easily with so little data.
LSU Tiger Josh wrote: Day 1 will end sometime after I get home from work on Thursday. That will give you the 5 days I guaranteed in the rules plus a couple of extra hours.
that was in the first 2 vote counts
LSU Tiger Josh The man, the myth, the legend has returned.
Vote Count (17 alive: 8 to get a kick in the balls and 9 to lynch) 4: Elon: Campin, edicsil, Jonty, DJ 3 Nag: Red, LV, Geegel 2 Hippo: nag, Vodean 1 Aage: Strike Wolf 1 Vodean: Zimmah 1 Strike WOlf: Aage 1 DJ: Shaggy
After lots of discussion the letters of the alphabet were unable to decide on a lynch.
LSU Tiger Josh The man, the myth, the legend has returned.
Sorry guys, but I'm preparing for a hurricane right now. At some point tomorrow the scene will be posted. The damn storm has moved further west than they originally expected.
LSU Tiger Josh The man, the myth, the legend has returned.
Mr. W was walking home after doing a house call for someone that was sick. As he was walking home, he hears someone coming up behind him and call to him. Just as Mr. W turns around, the figure catches up to him and stabs the good doctor in the heart killing him instantly.
Campin: Mr. W town doc has been killed
Mr. Q finishes his kill and then starts to head home cutting through some alleys. In one of those alleys, he witnesses a dirty transaction taking place. As he tries to explain that he would never rat them out, the mobsters decide that they could not risk Mr. Q telling on them. They put Mr. Q's feet in blocks of cement and dump him into the river where he sinks to the bottom and drowns.
Zimmah: Mr. Q SK has been killed
Day 2 has now begun.
LSU Tiger Josh The man, the myth, the legend has returned.
Night kill analysis is hard, since the SK and the doc probably knew as little as we do.
Yesterday wasn't very productive and the only lead I have is that Vodean seems scummy (for a change). In response to Strike Wolf's "over-defence", he didn't vote for him once despite making several posts in which he seems to imply that SW is scummy. It seems very non-Vodeanish not to vote on that. Normally he puts his money where his mouth is. So FoS for that, and that's all.
Yeah, there is little to take from the night scene, just have to hope that someone has some evidence to bring to the table else we are back at square 1. Need to lynch today, no lynch is counter-productive. Any volunteers?
I agree that the scene leaves little to be done with. If we have any other information out there I agree bring it up. The only thing that still sticks in my mind elon and SW. Geezel did play the delay the voting part but as stated may have been inexperience and people just not stepping into anything. Other than that Night gave us nothing. We do need to start the pressure and get some claims going.
So ill start back up with the highest vote count and where we had some debate on SW's defense so time to put the pressure back on
LSU Tiger Josh wrote:Mr. W was walking home after doing a house call for someone that was sick. As he was walking home, he hears someone coming up behind him and call to him. Just as Mr. W turns around, the figure catches up to him and stabs the good doctor in the heart killing him instantly.
Campin: Mr. W town doc has been killed
Mr. Q finishes his kill and then starts to head home cutting through some alleys. In one of those alleys, he witnesses a dirty transaction taking place. As he tries to explain that he would never rat them out, the mobsters decide that they could not risk Mr. Q telling on them. They put Mr. Q's feet in blocks of cement and dump him into the river where he sinks to the bottom and drowns.
Zimmah: Mr. Q SK has been killed
Day 2 has now begun.
So is it safe to assume that the SK killed Campin, then the Scum kill the SK? If not, there could be an issue here. I'll wait to hear more.
Mobsters, blocks of cement, not to mention that it starts with "Mr. Q finishing his kill".
I might add that I think the Day 1 start scene hinted at Mr. Y being cult. Odd that there's no mention of possible cult recruitment, although that doesn't necessarily mean there is no cult.
Well we didn't get a lot of info out of day one in this game. I'm still not sure why there is pressure on me. Most of the votes on me were joke votes about my name (which comes from my alma mater Elon, plus the fact that I was on the roller hockey team and def not a puck hog), one was because that person had never played with me before, etc. Then I made a mistake, indicating that I thought we were out of joke phase when we weren't. It seems like most of you were surprised when the deadline came because activity never really picked up before the deadline like I thought it would.
thehippo8 wrote:Just out of interrest, Zimmah, how do you suspect that the SK was killed?
EBWOP ... that came out strange. I meant to say, how do you all think that Simmah was killed. Sigh!
The scene speaks for itself. If you need me to analyse it for you, I suspect you have bigger issues than this game, no offence.
Saf, I assume there has been a recruitment but it rarely mentions so in the day scene; neither is the cop or doctor, and I doubt the new recruit will enlighten us with the info. I feel strangely offended. Like my reply to Hippo, I thought it went without saying.
thehippo8 wrote:Just out of interrest, Zimmah, how do you suspect that the SK was killed?
EBWOP ... that came out strange. I meant to say, how do you all think that Simmah was killed. Sigh!
The scene speaks for itself. If you need me to analyse it for you, I suspect you have bigger issues than this game, no offence.
Saf, I assume there has been a recruitment but it rarely mentions so in the day scene; neither is the cop or doctor, and I doubt the new recruit will enlighten us with the info. I feel strangely offended. Like my reply to Hippo, I thought it went without saying.
For the record, I will say that whether or not a cult recruitment shows up in the night scene is a mod preference thing. I myself will indicate a cult recruitment happened if it was successful, and I have seen other games where this is also the case.
Well I suppose we'll have to assume cult recruited N1 unless some scene later on disproves this. I can't think of a reason why cult wouldn't recruit N1.
War doesn't determine who's right; it determines who's left.
