Conquer Club

Vote for Mafia thread

http://www.conquerclub.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=15793

I can't protect till i revive some1 so untill i revive some1 i cant protect any1!

Incandenza wrote:good one... exile does seem to be popping in, posting a quick message, and then disappearing for the next 24 or so hours... maybe that's just due to the schedule he's on. But it's been hard to get much of a bead on him thru his posts.

I'm kinda in over my head for mafia games atm, so apoligies if I'm not too active, but that's midweek for you.

I'm only in mafia games once a day for an hour or so... I hope you don't need me much more, a day phase is 5 RL days, after all.

Anything particularly scummy I'm doing though, call me out on it.

spinwizard wrote:I can't protect till i revive some1 so untill i revive some1 i cant protect any1!

OH. Got it. So it's not trying to revive, it's actually succeeding. That makes sense and fits your stories. Thanks for clarifying.

It's now Thursday. Where are all of you on votes for a lynch? I'm really thinking Fircola, but I've been wrong before.

3. Fircoal - x
9. Incandenza - x
10. for dummies - x
11. XenHu - x


These are the four I believe are most likely mafia...

I'm gonna have to go out on a limb here and vote Fircoal

He doesn't look too scummy to me, but he's not looking that innocent either and he isn't sticking with his usual character.

I'm hoping someone has a better case to persuade me, but meh.... we can't really go with a no lynch.

wicked wrote:

spinwizard wrote:I can't protect till i revive some1 so untill i revive some1 i cant protect any1!

OH. Got it. So it's not trying to revive, it's actually succeeding. That makes sense and fits your stories. Thanks for clarifying.

It's now Thursday. Where are all of you on votes for a lynch? I'm really thinking Fircola, but I've been wrong before.

That's what that means?! lol just kidding, but seriously spin. How much longer would that have taken to type 'one' than '1' and maybe a comma or two?

I would have to agree with everyone that fircoal would be the best choice however i still don't really think he is mafia.

So it seems that the predominant opinion about spin is town. I can get on board with that. FD made a good point about the whole captain concept...

as far as who to lynch... fircoal is definitely on my shortlist. I hesitate to vote for someone based on 'he's acting weird', but there's not a to else to go on.

I'm gonna need to ponder. I'll vote later this afternoon or evening.

I guess that i have to vote: fircoal i mean we don't have any really good leads. At this point he seems like the most viable option. Vote fast people as the deadline is tomorrow

i am still FOS'ing Wicked cause she has not been night killed yet...

I'm surprised by that as well. Either I'm spot on with the guys I'm calling scum (Fircola & Exile), or I'm dead wrong but leading you guys in the wrong direction with those two. I sure hope it's the former.

FD also makes me suspitious...but remotely

what exactly is suspicious?

wicked wrote:I'm surprised by that as well. Either I'm spot on with the guys I'm calling scum (Fircola & Exile), or I'm dead wrong but leading you guys in the wrong direction with those two. I sure hope it's the former.

Um, yeah, me too...

Well your dead wrong about me, but I'm not so sure about The1exile

Between fircoal and exile, i still don't think fircoal is mafia.

Vote exile

I don't think it's worth voting fircoal, a good mafia player, just because he isn't as active as usual.

I agree...

Vote: Exile

I'd say to say Exile is scummier, so Vote: Exile

Fircoal wrote:I'd say to say Exile is scummier, so Vote: Exile

I'm sure you'ld say to say it, as you are the other person... hahaha

Anarkistsdream wrote:

Fircoal wrote:I'd say to say Exile is scummier, so Vote: Exile

I'm sure you'ld say to say it, as you are the other person... hahaha

ya. lol

Vote: Fircoal


I don't think Exile is scum.. And since we're choosing between the two..

-X

XenHu wrote:Vote: Fircoal


I don't think Exile is scum.. And since we're choosing between the two..

-X

F***in' Rogues...

I'm not scum. And no-one has said why I'm acting scummy, especially. I can't post as much as I'd like because of my day schedule.

Vote Count



4 Fircoal (wicked, The1exile, for dummies, XenHu)
3 The1exile (dcowboys055, Anarkistsdream, Fircoal)
1 XenHu (trestain)



3 Not Voting (spinwizard, Incandenza, Minkish)



With 11 alive it takes 6 to Lynch!

Both fircoal and exile look at least somewhat mafia to me.

The problem is that neither of them are anything like a slam dunk.

The additional problem is that, barring divine intervention, it's pretty much down to one or the other.

So, in a situation like this, I can only try and reason things out. And my thinking leads me to this question: if I'm wrong, who would I prefer to remain alive?

The answer to that can only be fircoal. I imagine some sort of investigative agency might want to have a gander at him at some point, but for the moment...

Well, let me put it this way. If I'm wrong, and they're both town, I'd rather fircoal still be alive than exile. It's a hard way of looking at things.

However, it might be the wrong way to look at things. Remember, one of the reasons that we're thinking of lynching fircoal is that he's been singularly unhelpful, which is aberrant behavior. So it's not like he's been a big help thus far, nor should we expect his productivity to pick up, given his multifarious RL engagements.

Plus, if he does turn out to be mafia, and given at least one other mafioso, it's likely that he's the vet with an inexperienced partner or two (or three, but if it's three we're probably fucked), who should be easy to round up.

Clearly I'm torn. But a vote for fircoal would put him at lynch -1, and that doesn't strike me as being a very intelligent move, especially given that it's the wee hours.

But I will almost certainly be back on some hours (at least 3) before the deadline... and as always we'll see how it goes.