Conquer Club

Regarding fakeclaims

Hojo and Sephiroth's fakes were pretty straightforward.

Sephiroth's was Dr. Lucrecia Crescent, a poison doctor that was supposed to protect people from being killed by Hojo.
Hojo's was Zack Fair, a FBI agent that was could investigate people to find Sephiroth.

Mafia's 5 fakeclaims were not all necessarily believable, but they were important in showing them which power roles town did not have.
They knew from the get-go that town did not have a tracker nor a watcher. I also gave them both Red XIII claims, so one of them could be strongly believed after the other was shown to be fake. Yes, faking investigations was not an easy job, but they could always claim "mafia busdriver" tampered with them.

Vincent as a jailkeeper was the perfect fakeclaim for Scarlet.

Tifa's fakeclaim was a weaker one (governor). Wildwilliam did not like it and decided to fakeclaim JOAT instead, which allowed Strike to lead his lynch.

Barret's fakeclaim was a vengeful townie, matching the same flavour of the actual Barret (bomb) - "both Barrets would seek revenge by killing someone".

Just gonna comment and say I thought it was funny that this lasted seven days, what with the theme and all.

I just hated these busdrivers i kept getting busdriven a lot , and if i didn't, they would die. i was expecting chap and ghostly to die rather than edoc and dazza

It was a fun game, I got so frustrated that my night kills were falling foul!

Good game all. Really enjoyed this 1.

Victor Sullivan wrote:

strike wolf wrote:For the record I can't really blame town for lynching the busdriver when there was a mafia Bus driver all but confirmed but really? you follow the third party who doesn't care which side wins in choosing the lynch? Town seemed a bit too eager there.

Haha, I know! I just wanted him lynched so he wouldn't screw me over

-Sully

Which I actually planned to do...

Even though I hadn't quite decided on with who, most likely myself

Great game, Rodion. I especially liked the post-game analysis. I can't wait for your next one.

drunkmonkey wrote:Great game, Rodion. I especially liked the post-game analysis. I can't wait for your next one.

Agreed!

took forever to fill up but was worth it,

rodion, thanks for all thanks for this, and have you got the night actions handy?

drake_259 wrote:took forever to fill up but was worth it,

rodion, thanks for all thanks for this, and have you got the night actions handy?

They are in my excel file. I need to type them into something "understandable" first, which I plan to do today!

Good Game, good win. Strike, when you got ANNIHILATED every one of those hits was supposed to take me out, we busdrove you and I. So sad that I still died afterwords.

edocsil wrote:Good Game, good win. Strike, when you got ANNIHILATED every one of those hits was supposed to take me out, we busdrove you and I. So sad that I still died afterwords.

Yeah. Funny thing is I actually figured that out. lol. Actually when I saw the Gatling gun, I thought it was because the real Barret was aiming to kill you.

So being a bit dumb, I miscounted the number of mafia. I take back what I said about the balance.

Actions

N1

Eldario swaps Commander and newguy
Alt/Sniper swaps Wildwilliam and DoomYoshi
Drunkmonkey blocks Ghostly
Jgordon blocks Strike Wolf
Wildwilliam frames Victor Sullivan
Agentcom investigates Zimmah -> not a Turk
Dukasaur investigates Victor Sullivan -> Reno finds Elena and they become day/night masoned
Newguy investigates DoomYoshi (actually ends up investigating Wildwilliam) -> not a Turk
Victor Sullivan investigates DoomYoshi (actually ends up investigating Wildwilliam) -> not a Turk
DoomYoshi investigates Chapcrap -> not mafia (godfather immunity)
Strike Wolf investigates Wildwilliam - > roleblocked (his 1-shot investigation was refunded for later use)
Dazza protects Wildwilliam
Djfireside protects DoomYoshi
Hippo kills agentcom
Wildwilliam kills Commander9 (actually ends up killing New Guy)
Ghostly kills Edocsil -> kill fails due to roleblock
Drake poisons New Guy (actually ends up poisoning Commander)

N2

Eldario swaps Commander and slowreactor
Alt/Sniper swaps Edocsil and Zimmah
Drunkmonkey blocks Zimmah (actually ends up blocking Edocsil)
Jgordon blocks Commander
DoomYoshi investigates Jgordon -> mafia
Strike Wolf investigates Zimmah (actually ends up investigating Edocsil) - > mafia
Dazza protects Strike Wolf
Djfireside protects Strike Wolf
Hippo kills Commander (actually ends up killing slowreactor)
Edocsil kills DoomYoshi -> kill fails due to roleblock
Ghostly kills Chapcrap -> Chap loses his 1-shot bulletproof
Drake poisons Zimmah (actually ends up poisoning Edocsil)

N3

Eldario swaps Commander and chapcrap
Alt/Sniper swaps Edocsil and Strike Wolf
Jgordon blocks Drunkmonkey
Drunkmonkey blocks Hippo -> block fails because Drunkmonkey was blocked
DoomYoshi investigates Commander (actually ends up investigating Chapcrap) -> not mafia (godfather immunity)
Strike Wolf blocks Violet
Dazza protects Commander9 (actually ends up protecting Chapcrap)
Djfireside protects Chapcrap (actually ends up protecting Commander)
Hippo kills Commander (actually ends up killing Chapcrap) -> kill fails due to Dazza's protection (Dazza took the bullet and lost his 1-shot bulletproof)
Jgordon kills DoomYoshi
Ghostly kills Drunkmonkey
Drake poisons Chapcrap (actually ends up poisoning Commander)

N4

Eldario swaps Ghostly and Codierose
Alt/Sniper swaps Edocsil and Violet
Strike Wolf protects Ghostly (actually ends up protecting Codierose)
Dazza protects Strike Wolf
Djfireside protects Strike Wolf
Hippo kills Drake -> Drake loses 1 of his 2 bulletproof shots
Chapcrap kills Dukasaur
Ghostly kills Djfireside
Drake poisons Dukasaur

N5

Eldario swaps Ghostly and Dazza
Alt/Sniper swaps Edocsil and Strike Wolf
Strike Wolf does not act
Dazza protects Strike Wolf (ends up protecting Edocsil)
Hippo kills Edocsil (ends up killing Strike Wolf)
Chapcrap kills Edocsil (ends up killing Strike Wolf)
Ghostly kills Edocsil (ends up killing Strike Wolf)
Drake poisons Ghostly (ends up poisoning Dazza)

D6

Drake kills all poisoned players (Edocsil and Dazza)

N6

Alt/Sniper swaps Sniper and Hippo
Hippo kills Drake -> Drake loses his final bulletproof
Sniper kills MoB Deadly
Ghostly kills Drake
Drake poisons Chap

N7

Alt/Sniper swaps Chapcrap and Ghostly
Sniper kills Chapcrap (actually ends up killing Ghostly) -> kill fails due to Sephiroth's bulletproof
Ghostly kills Chap (actually ends up killing Ghostly)

A little on flavour

Cait Sith was doublevoter because his weapon is a megaphone.

Vincent was a JOAT because he could transform into 4 different monsters.

Both Clouds were bulletproof because he is strong.

Cid as a busdriver and Aerith as a doctor are obvious calls.

Jessie, Biggs and Wedge were VTs because they were not important and died soon.

Dyne was the vigilante and I enjoyed when people thought it was Barret doing the killing. That actually happened in the videogame when Barret was accused of murdering someone that Dyne had actually killed.

Palmer was the mafia busdriver because he was involved with Cid in the story.

I was just thinking... My third party victories are actually comparable to my victories as town or mafia, ha. Personally, I think I like being a third party more than town or mafia. I think I'd take Survivor over town power role if given the choice. I just think they're more fun to play, and I think there are more ways you can play them, and you can take on a more flexible strategy.

Just my opinion. Felt like a mini-rant

-Sully

Victor Sullivan wrote:I was just thinking... My third party victories are actually comparable to my victories as town or mafia, ha. Personally, I think I like being a third party more than town or mafia. I think I'd take Survivor over town power role if given the choice. I just think they're more fun to play, and I think there are more ways you can play them, and you can take on a more flexible strategy.

Just my opinion. Felt like a mini-rant

-Sully

You did well in recruiting at the end as you were my next target!!