Page 5 of 21
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 3:27 pm
by MeDeFe
wercool wrote:wercool wrote:players bolded if firm
1.vodean
2.gregwolf121
3.Rainbow Eater
4.cubfanpgh
5.MeDeFe
6.cena-rules
7. Khiva
8.spiesr
9. captainwalrus
10.naxus
11.UTAlan
12.Thezzaruz
13.vodean
14./
15.edocsil
16.duday53
17.Mr. Squirrel
18.safariguy5
thats who's posted
You've still got vodean on that list twice.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 3:36 pm
by naxus
MeDeFe wrote:wercool wrote:wercool wrote:players bolded if firm
1.vodean
2.gregwolf121
3.Rainbow Eater
4.cubfanpgh
5.MeDeFe
6.cena-rules
7. Khiva
8.spiesr
9. captainwalrus
10.naxus
11.UTAlan
12.Thezzaruz
13.vodean
14./
15.edocsil
16.duday53
17.Mr. Squirrel
18.safariguy5
thats who's posted
You've still got vodean on that list twice.
Plus ive firmed and posted still....
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 6:03 pm
by safariguy5
Well we identified 1 lurker at least, twice at that.
unvote vote vodean
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 6:47 pm
by /
I think it's a waste of time and lynches to focus all our attention on people who may never actually contribute any thing good or bad.
They are equally likely to be scum or town, but if we keep lynching them not only does it not provide any evidence, but it gives scum free kills each night. Prod them, then either replace, or if that's not an option I would prefer they be mod-killed, too many games are dying like this, even a random mass kill is better if it saves the game.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 7:13 pm
by Khiva
Yes, I think everyones who is playing is here. The only lurker is UTAlan who presumbably can't post and is are ??? Anyway Unvote Mr. Squirrel
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 8:51 pm
by wercool
wercool wrote:vote count
cena-rules 5 (spiesr naxus mr squirrel edocsil ???)
edocsil 1 (gregwolf)
naxus 1 (cena-rules)
duday 1 (/)
mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus )
vodean 1 (safariguy5)
17 alive 9 to lynch
6 days till lynch
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Sun Jun 06, 2010 10:32 pm
by edocsil
Yo, vote counts are not accurate, squirrel has at least 3 votes against.....
That being said, squirrel doesn't strike me as scum, just bored, like all of us.
Questions
Khiva, how do we know uta cant post? i read the logs but didnt find anything
Wercool, will you modkill/replace nonfirms? otherwise this game is going to fall apart, the only way to prevent it is to remove by your hand or ours.
Leaving my vote as it is, cant lay my finger on it but cena feels scummy, and his explanation was no explanation. However, cant really say i would have acted any differently if the vote was against me.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 9:45 am
by wercool
he had 1 and medefe voted for him then kniva unvoted him. he has two votes.
vote count
cena-rules 5 (spiesr naxus mr squirrel edocsil ???)
edocsil 1 (gregwolf)
naxus 1 (cena-rules)
duday 1 (/)
mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus medefe)
vodean 1 (safariguy5)
17 alive 9 to lynch
6 days till lynch[/quote][/quote]
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 12:21 pm
by edocsil
Khiva! Stop editing your posts!!
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 2:24 pm
by Khiva
Pretty impressive how I slipped in that bit about it in the previous post as well no?
Anyway, I was just speculating about Alan since he is the only active who has confirmed but not posted, and Duday53 was last active at Fri Jun 04, 2010 10:55 pm but the mystery voter changed from Spiesr to Cena in between.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Mon Jun 07, 2010 5:11 pm
by spiesr
Khiva wrote:Anyway, I was just speculating about Alan since he is the only active who has confirmed but not posted, and Duday53 was last active at Fri Jun 04, 2010 10:55 pm but the mystery voter changed from Spiesr to Cena in between.
There is no reason to assume that the ??? vote is cast by someone who can't post. A role the couldn't post but could do mystery votes would be pretty stupid in my opinion. It more likely belongs to someone who did post during that time...
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 2:27 pm
by duday53
To be honest this is probably the worst month of the year for me to be in a mafia game because of my upcoming exams and summative assignments.
But I never even noticed that ??? voter before :p
Anyways, I might as well vote cena because it will push the game forward and hopefully produce more activity (I'm a hypocrite.. I know).
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 3:23 pm
by wercool
wercool wrote:vote count
cena-rules 6 (spiesr naxus mr squirrel edocsil ??? duday)
edocsil 1 (gregwolf)
naxus 1 (cena-rules)
duday 1 (/)
mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus medefe)
vodean 1 (safariguy5)
17 alive 9 to lynch
4 days till lynch
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:35 pm
by spiesr
wercool wrote:mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus medefe)
Either change the number, change the number of names, or explain why one of these votes doesn't count.
Also, with like four days left I suggest that cena offer some sort of compelling reason for people to unvote him or he will likely be lynched simply for being the only one with enough votes to be lynched.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 7:53 pm
by duday53
spiesr wrote:wercool wrote:mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus medefe)
Either change the number, change the number of names, or explain why one of these votes doesn't count.
Also, with like four days left I suggest that cena offer some sort of compelling reason for people to unvote him or he will likely be lynched simply for being the only one with enough votes to be lynched.
Yep, role claim time..
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 8:20 pm
by edocsil
duday53 wrote:spiesr wrote:wercool wrote:mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus medefe)
Either change the number, change the number of names, or explain why one of these votes doesn't count.
Also, with like four days left I suggest that cena offer some sort of compelling reason for people to unvote him or he will likely be lynched simply for being the only one with enough votes to be lynched.
Yep, role claim time..
QFT
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Tue Jun 08, 2010 9:55 pm
by wercool
spiesr wrote:wercool wrote:mr squirrel 1 (thezzarus medefe)
Either change the number, change the number of names, or explain why one of these votes doesn't count.
Also, with like four days left I suggest that cena offer some sort of compelling reason for people to unvote him or he will likely be lynched simply for being the only one with enough votes to be lynched.
yes that should be a two i just missed it.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 3:57 am
by cena-rules
Im a third party survivor. Im a dwarf (which was spelt wrong in my role pm) I am also masoned with 2 people who are dwarves like me. I can also pm another player, but as of yet have not been told their role
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:03 am
by edocsil
Unvote Cena, I believe him.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:07 am
by Khiva
Hahaha yeah I believe him i'm a farmer with the same set up but only the role I don't know is active
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:17 am
by edocsil
That was hasty, I want to see what others have to say about this before I change my vote, that being said I believe that cena is telling the truth, or something very near to it. The only only thing I would question is the third party survivor. I believe the Empire is Town, Varden Mafia, Elves side certainly with the Varden. Dwarves could POSSIBLY be third party survivor, but I would say say it is extremely unlikely, especially if Wercool is following the storyline of the Inheritance cycle at all.
In this case I would say that the chances are slim that cena is pro town
Revote Cena
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:20 am
by edocsil
Looks like there are many small cells of 4 set up with three people on the same "team" and one unknown.
Khiva, I am in a similar boat and it is driving me crazy....
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 10:36 am
by wercool
utter chaos. i like it!
vote countcena-rules 6 (spiesr naxus mr squirrel
??? duday edocsil)
edocsil 1 (gregwolf)
naxus 1 (cena-rules)
duday 1 (/)
mr squirrel 2 (thezzarus medefe)
vodean 1 (safariguy5)
17 alive 9 to lynch
3 days till lynch
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 11:22 am
by cena-rules
edocsil wrote:That was hasty, I want to see what others have to say about this before I change my vote, that being said I believe that cena is telling the truth, or something very near to it. The only only thing I would question is the third party survivor. I believe the Empire is Town, Varden Mafia, Elves side certainly with the Varden. Dwarves could POSSIBLY be third party survivor, but I would say say it is extremely unlikely, especially if Wercool is following the storyline of the Inheritance cycle at all.
In this case I would say that the chances are slim that cena is pro town
Revote Cena
I think if you will look, I didnt claim pro town. I claimed survivor, which is as always a third party role. Secondly, assuming I was mafia, how would I know so much about how these groups work? Thirdly, If I was fakeclaiming, would I go for something quite as sucky as survivor.
Re: eragon game thread. day one start
Posted: Wed Jun 09, 2010 12:20 pm
by Mr. Squirrel
edocsil wrote:That was hasty, I want to see what others have to say about this before I change my vote, that being said I believe that cena is telling the truth, or something very near to it. The only only thing I would question is the third party survivor. I believe the Empire is Town, Varden Mafia, Elves side certainly with the Varden. Dwarves could POSSIBLY be third party survivor, but I would say say it is extremely unlikely, especially if Wercool is following the storyline of the Inheritance cycle at all.
In this case I would say that the chances are slim that cena is pro town
Revote Cena
Actually, if anything, the elves would be the survivors not the dwarves. The dwarves fought alongside the varden in the first book. The elves didnt start fighting the empire until later in the series.
However I disagree with you. I think cena is more likely than not telling the truth. It seems this game is full of mason groups. very confusing. However this may be a game-breaking mechanic. If the game is full of masons, and we all claim our mason partners, then one group will obviously be scum. finding one scum member, we find all the scum. hmmmm, i'll have to think over the viability of this a bit more...
unvote