Judgement Day- Game Over, MAFIA WIN!!!

[freezie]

EBWOP

Not to mention, Melchior IS a biblical or religious figure, and he WAS a seer, and how the hell would I have pulled that out of my ass so fast once you decided to try and attack me...?

Can anyone counter-claim me? Because, if so, then all I can say is my role sucked.

If you are Melchior, shouldn't there be Gaspar and Balthazar out there? They could confirm your claim.

As for the counter-claiming, I think that there is more characters in the Bible then there are roles here.

EXCELLENT POINT!

Are the other wise men here????

Looks like they are on vacation..

I call for B.S of your claim. Doesn't make sence, and I clearly says I am not beleiving you.

Wise as you are, knowing ( like you seem to input ) that you would be role-blocked claiming you're seeking the antichrist, why did you tell us to give you a night to figure it out?

[F1fth]

Hold on guys, you're doing to AD what was done to LSU...

I'm inclined to believe AD, not only because of the name of the role he described, but also the conditions of the role. In nature, it sounds quite similar to some roles that have already been revealed, and I don't think we should be hasty in judging him.

And ask yourself: if he were scum, why in the hell would he say he could figure out who the antichrist/Devil is and then randomly pull some BS story out for why he couldn't. On day 2 no less! I know AD is a better player than that, which leads me to believe that he's being truthful.

Plus, he didn't lie, which was the basis of your vote, Ga.

[Koesen]

I'm inclined to believe AD, not only because of the name of the role he described

Would it be farfetched to draw the conclusion that you are another Wise Man?

I'm not sure if the above question is in town's best interest, so feel free to ignore it, but I'm trying to weigh several bits of circumstantial evidence here.

[Koesen]

Oh, wait a minute... Name of the role, not person.

[Talapus]

About time this day started back up! Anyway, I don't totally buy AD's claim, but if it's true, then he can't really hurt us. Someone should check him out tonight and let us know what they found. Not the best night, but I'm glad to see only one death happened. As for the counterclaims....Ha, goodluck. I'm not too sure we will be able to trust anybodies roleclaim because like it was said before, there are so many characters that could be in this game it would be hard to prove or disprove with a counterclaim.

On a final note, I'd like to congradulate Mandy with once again pulling some of the most random theories out of his ass and trying to bring reason to utter chaos... ! Seriously dude, you out do yourself almost every game. So, bravo...

[Koesen]

On a final note, I'd like to congradulate Mandy with once again pulling some of the most random theories out of his ass and trying to bring reason to utter chaos... ! Seriously dude, you out do yourself almost every game. So, bravo...

I wonder if that's the forced cheerfulness of someone who feels he's being driven into a corner...

Although that would mean accepting Mandy's wild theories, which is hard to do if you want to be able to look at yourself in the mirror again the next day

[Talapus]

On a final note, I'd like to congradulate Mandy with once again pulling some of the most random theories out of his ass and trying to bring reason to utter chaos... ! Seriously dude, you out do yourself almost every game. So, bravo...

I wonder if that's the forced cheerfulness of someone who feels he's being driven into a corner...

Although that would mean accepting Mandy's wild theories, which is hard to do if you want to be able to look at yourself in the mirror again the next day :)

I'm sure we are just boosting his self esteem and ego...lol

[Koesen]

Ah, would that be his inspiration?! I've been wondering...

[gimpyThewonder]

I'm not too sure i buy AD's claims either. but i don't want to get the wrong guy again today like what happened yesterday

and to diprove Mandy's theory i will list the following colors, in black:
red, blue, yellow, pink, lavender, aqua, sage, brown

as you can see, no post restrictions. i can also do this: turqoise, fuschia, peach

i can keep going if you want

[Koesen]

Scumtell! That's not turquoise!

[Fircoal]

At the current moment, I believe Mandy's role but I'm not so sure about his suspicions as for AD, I'm not sure whether he is truly good or not. There are some little holes in his arguments like the differences of his claims. They are a bit different, but due to the nature of his claim, I'd rather find someone else, as with the doc and roleblocker gone, we don't need another main powerole lost.

[Sierra_Leon]

I'm all for firth investigating AD, so we can be sure.

[Syzygy]

I really don't but AD's claim.

In addition to some reasons already mentioned is the fact that it doesn't fit in with the story.

This is apocalypse mafia, not the-birth-of-jesus (no offence) mafia.

What do the 3 wise men have to do with the apocalypse?

[Anarkistsdream]

I really don't but AD's claim.

In addition to some reasons already mentioned is the fact that it doesn't fit in with the story.

This is apocalypse mafia, not the-birth-of-jesus (no offence) mafia.

What do the 3 wise men have to do with the apocalypse?

But barnabas and nostradamus make sense?!?!?!

That is the most ignorant thing I have heard in this game so far.

Look, guys... PLEASE, firth, investigate me...

I am totally okay with that. I have nothing to hide, and I am not lying.

[firth4eva]

Sorry AD I already used my investigation. I investigated mandy and for some reason I didn't get my result back .I got a pm from jnd saying "for some reason you don't get the investigation result through".

I have no idea why

[mandalorian2298]

I really don't but AD's claim.

In addition to some reasons already mentioned is the fact that it doesn't fit in with the story.

This is apocalypse mafia, not the-birth-of-jesus (no offence) mafia.

What do the 3 wise men have to do with the apocalypse?

But barnabas and nostradamus make sense?!?!?!

That is the most ignorant thing I have heard in this game so far.

Look, guys... PLEASE, firth, investigate me...

I am totally okay with that. I have nothing to hide, and I am not lying.

Considering that I am Abraham, I am inclined to agree that most if not all characters used for roles come from the past.

I'm not too sure i buy AD's claims either. but i don't want to get the wrong guy again today like what happened yesterday

and to diprove Mandy's theory i will list the following colors, in black:
red, blue, yellow, pink, lavender, aqua, sage, brown

as you can see, no post restrictions. i can also do this: turqoise, fuschia, peach

i can keep going if you want

It is my theory that you only had to post the hint once during the Day 1.

On the other hand, this kind of reaction to one of my more insane theories makes my eyebrow go up. Unvote
vote Gimpy

[ga7]

Unvote Alright, I'm satisfied with that even though other mages claims would have been nice... But as far as I can see the roles don't make any sense between the catholic ones and the biblical ones; so I guess we'll need more time to figure it out.
I somehow doubt there's a day roleblocker so kinda weird Firth... Meh.
Will have to look back at day 1 to check the Mandy mess.

[gimpyThewonder]

very interesting Mandy. I reply w/ a joke to your seld-admited insane theory. and then you vote for me? that makes my eybrows go up then we get no result from you being investigated. interesting, very interseting. not to go all OMGUS but i'm thinking we should be taking a closer look at you

[ga7]

Hmm I just quickly skimmed to read back on Gimpy's posts, not sure about the hint theory but a thought came up to my mind seeing Freezie's weird use of tags with the 'red' word. A god indicated at some point that we should lynch Freezie. At that point, it wouldn't be far fetched to think that he wanted that to _not_ get Freezie lynched using reverse psychology and the obvious fact that no one was too keen on listening to the godly ramblings. I'd like to dig deeper in this, so Vote Freezie
On a side note, Mandy, I think you said you had 2 investigations to find your target. It might not be so unreasonable to consider that it's the only you get after all Ah well I guess we'll find out eventually.

[Koesen]

Another day, another can of madness...

[gimpyThewonder]

re-reading Mandy's original posting about horses of the apocalypse something else stands out. You refer to War as the RED horse. Why? I'm pretty well versed in biblical lore as well as fantasy lit in general and i've never seen the 4 horsemen refered to as being a particular color. I for one just assumed that the horsemen would be War, Famine, Pestilence, and Death. pointing out something like color makes me think that you in fact are one of the horsemen and are trying to get us looking in other directions so we have another bad lynch. how on earth could you know something like that unless you had the benefit of being one?

[mandalorian2298]

re-reading Mandy's original posting about horses of the apocalypse something else stands out. You refer to War as the RED horse. Why? I'm pretty well versed in biblical lore as well as fantasy lit in general and i've never seen the 4 horsemen refered to as being a particular color. I for one just assumed that the horsemen would be War, Famine, Pestilence, and Death. pointing out something like color makes me think that you in fact are one of the horsemen and are trying to get us looking in other directions so we have another bad lynch. how on earth could you know something like that unless you had the benefit of being one?

Wikipedia.

Pestilence = White
War = Red
Famine = Black
Death = Pale

I take this as an admission that you have not been tasked with hunting down a insert color horse. Thus, I see no big harm that would result from you being lynched.

[freezie]

Hmm I just quickly skimmed to read back on Gimpy's posts, not sure about the hint theory but a thought came up to my mind seeing Freezie's weird use of tags with the 'red' word. A god indicated at some point that we should lynch Freezie. At that point, it wouldn't be far fetched to think that he wanted that to _not_ get Freezie lynched using reverse psychology and the obvious fact that no one was too keen on listening to the godly ramblings. I'd like to dig deeper in this, so Vote Freezie
On a side note, Mandy, I think you said you had 2 investigations to find your target. It might not be so unreasonable to consider that it's the only you get after all Ah well I guess we'll find out eventually.

Once again, you all follow blindly one of the gods, without knowing which one is who. Pathetic.

[Koesen]

I take this as an admission that you have not been tasked with hunting down a insert color horse. Thus, I see no big harm that would result from you being lynched.

I'm not making any statements regarding Gimpy's guilt or innocence, but that conclusion is seriously flawed. Or do you think losing the doc last night was 'no big harm' either?

Assuming for the moment that you are telling the truth (which is always hard to determine with you ), I think people like Firth may very well be more useful than you. You can only get one scum result. Surely Firth has a better chance of tracking down the horsemen and whoever else we're dealing with? The same goes for the night cop, if we have one.

[freezie]

I take this as an admission that you have not been tasked with hunting down a insert color horse. Thus, I see no big harm that would result from you being lynched.

But..2 investigations? So, if you are right, you have used up your power? Then it's not like lynching the horses hunters is really that much of bad thing..

And no I am not saying to lynch you