The Asylum Mafia (Fircoal wins!)

[mandalorian2298]

Alright, with cena now talking sanely for once, I'll believe he might have been set up. Unvote.

If it was set up, then it would make more sense to me that the real killer did not vote for cena, so afterwards he could prove his innocence by saying "Look back at the voting records, I didn't vote cena so I'm not scum!". And what does mandy say shortly after tal's death?

I think that Cena is some sort of Village Idiot. You are not geting my vote mister. Speak to the monkey because the face ain't listening.

I know, it's pretty farfetched and not worth a vote, so I'll just FOS mandy. But I'm just not buying into the koesen, jnd or xgs theories, so I'll keep my vote to myself and my eye on mandy for now.

Cena was persistently acting in a suspicius way. I won't vote someone who is acting too suspicius on Day 1, except to avoid a No Lynch (at which point I would vote anyone, save Talapus who is a proven Pro-town). At this point it makes much more sense to lynch Koesen (based on my logic) or (objectivly) to lynch me based on your logic, then to mindlessly bandwagon Cena.

Koesen your argument is good. I guess I missed the fact that you didn't start the 4 gangmembers theory, but were just thinking it over (and I must admit that your conclusion was sound). Unvote

FOS jake,fireedud,neutrino,sierra leon for bandwagoning Cena.

[Talapus]

i do think the mafia is more likely to be the staff because they are the minority but it could be the crazy patients.

but fos on all who voted cena

there was no reason to vote him except for being the normal DUFUS that he is.

but vote xg for that thing about cut. does this mean he is a killing role or some kind of weird role that ends up in himself dying

Ummm, did you even see the role that was posted that I am....I believe the mod said I was town. Also, I think it was made fairly apparent that I'm staff. So why in the world would you even consider me being mafia
?!?

Unvote

Vote - - - firth4eva

Explain yourself.......

[diddle]

i do think the mafia is more likely to be the staff because they are the minority but it could be the crazy patients.

but fos on all who voted cena

there was no reason to vote him except for being the normal DUFUS that he is.

but vote xg for that thing about cut. does this mean he is a killing role or some kind of weird role that ends up in himself dying

Ummm, did you even see the role that was posted that I am....I believe the mod said I was town. Also, I think it was made fairly apparent that I'm staff. So why in the world would you even consider me being mafia
?!?

Unvote

Vote - - - firth4eva

Explain yourself.......

we've discussed the issue with who we think us town and who isn't, although the staff being scum was a possibility, i think the talapus incident has cleared up any queries there, so therefore vote firth

[XGSuperstar]

I agree about Koesie on one thing: even if it's WIFOMing, the odds are higher that someone tried to frame Cena. My main suspicion on the bandwagonners is XG. First he acted like a loonie with a restriction, then all of a sudden that disappears when he needs to accuse Cena. And this post:

I don't have a restriction, I was trying to draw attention for a very specific reason. Also, when I disappeared, it was at 10PM, I have a normal bedtime of 9:30PM, and I just came home from school [about 30 minutes ago].

Sounds awfully scummy to me. He said before that he was a patient, dropping hints, and cutting things. When AD puts some heat on him, he claims he couldn't have done it because of the syringe. This accumulation of scumminess makes me want to Unvote Vote XG

I was cutting MYSELF, never other people. I was dropping hints, that only one person on the staff will understand. AD accused me of killing the doctor and related it to cut, but I was cutting myself, and he was killed by syringe [but his blood was on the walls...]. So it doesn't add up.

but vote xg for that thing about cut. does this mean he is a killing role or some kind of weird role that ends up in himself dying

Someone's a bright boy. Might be almost as bright as me, weep.

Also, I remember firedud bandwagoning on the THIRD vote on me, and then votehopping to Cena...

[fireedud]

I tried reading the last 5 pages I missed, and I don't remeber anything, so I can't post anything relevant, except for, Unvote Vote Firth

[diddle]

talapus' death, suicide maybe




i know its a long shot, but i just though i'd throw it out there

[firth4eva]

huh wtf.well that was my first impression

now that i look back i thought it meant doctor as in your role was doctor. which it is.
i thought it meant that you were town doctor not doctor who worked at the asylum.

but fos fireedud for jumping on the bandwagon so easily

[Koesen]

I know it's Day One, but this Firth bandwagon seems a little over the top to me.

And I don't believe Talapus' death was suicide. No proof, but I just don't believe it. Why would he commit suicide in the tenth or so post on Day One?

[Koesen]

Oops, fastposted. That's what you get when you click reply and then decide to do something else first

[Minister Masket]

How does my remark about the possibility that scum may recruit indicate that I am cult? Minister Masket suggested that there might be four scum. I submitted that four was a low number in a game this size, unless they can recruit and expand their numbers. That is not a slip up or even a vaguely suspicious remark, it makes complete sense.

That makes sense, assuming we got 4 scums. Would Got tonkaed actually have posted the number of scums? That's maybe it's minister that beleives it..
There would also be the possibility of multiple 3rd parties working against the town. I wouldn't be surprised to see many insane people working like that.
Although I fairly beleive minister was reading too much.

Y'wot? Did you actually read what I said?

Patients A, B, C, + D.

4 inmates? Just a thought.

Look, I said Inmates, INMATES. Now you can kindly tell me where I said the inmates were scum.

[Koesen]

Patients A, B, C, + D.

4 inmates? Just a thought.

Look, I said Inmates, INMATES. Now you can kindly tell me where I said the inmates were scum.

Ehm, yes... I kind of misinterpreted that, I guess.

Well, at least you got a nice discussion going

[XGSuperstar]

but fos fireedud for jumping on the bandwagon so easily

I remember him [fireedud] being the third dastardly vote on me in a bandwagon, jumping on Cena repeatedly when I voted him, and then he just now jumped on another bandwagon.

And Firth might have forgotten that little detail, probably. You never know, Firth's analysis was a bit uncalled for, but what can you say, he is most likely another loony, or scum, a scummy loony, the most common of scum.

I remember reading something that most criminals have an IQ of slightly under 100, like maybe 90.

[fireedud]

huh wtf.well that was my first impression

now that i look back i thought it meant doctor as in your role was doctor. which it is.
i thought it meant that you were town doctor not doctor who worked at the asylum.

but fos fireedud for jumping on the bandwagon so easily

That's how I play, especially on the first day. As the days go on, I make more logical calls.

[Minister Masket]

Patients A, B, C, + D.

4 inmates? Just a thought.

Look, I said Inmates, INMATES. Now you can kindly tell me where I said the inmates were scum.

Ehm, yes... I kind of misinterpreted that, I guess.

Well, at least you got a nice discussion going

You've avoided my distaste, for now...
Well now we need a new discussion.
Fireedud, I can't deny I'm not suspicious of you ATM, maybe that will change over time.

[got tonkaed]

early in the afternoon a little vote count to let everyone know where the stand....

mod note* firth your most recent vote does not count because you did not unvote....

Day 1 votes
fireedud 1 (firth4eva,)
cena 6 (minister masket,LSU,xgsuperstar,mtg,jake,neutrino,)
mandy 1 (cena,)
anark 1 (jnd)
jake 1 (kwanton)
jnd 1 (nagerous)
xgsuperstar 1 (ga7)
firth4eva 3 (talapus,diddle,fireedud)



with everyone alive it still takes 14 to lynch....note, you guys are under 48 hours at the time of this post if my math is correct.

[mandalorian2298]

The bunny told me to Vote XGS.

All that 'cut' stuff sound to muvh like 'cough' (in Re-Inquisition ) for my taste.

[XGSuperstar]

The bunny told me to Vote XGS.

All that 'cut' stuff sound to muvh like 'cough' (in Re-Inquisition ) for my taste.

Re-Inquisition mafia, I never played in it, at least I don't think so.

I remember at one point you kinda seemed like you teamed with freezie or something, as was pointed out by someone else, so you might be a scummy and want to lynch me on little evidence, but there is no hard evidence and I vaguely remember the incident.

The cutting means I am emo, that's it, its a clue to my role that only a member of the staff will understand. I am trying to single myself out, isn't it obvious? First I act crazy [its fun though, but under heat I cannot afford to act crazy], and then I slip in a "I will cut myself."

[mandalorian2298]

Only thing that Freezie and I agreed on was that Koesen was suspicius (of which he was later cleared.)

If you are Town, why would you want to 'hint' your role!? That's what scum does. Pro-Town's hide their roles. My vote stands and I am almost ready to play lynching game with you.

[XGSuperstar]

Only thing that Freezie and I agreed on was that Koesen was suspicius (of which he was later cleared.)

If you are Town, why would you want to 'hint' your role!? That's what scum does. Pro-Town's hide their roles. My vote stands and I am almost ready to play lynching game with you.

That's why I said there was no hard evidence.

Also, my role is one that Tonka made up, its a special linked role, where if the link is not completed I die tomorrow. Happy?

[kwanton]

hrm. Just random bandwagons and back and forth banter that amounts to nothing. Pretty norm for day one.

Right now I'm prepared to just kill cena if we get near-deadline. Other than that I have nothing to say except unvote

[XGSuperstar]

hrm. Just random bandwagons and back and forth banter that amounts to nothing. Pretty norm for day one.

Right now I'm prepared to just kill cena if we get near-deadline. Other than that I have nothing to say except unvote

This is an asylum, you are not bloodthirsty enough.

We all like blood, right, blood is tasty [licks blood of the wall, the one where Talapus' blood was written].

WHO WANTS BLOOD!

[jnd94]

I've read up and a few pointers to boot: the cena bandwagon I don't find convincing. It seems that with the talapus kill he was setup by someone, possibly one of the earlier ones on the bandwagon. Few others are acting like idiots (MTG, XGS) I'm just glad MM10 isn't in this game because he spams way too much. Others appear to have post restrictions or just might be acting crazy for the hell of it. I'm gonna throw a vote jnd on the suspicion that he killed talapus. Just because his posts don't sit well like the overstating the obvious after the death "there must be a day sk/vig" almost like he felt implied to comment on the kill but trying to say something mild and quiet. The koesen vote doesn't sit well with me either as I think mandy is pulling something random out of a hat there and I'm suspicious of freezie for following it though I might still be in braveheart mode. Anyways, I'm off to get pissed!

Well, do you have any other input on how this atempt at killing talapus happened? I had 3 ideas, and in my opinion, they are all valid. it is entirely possible there are day roles.

[pancakemix]

Still not sure what's going on here...

All I can tell is that XG is either doing a very bad job at jester or wants us to think he's a jester but is actually scum, or is a jester making us think he's a jester making us think he's scum so we lynch him, etc.

The rest of the game is like reading Huck Finn. You get the gist of it, but aren't quite sure what's going on.

[XGSuperstar]

Still not sure what's going on here...

All I can tell is that XG is either doing a very bad job at jester or wants us to think he's a jester but is actually scum, or is a jester making us think he's a jester making us think he's scum so we lynch him, etc.

The rest of the game is like reading Huck Finn. You get the gist of it, but aren't quite sure what's going on.

I'm getting into the spirit of the game, its fun. Not a jester, I already gave away my role, without the name.

Hmm, Mandy is most definately scummy.

Patients A, B, C, + D.

4 inmates? Just a thought.

A sensible idea, but with 26 players, I expect more scum. Unless they can spread their, eh, world views.

Interesting game. If Talapus was killed by a vig, it has to be either a scummy vig or a really stupid and irresponsible one. I've seen both in previous games, so I can't decide.

Good thing we have a mortician. I hope he sticks around for a while.

Unvote
Vote Koesen on suspicion that he is a cultie.

Votes Koesen for little reason if at all. Koesen did a standard analysis [imagine if he truely WAS a cult, cruel irony ] However, after reading some more, Mandy unvoted after Koesen's reasoning. But then:

The bunny told me to Vote XGS.

All that 'cut' stuff sound to muvh like 'cough' (in Re-Inquisition ) for my taste.

I said I would cut myself, so why is there a bandwagon on me? It does sound scummy that I am hinting, but its more of a made up role kinda hint. Since I gave too much, I will roleclaim.

I'm an insane suicidal patient who will die tomorrow if a certain power role does not heal me from my depression. GOT IT, I WILL NOW PROCEED TO CUT MYSELF!

[XGSuperstar]

so why is there a bandwagon on me?

I thought there was one, but I don't see any suspicion in me saying I will cut myself...