D2 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

[Extreme Ways]

I have Rag as a strong candidate for third party if not Devante. Gut feeling, not much more. Rag's been effective at being not very involved.

Strong candidate vs. gut feeling

If involvement is your (only) parametre, you should probably just do a post count. I'm quite sure I'm in the top three after Loose and halrob.

Your second prod at voting Charle without any reason pinged me heavily . All I know (and poor me if I'm wrong) is that you dont seem like scum.

Care to explain how hjelp plays differently? I'm not too excited to town hjelp, but lack a good reason to scum them.

[Loose Canon]

EW do you have any theories on what Devante could be if Town?

It seems to me we have evidence there are 3 pretty solid town players in Extreme, Charle and Halrob
Therefore it seems to me there are 3 options for D2 currently

1. Lynch Devante as most likely 3P for me anyway
2. Lynch Devon - for me I might not have favoured this D1 had Charle claimed cop then and I don't see more evidence now. The biggest argument for me as to what has changed is the % probabilities by process of elimination have grown on all players.
3. Actually allowing no lynch to happen might be a decent option.

Devon - silence whatever you are, will get you lynched sooner or later.

Devantes defence (counterattack) hasn't been doing it for me, EW has most number of games played experience - what do you think Devante could be if town?

I have no clue. He has just been... so honest, that I dont see resolving him as a priority. My money is on Devon but I'm not voting at the moment because some folk have been trigger happy.

I have Rag as a strong candidate for third party if not Devante. Gut feeling, not much more. Rag's been effective at being not very involved.

I'm not satisfied with "I have no clue".
Cannot believe you said it.

Are you actually the Warden AND 3P I wonder Extreme?

A mafia dies, & warden verifies 2 townies making it seem that 3 townies including himself are hermetically sealed clean.

Wardens wear white coats.

Is Devante actually a townie but in your straightjacket?

[Loose Canon]

Extreme - are you the Warden, with the White Hand, wearing the White Coat?

When night is whole and silver gleams,
Three fates entwine in mortal dreams.

When the White Hand touches the Seeker of Blue,
My Blood of Red shall gleam as true,
And hide with honeyed tongue,
My sins disguised, praises sung.

The White coat shall mend what time defiles,
Yet twist the world with tender wiles.
Beneath the moon, where mirrors lie,
Justice weeps, and truth runs dry.

But should the White Hand grace his side,
My guilt will pale, my stains will hide.

He twists what’s right beneath the night,
His touch makes day from darkest sight.
Yet lies are born where he have stayed.

My cloak is white, I come to heal,
But fate turns false beneath my seal.
I soothe the Seeker’s searching hue —
As Red’s dark deeds appear as new.

I blind the eyes that pierce deceit,
And let the guilty walk the street.
For mercy’s gift, though pure and kind,
Bends the truth and clouds the mind.

Thus spins this game, thus turns the night,
Where none see wrong, and few see right.

[Charle]

@Extreme - OK thanks re Warden - do you get to know if Charle's results are always accurate?

show

I only get to know that if I attempt to detain a cop, the results for that night only cannot be tampered with. The existence of that fact in my role indicates that false results were available, for example by a framer. Maybe there's a miller (==reads as scum to cop, but it actually town. Usually not aware of this himself) too in play.

FP'd by myself, I was meant to copy that previous post into this one.

If Doc saves me, then my result is the opposite. So for now I am certain that EW, Rob and I are town. That leaves us with 6 unconfirmed players of which 3 are probably scum/3p.

[Ragian]

I have Rag as a strong candidate for third party if not Devante. Gut feeling, not much more. Rag's been effective at being not very involved.

Strong candidate vs. gut feeling

If involvement is your (only) parametre, you should probably just do a post count. I'm quite sure I'm in the top three after Loose and halrob.

Your second prod at voting Charle without any reason pinged me heavily . All I know (and poor me if I'm wrong) is that you dont seem like scum.

Care to explain how hjelp plays differently? I'm not too excited to town hjelp, but lack a good reason to scum them.

Why do you quote something completely different from what you're asking me?

First of all, he's Swedish. At some point, they turn on you. Nah, bantering aside, I feel he's been playing differently from last time. I think I wrote that, which I would be able to see if you'd quoted the proper post.

[Ragian]

Oh cock. I missed a line completely. Shouldn't read in the morning. Ignore me bitching about what you've quoted. The quote makes sense with the first bit you wrote, which I missed completely. I'll address that now.

D1, I randomly posted that Strike was scum in order to get things going. D2, I semi randomly picked Charle (could've been hjelp, could've been Darin, could've been Devon although the latter wasn't really present) because I felt they were the ones I had the hardest time reading. I wanted to achieve two things: Get some people off from Devante (I think he's town) and get people's reaction. It's interesting to see who follows blindly, who ignores it, and who takes a more critical approach.

[Loose Canon]

right I'm following my convictions.

As I think Devante s hereto most vocal accuser unvote devante
I at least have a theory how Devante could be town.

Extreme as warden is too powerful - it's an unprecedented supercop role.

Call this a Wild Loose Chase if you like.

vote Extreme Ways

I think he's 3rd party warden

[Ragian]

Why is random guesses at who's the 3rd party your main priority?

[Extreme Ways]

Why is random guesses at who's the 3rd party your main priority?

Loose being Loose.

@ Loose, nowhere in my role description does it describe what I am wearing. A warden can wear many things depending on country of job location and a myriad of other factors.

I guessed Dev's role was linked to mine because I had the 'if you target cop, X happens instead" thing. Felt like Dev could be someone linked with me, but it was also to see how people would react. At the end of the day it's all guesswork.

Why is my role too powerful? I am not a cop, let alone a supercop. I am a jailkeeper with extra effects, including being unable to jailkeep a cop. Call it stronger because the cop's result is accurate, call it weaker because I can't protect the cop. It's definitely not "supercop", if anything it's "superjailkeeper".

[halrob64]

The Loose of Chaos strikes again

[halrob64]

A doc wears a white coat, maybe the doc has a duel role, he/she certainly has access to poisons how does that fit your theories Loose?