D2 of The Reid technique Mafia Game

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 12:59 pm

SoN!c wrote:And also : another Night powerrole is to be won today !

What's this now?

by **SoN!c** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 1:04 pm

Ragian wrote:
SoN!c wrote:And also : another Night powerrole is to be won today !

What's this now?

Same thing as announced D1 (see D1 posts for the small letters how to get it, but its real)

And the winner is / stays anonymous.

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 1:19 pm

I've probably ignored that, too, when scumhunting O:)

by **Extreme Ways** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 2:17 pm

Anyway, I forgot about us having claimed an odd or even night cop.

Which makes all pr claims interesting and weaker, because scum killed outside of not one but two pr claims. Three if you count Halrob, but I feel like counting Dev may be a stretch. Mafia may have more info there.

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 3:12 pm

Did you forget extreme?

Sonic has also said or at least hinted strongly that all roles are pr - have importance . Guess you might have forgot that too.
Are you claiming amnesiac?

If we assume of 9 players remaining 2 are mafia and 1 is 3p that's 6 town/6 potential sources of info.
I'm also assuming the 2 kills last night is abnormal because struggling to see a sk from sonics posts.
But if we instead assume worst case 2 kills on town n2, there's 8 potential sources of info D3.
It does admittedly reduce back to 6 again if we mislynch a town as 3p.

Point is you are a clever and experienced guy- youve got all this figured too I'm sure. I also figure you are not amnesiac. I did have you placed as likely town - still do with lesson learned from last game - probably.
Just a question mark whether with 1 mafia down you might be playing a funny game as mafia rather than a funny game as town this time?

by **Extreme Ways** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 3:14 pm

Loose Canon wrote:Did you forget extreme?

Sonic has also said or at least hinted strongly that all roles are pr - have importance . Guess you might have forgot that too.
Are you claiming amnesiac?

If we assume of 9 players remaining 2 are mafia and 1 is 3p that's 6 town/6 potential sources of info.
I'm also assuming the 2 kills last night is abnormal because struggling to see a sk from sonics posts.
But if we instead assume worst case 2 kills on town n2, there's 8 potential sources of info D3.
It does admittedly reduce back to 6 again if we mislynch a town as 3p.

Point is you are a clever and experienced guy- youve got all this figured too I'm sure. I also figure you are not amnesiac. I did have you placed as likely town - still do with lesson learned from last game - probably.
Just a question mark whether with 1 mafia down you might be playing a funny game as mafia rather than a funny game as town this time?

i am not amnesiac and did forget. I put a roundup of why I didnt think Dev was town aligned and the cop claim was completely absent from it.

I do not think everyone has a power role in this game, but you saying that strongly indicates that you do.

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 3:45 pm

Quoting sonic here "every role matters" & "no useless powers"
I will backtrack a bit - maybe mine isn't that strong.

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 3:52 pm

Could we stop thinking that EW is superhuman? He's a brilliant mafia player, yes, but he's human. Forgetting things happens. I know I do it all the time.

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 3:59 pm

My bad - again - sigh.

I'd forgotten ew is a mere mortal.

by **hjelp** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:20 pm

Kingm wrote:Full claim then: 50% Vanilla Town, 50% Cop, I will not give away if its odd or even day I can investigate, since that will make it really easy to block if scum has a roleblocker.
I also hope that we town have more investigation power than this, but I have a feeling that maybe nobody is 100% vanilla, and everyone at least have some kind of power, that's at least my guess.

And to any other cops, if you have the ability to check me N1, then do so and then have me lynched D2 if I'm lying.

Thinking ...
Kingm stated " ... And to any other cops, if you have the ability to check me N1, then do so and then have me lynched D2 if I'm lying".

- check during N1. Why shall another Cop check during N1? Because Cops investigate during nights (if I recall). => Kingm's claim " ... if its odd or even day I can investigate ..." doesn't make sense. Cops investigate during nights.
=>
Kingm isn't a Cop. Then the question will be - if not a Cop, what RP then?
I think Kingm claim was false and it's up to Devon now.
Kingm also stated "And to any other cops, if you have the ability to check me N1, then do so and then have me lynched D2 if I'm lying"
Maybe that's what Kongming3 did. and then we can lynch Kingm D2 according to Kingm. That will be lynch Devon D2.
Is it to stretch to far?

by **hjelp** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:21 pm

@ Devon
What do you have to say?

by **hjelp** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:49 pm

I will keep my vote on Devante since Devante is a more obvious not townie as I see it.

Regarding Kingm/Devon I was just thinking and giving Devon the opportunity to answer.

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 4:52 pm

Ragian wrote: Ragian » Tue Nov 04, 2025 12:58 pm
The Elevator Killer is a joke Ragian its from an old film called The Man with Two Brains, wise up Bub and get with the program

halrob64 wrote:
Who said he did??

You know people can say facts without being prompted, right? Are you unsteady?

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:04 pm

That doesn't look like a proper use of quoting Halrob.

I know/think it is fluff/provoking in this instance but you/we need to be careful when saying something substantive.

Just saying.

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:16 pm

So lets call it.
hjelp is the dark horse here, cool, collected, says much but nothing really to give anything away. Someone I respect, drives a nice car, wife 2.5 kids maybe or maybe not a player. 60% killer 40% family man.
Charle the Elevator Killer, gets his thrills outside of town, does he drink Duff beer or does he drink Fudd?? Probably retired from active murdering due to his previous life and injuries sustained. A man to be respected.
Loose, spends his time in Lycra counting money but is it clean or dirty?
Ragian, the Clockmaker, the best interrogator known to the security services, not known for a sense of humour. Was a sniper in the army during the cold war.
Devon, will he be the Monday or the Tuesday man? Will he have the powers passed on to him by Kingm or will he have a brain drain and know nothing?
Darin, known to enjoy pulling wings off flies in moments of stress but is that just a fun hobby or does he hide a secret, maybe he wants to run a tea room? Or maybe he has impulses...also an expert on mushrooms..
EW the Sear knows more than he lets on. A person I admire, seems to know stuff.
Me well I'm getting old, I don't go out much, do the school crossing twice a day. Sleep a lot and enjoy watching Traitors.
Sonic, as mad as a box of frogs, likes to wear dresses when making decisions but don't hold that against him, great game player.

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:23 pm

Let's not forget strike.

Maxleod wrote "not strike he's the only one with a functioning brain

Talk about sending an advert to Lecter.

by **halrob64** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:23 pm

Loosen up Loose, the Elevator Killer is dead. Watch the film.
I di forget Devante, the town folk like a good lynching, I did see some folk throw a rope over the large oak in the town square this morning. I also saw Dev going into church, maybe he was making a confession?

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:36 pm

Actually Halrob I can't loosen up.
I can't quite shake your opening post.

Also the surfboarding alien from Mars Attacks makes me wonder whether it's not in your nature to relish a comic baddie role?

by **Ragian** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:37 pm

I have a perfect sense of humour!

by **Loose Canon** on Tue Nov 04, 2025 5:55 pm

Too funny.

Where on earth did you find him.

(Assuming that's not really you Rag)

by **Ragian** on Wed Nov 05, 2025 1:21 am

Loose Canon wrote:Too funny.

Where on earth did you find him.

(Assuming that's not really you Rag)

Giphy. Just searched for awkward laugh...

by **SoN!c** on Wed Nov 05, 2025 2:12 am

Ragian wrote:
Loose Canon wrote:Too funny.

Where on earth did you find him.

(Assuming that's not really you Rag)

Giphy. Just searched for awkward laugh...