WW2 mafia Game thread- TOWN WINS!!!!!!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I'll let Fircoal offer a defense before I cast my vote on him although all 3 of the real experienced players are still getting my eye on them.

[Fircoal]

If I was scum, why would I put myself out in the spotlight, and present evidence that goes against myself too? It wouldn't make sense.

Also you're saying that half the reason I'm thinking he's scum, is because he pushed Dr. dr instead of Geo. Sure, both were scummy, but if he was mafia, who would he likely pick? The non-scum.

As for framing, I've seen games where it has been done. 2 real time games, where I and LSU did it comes to mind. That makes me a bit suspicous of LSU too. Fos: LSU

There is no real reason to lynch me, and it looks like this would be a place where some scum, are going to stick there vote.

[dominationnation]

If I was scum, why would I put myself out in the spotlight, and present evidence that goes against myself too? It wouldn't make sense.

Also you're saying that half the reason I'm thinking he's scum, is because he pushed Dr. dr instead of Geo. Sure, both were scummy, but if he was mafia, who would he likely pick? The non-scum.

As for framing, I've seen games where it has been done. 2 real time games, where I and LSU did it comes to mind. That makes me a bit suspicous of LSU too. Fos: LSU

There is no real reason to lynch me, and it looks like this would be a place where some scum, are going to stick there vote.

yeah I dont think fircol is scum

[LSU Tiger Josh]

If I was scum, why would I put myself out in the spotlight, and present evidence that goes against myself too? It wouldn't make sense.

Also you're saying that half the reason I'm thinking he's scum, is because he pushed Dr. dr instead of Geo. Sure, both were scummy, but if he was mafia, who would he likely pick? The non-scum.

As for framing, I've seen games where it has been done. 2 real time games, where I and LSU did it comes to mind. That makes me a bit suspicous of LSU too. Fos: LSU

There is no real reason to lynch me, and it looks like this would be a place where some scum, are going to stick there vote.

1st statement: The same reason that you killed cola in a rt game as scum when he was the only one accusing you and you blamed someone for framing you.

2nd statement: Yes he would most likely pick the one that was nonscum. I am gonna reread and see what else pancake had to say in regards to drdr and geo.

3rd statement: Yes you and I have both done it, but unfortunately in this game I don't have the power to cause a frame as it would hurt my winning team which is for the town. Maybe next time I will, but this game I haven't done any "framing".

4th statement: Scum are goign to stick their vote wherever they like. Personally I'm not sure on who I want to lynch right now since dr dr was the only other one that i was fairly certain was scum based on their actions. As such, I have no vote out yet as N8te did do a defense that for now I'll accept unless it's at deadline and he is closest to lynch.

[Avron]

Can we get a vote count please?

[Fircoal]

If I was scum, why would I put myself out in the spotlight, and present evidence that goes against myself too? It wouldn't make sense.

Also you're saying that half the reason I'm thinking he's scum, is because he pushed Dr. dr instead of Geo. Sure, both were scummy, but if he was mafia, who would he likely pick? The non-scum.

As for framing, I've seen games where it has been done. 2 real time games, where I and LSU did it comes to mind. That makes me a bit suspicous of LSU too. Fos: LSU

There is no real reason to lynch me, and it looks like this would be a place where some scum, are going to stick there vote.

1st statement: The same reason that you killed cola in a rt game as scum when he was the only one accusing you and you blamed someone for framing you.

2nd statement: Yes he would most likely pick the one that was nonscum. I am gonna reread and see what else pancake had to say in regards to drdr and geo.

3rd statement: Yes you and I have both done it, but unfortunately in this game I don't have the power to cause a frame as it would hurt my winning team which is for the town. Maybe next time I will, but this game I haven't done any "framing".

4th statement: Scum are goign to stick their vote wherever they like. Personally I'm not sure on who I want to lynch right now since dr dr was the only other one that i was fairly certain was scum based on their actions. As such, I have no vote out yet as N8te did do a defense that for now I'll accept unless it's at deadline and he is closest to lynch.

1) Pancake wasn't accusing me, until I brought him out into the spotlight. Don't skim.

3) Town couldn't frame a kill. They can't unless they are the vig. So you point is pointless.

4) n00b scum = Bandwagoners.

[jnd94]

VOTE COUNT

2-pancakemix(Fircoal,nagerous)
3-Fircoal(serbia,Sunstripe,Duday)

WITH 17 ALIVE IT TAKES 9 TO LYNCH!!!
DAY WILL END WEDNESDAY AT 7:00 AM CENTRAL TIME!!!

O BTW, about te throwing stars. Its not because I like ninjas. In fact, I hate them. I love pirates, however, hence my pirate mafia game. I have always been interested in theowing stars, and i guess it just happens to be that it is a japanese weapon and the japanese were part of the Axis. Coincidence.

[Serbia]

Unvote for now.

[pancakemix]

I'm about 50/50 on Fircoal right now. Suspicious with the push, but not enough to FOS. LSU on the other hand is acting a might bit scummy. I've already FOSed him, no need to again.

[jnd94]

BTW, thanks everyone for putting in intelligent thinking and not just bumping and posting shit. The outlook of this game looks a lot better than my previous 2.....

[Sunstripe]

ok I think for now I will

Unvote - Fircoal

until we have sufficent evidence against someone, and I think suspects might be LSU, Dominationnation, and Fircoal. Also what about people who aren't posting much like Spurgistan or Spinwizard and anyone else who isn't posting. That must be a sign of a mafia waiting till night when they talk to other scum.

[Talapus]

VOTE COUNT

2-pancakemix(Fircoal,nagerous)
3-Fircoal(serbia,Sunstripe,Duday)

WITH 17 ALIVE IT TAKES 9 TO LYNCH!!!
DAY WILL END WEDNESDAY AT 7:00 AM CENTRAL TIME!!!

O BTW, about te throwing stars. Its not because I like ninjas. In fact, I hate them. I love pirates, however, hence my pirate mafia game. I have always been interested in theowing stars, and i guess it just happens to be that it is a japanese weapon and the japanese were part of the Axis. Coincidence.

Ok, without giving anything away or ruining the game, will you tell us if there is a kamikaze in this game. It would help to know if we have to be careful of someone being a bomb or not.

If you choose not to answer no worries, I know it's all part of the game. It's just from the quote above it kinda sounds like the Japenese aren't playing a big role in this theme game.

[Serbia]

"News here, get your news here! The Allies are marching close to us! Grab your bags, safety walks!

A fight just happened in a small camp outside of Poland. It include many nazis and different rioting soldiers. The Allies surrounded the encampment with orders ready to storm in and take out everything. But the 20 remaining people didnt want to die, so they made a compromise. If the group could try and find the Nazis out of this group and hand them over to the Allies, the Allies would not storm the encampment. Now the Nazis in there have pretended to be civilians to not be killed, Instead they kill the people at night! watch out, this could get ugly![/b]

Little history... the war in Poland involved Germany (Nazis), Russians, and the defending Poles. The British and French and vowed to help defend Poland, but (and I could be wrong here) I don't believe they ever got troops into the nation before it was overrun (which happened within 30 - 40 days, if I'm not mistaken). So, we're most likely looking at Nazis and Poles (civilians), unless to mix it up, JND also threw in some Commies (Russians). Japanese in Poland wouldn't make much sense historically, but hey, it's JND's game.

[Serbia]

I was thinking of going back and finding someone who isn't posting, and putting a random vote on them. I found Skittles! name, and thought of voting him, until I saw this bit.

vote-skittles!

So now I'm thinking he's safe.

So, who else? I found these two here.

not smart geo. What reason can you offer on us on why we shouldn't vote you dead wtih that many votes already?

I will vote Dr. Doctor just because it seems obvious that he is Mafia now

Vote-Dr. Doctor

P.S. Geo might be mafia too, but there is a tiny bit more evidence for Dr. Doctor

LSU is posting quite a bit. He never did vote for Geo. Sunstripe too. Sunstripe I find more suspicious, simply because he had two posts like this.

Vote - Dr. Doctor

Because Dr. Doctor is almost certainly mafia while geographical might just be a noob, or might be mafia too

This being the second post.

Then there is Spurgistan, who seems to be submarining.

So, for me, the three scummiest right now are LSU, Sunstripe, and Spurgistan (he never voted). So, I will for now FOS LSU and Spurgistan, and VOTE: Sunstripe. Sunstripe, please fill us in.

[Fircoal]

True, but I don't think LSU's post that you quoted is that scummy. It's just him. But the rest of his actions have been scummy.

I argee with you on Sunstripe, I want to here some defense.

[Serbia]

True, but I don't think LSU's post that you quoted is that scummy. It's just him. But the rest of his actions have been scummy.

I argee with you on Sunstripe, I want to here some defense.

You're right. It was more the context surrounding that particular post that made it look scummy, and the fact that he never voted for Geo. But that quote by itself doesn't look bad, no.

[Fircoal]

True, but I don't think LSU's post that you quoted is that scummy. It's just him. But the rest of his actions have been scummy.

I argee with you on Sunstripe, I want to here some defense.

You're right. It was more the context surrounding that particular post that made it look scummy, and the fact that he never voted for Geo. But that quote by itself doesn't look bad, no.

Well did he get a chance to vote?

And did he say anything more about it?

[Serbia]

Fircoal, I went back and found all LSU's posts between the first quote I listed, and the lynch. He had three. (He previously had voted for Spin, btw)

geo you have til around noon tomorrow central time to post why i shouldn't vote you. i highly suggest you do a role claim on why killing you would be bad for the town b/c as of now you sure aren't helping us with voting no lynch. same goes for you dr dr

last time i checked calling for a role claim was also considered a scum tactic

Role claiming for the sake of role claiming is scummy. Role claiming because your neck is on the line isn't. With no role claim,he is a goner for sure, but if he convinces people on why they shouldn't lynch him it would be worth it to the town to know he is important even if he is a knucklehead.

No unvote here, followed by this.

Vote Geo. That lame excuse is pathetic. dr you are next if he turns out to be scum If you somehow decide to actually post a decent reason as to why I shouldn't vote for you I'll unvote, but so far you have only made yourself and dr dr look worse.

The bold is the original quote by LSU, not added by me. So, one can say he forgot, and really meant to vote for Geo, just didn't unvote. Or, perhaps that was strategy? Something to think on.

FINAL VOTE COUNT FOR DAY 1

1-Dr. Doctor (Sunstripe,nagerous,pancakemix)
1-Dominationnation (Dr. Doctor)
1-pncakemix (Fircoal)
1-Spinwizard (LSU Tiger Josh)
11-Geographical (Talapus, XenCobra,Serbia,Avron,duday,dominationnation,Skittles,haoala,Gimpy,Fircoal,Spinwizard)
2-No Lynch (geo, Dr.Dr.)

And I added the final totals just for record.

[Fircoal]

Fircoal, I went back and found all LSU's posts between the first quote I listed, and the lynch. He had three. (He previously had voted for Spin, btw)

geo you have til around noon tomorrow central time to post why i shouldn't vote you. i highly suggest you do a role claim on why killing you would be bad for the town b/c as of now you sure aren't helping us with voting no lynch. same goes for you dr dr

last time i checked calling for a role claim was also considered a scum tactic

Role claiming for the sake of role claiming is scummy. Role claiming because your neck is on the line isn't. With no role claim,he is a goner for sure, but if he convinces people on why they shouldn't lynch him it would be worth it to the town to know he is important even if he is a knucklehead.

No unvote here, followed by this.

Vote Geo. That lame excuse is pathetic. dr you are next if he turns out to be scum If you somehow decide to actually post a decent reason as to why I shouldn't vote for you I'll unvote, but so far you have only made yourself and dr dr look worse.

The bold is the original quote by LSU, not added by me. So, one can say he forgot, and really meant to vote for Geo, just didn't unvote. Or, perhaps that was strategy? Something to think on.

FINAL VOTE COUNT FOR DAY 1

1-Dr. Doctor (Sunstripe,nagerous,pancakemix)
1-Dominationnation (Dr. Doctor)
1-pncakemix (Fircoal)
1-Spinwizard (LSU Tiger Josh)
11-Geographical (Talapus, XenCobra,Serbia,Avron,duday,dominationnation,Skittles,haoala,Gimpy,Fircoal,Spinwizard)
2-No Lynch (geo, Dr.Dr.)

And I added the final totals just for record.

I think he forgot, it happens, but considering it's LSU, maybe he did it on purpose. I think it's a just a mistake on his part.

[Serbia]

Ok, I have a correction.

Vote the good dr dr for the OMGUS vote

Unvote Dr Dr only has 12 posts. I am inclined he probably is just a NOOB

Nice BANDWAGON spin being that I'm not skum nothing else needs to be said other than you are actually bandwagoning without a just cause.

BFOS on Spin

These are the only votes or FOS by LSU before he voted for Geo. Looks to me like it was a mod mistake (unless I'm missing something), and LSU never actually VOTED for spin, just the BFOS. Meaning, the vote against Geo should have counted. So, I'm going to say LSU looks less scummy to me now than Spurgistan and Sunstripe, and my vote stays on Sunstripe.

[Fircoal]

Ok, I have a correction.

Vote the good dr dr for the OMGUS vote

Unvote Dr Dr only has 12 posts. I am inclined he probably is just a NOOB

Nice BANDWAGON spin being that I'm not skum nothing else needs to be said other than you are actually bandwagoning without a just cause.

BFOS on Spin

These are the only votes or FOS by LSU before he voted for Geo. Looks to me like it was a mod mistake (unless I'm missing something), and LSU never actually VOTED for spin, just the BFOS. Meaning, the vote against Geo should have counted. So, I'm going to say LSU looks less scummy to me now than Spurgistan and Sunstripe, and my vote stays on Sunstripe.

though you have to remember how he's acting now.

[Skittles!]

I'm looking at all the votes that didn't go to Geo, and I see Fircoal's name against Pancake and against Geo. I also saw Dr.Dr twice, 1 with no votes and 1 with dominationnation.
Most of the town might of voted for Geo, but still some mafia could of voted for Geo just to seem like they are townies.
I was orignally inclined to FOS avron, because he's the first one to go against Fircoal, and Fos him. He was turning the tables for Pancake, and going against Fircoal.
Sunstripe, nagerous, pancake & LSU all didn't vote for Geo, who was obviously mafia, as we do know now. Duday didn't vote at all, and maybe someone else didn't. I'm not too sure, I'll look back later.

Duday, he knew that Dr.Dr was a townie. He said it himself in the past pages. I'll put a quote up on it later. This is making me suspicious of Duday.

FOS: Duday

P.S. thanks Serbia, for clearing my name.

[Skittles!]

ill vote, but i want him to testify before we lynch him

vote-fircoal

This was a bandwagon, started by Serbia, then followed by Sunstripe.
He didn't state a reason, as before (Look underneath), he said to take our time before we FOS or vote someone. He changed his mind when the bandwagon happened.

did anyone else note that Xencobra was killed by throwing stars? Could this be significant? Perhaps there is a Japanese mafia (Yakuza) as well?

WW2 theme dude, so maybe a Japanese soldier but not a yakuza,

FOS Fircoal

you seem to be trying to frame Pancake and I think it was just bad luck for him, He was just presenting hes reasons about Dr.Dr and he just thought he was scum, no you seem to want people to bandwaggon with you and try to frame him.

True, and Dr. Doctor was almost certainly a mafia (or so we thought). So it makes sense that Pancakemix would vote him.

FOS Fircoal

FOS, FOS, FOS. we gonna vote or just say he is suspicious and not vote but still we have lots of time to figure it out so dont rush.

Just stating my views.

[nagerous]

unvote vote sunstripe


I'm not sure why you are defending pancake so much and now bandwagonning on fircoal with little cause apart from a big to know that your buddy pancake seems safe. You both vote Doctor yesterday and defended Geo. I'm confident that you are scum.

[nagerous]

I screwed up slightly because I did vote geo but then I chose to unvote and vote Doctor purely on the way he was acting. I can't say the same for Sun and Pancake who were happy to push a doctor lynch yet completely ignored geo