[Official] Choose Your Own Mafia - TOWN WINS

by **Streaker** on Tue Sep 29, 2015 3:48 am

Ofcourse I took an opportunity, just not for the reasons you state. The fact that I was not content letting day draw out on a no lynch should speak for me.

Voting back is also normal, since both ptlowe AND tim voted him, and I now saw another opportunity to go back to my biggest scumread (not scumbuddy).

I am now done defending these particular actions of mine, as I believe I have explained them extensively.

by **subtleknifewield** on Tue Sep 29, 2015 3:52 am

Explain it how you like, it still reeks of the scum-trait of opportunistic voting.

by **Marashu** on Tue Sep 29, 2015 4:43 am

FINAL VOTE COUNT:

ptlowe: AoG, Pixar, benga, Sausage, Tim, skw, Streaker
Epi: Mets, madmitch, Wing, End
madmitch: dakky,
AoG: Epi
Mets: ptlowe

ptlowe has been lynched. he was Vanilla Townie.

Night 1 begins. You have 48 hours to submit your night actions. If you are not using your night action, please send a "No action" PM. Day 2 begins Thursday, Oct 1, at 0600CCT.

by **Marashu** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 4:40 am

During the night, the following players die.

Epitaph1 - Town Watcher
WingCmdr Ginkapo - Town Bomb
dakky21 - Vanilla Serial Killer

Day 2 will be 9 days, with a deadline of Saturday, Oct 10, at 1000CCT. With 11 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

Day 2 begins.

by **WingCmdr Ginkapo** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 7:11 am

My work here is done

Good luck town

by **Epitaph1** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 7:15 am

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:My work here is done

Good luck town

Glad I didn't get around to making a case on you. lol

by **benga** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 7:42 am

so dakky targeted wing and mitch killed epi?

or tim killed epi

bit lost here

by ***Pixar*** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 8:42 am

How did so many people die over the night? I take it dakky did get one kill in before he died? And Scum killed another?

by **Streaker** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 8:50 am

benga wrote:so dakky targeted wing and mitch killed epi?

or tim killed epi

bit lost here

*Pixar* wrote:How did so many people die over the night? I take it dakky did get one kill in before he died? And Scum killed another?

We don't know who targeted the bomb, either Epi watched wing and they blew up, or dakky targeted wing and they blew up.

There is the odd case of them both targeting the bomb, but that is very little chance.

Pixar, so many? I'm surprised no more died with the bomb going off. Don't forget, there were 3 factions with a NK. So 3 + bomb + vig would mean 5 kills, and that's if only 1 power role targets bomb at same time.

Tim should tell us who he targeted, if any. Bulletproof and/or doc did their work, but enough speculation.

My biggest scumread is dead (ptlowe), and the duo I had my eyes on is also both dead...
Need to reread before anything else now, if anything the dead town reads should give us a good direction to go in today. I'll analyze them tomorrow.

by **Army of GOD** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 9:21 am

*Pixar* wrote:How did so many people die over the night? I take it dakky did get one kill in before he died? And Scum killed another?

coming into N1 there were 3 factions (2 mafias and 1 sk) with night kills and an alleged vig (Tim claimed and no one counterclaimed, so it's safe to assume at this point that he's the vig I think)

Then it gets weird because you have a jailkeeper, a doctor, a busdriver, a bulletproof, a bomb, etc.

I don't think we can safely say "x targeted y" because there are so many night actions that could be involved

by ***Pixar*** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 9:28 am

is this game not severely scum favored then?

by **Endgame422** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 9:40 am

Hmm.
So dakky went for wing. I think thats they only possible way bomb/SK pop up together like that.
So 1 scum faction killed epi,the other was blocked/saved somehow.
If your doc/RB think carefully about who you targeted.
Epis top scum picks were AoG/mitch.
I dont really like HS or streaker still.
Anyone else have thoughts for who to pressure today?

by **Whatsausage** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 9:52 am

No Pixar, because no scum faction is larger than 2 people. There will be lots of town deaths overall, but scum have to kill almost everyone to win, including the other scum factions.

As for the night (disregarding busdriver) it appears that dakky would have targeted the bomb (WCG) and tim didn't shoot. As for the other two scum factions, I'd say they targeted some combination of epi and dakky (epi may have targeted WCG and ended up killing himself). (I imagine they attempted to use their kills.) Of course it is possible that their kills were stopped in many different ways. If any scum had their kill stopped, they should come forward and say who they targeted and then we could figure out what exactly happened.

Day 1 ended with two town with the most votes, (no real surprise there) but I do think we lynched one of the scummier players. I think that epi flipping town makes mets look town.

FP'd by end

I do think streaker's voting at the end was a little bizarre, as I do think pt was more likely to be lynched even before epi's claim. I can understand his logic though, so I won't call this a clear scumtell (even though I was opposed to getting more claims, and I think this may have contributed to epi's death: a la he had a good town looking claim, so they should off him now), and his switching back made sense with what he had said his reasoning was.

by ***Pixar*** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 9:55 am

Whatsausage wrote: If any scum had their kill stopped, they should come forward and say who they targeted and then we could figure out what exactly happened.

lol I hope this was a joke...

by **madmitch** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 10:04 am

well that was one hell of a night

after rereading the past posts my scum bar is on Hot shot for her remark about voting Benga of because of his bottom position ,granted HS said it was a joke vote bt only after being confronted about it.I think HS got scared and backpaddled out of the light [-X

by **Endgame422** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 10:14 am

benga wrote:so dakky targeted wing and mitch killed epi?

or tim killed epi

bit lost here

This post doesn't seem like your lost.
Why was it mitch who killed epi?

by **Army of GOD** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 10:23 am

*Pixar* wrote:is this game not severely scum favored then?

I'm not sure. I think this is my first game ever with multiple scum factions.

The thing is...they don't know any better than town as to who is scum and who is town. It's unlucky that we lost 2 townies so far, but they could've easily been scum targets.

Endgame422 wrote:Anyone else have thoughts for who to pressure today?

I didn't like mitch from D1 and since ptlowe was my top scum target and well...wasn't scum...mitch moves into that slot now. I'll wait a bit until I put a vote on him to see if anyone else pops up

by **Whatsausage** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 10:30 am

*Pixar* wrote:
Whatsausage wrote: If any scum had their kill stopped, they should come forward and say who they targeted and then we could figure out what exactly happened.

lol I hope this was a joke...

A hope and a prayer, a joke, whatever you want to call it 8-)

Also, a suggestion for the mod: you should send a pm to all in the game to let them know the Day has started.

Army of GOD wrote:
Endgame422 wrote:Anyone else have thoughts for who to pressure today?

I didn't like mitch from D1 and since ptlowe was my top scum target and well...wasn't scum...mitch moves into that slot now. I'll wait a bit until I put a vote on him to see if anyone else pops up

Why wait? No one is just going to pop up out of nowhere, and it takes 6 votes to lynch.

by **madmitch** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 10:54 am

Army of GOD wrote:I feel like Endgame is scummy. He's pushing so hard to try to get out of the joke vote stage when he's the only one that sees any danger. I feel like he's scum or an sk trying too hard to act townie

unvote vote endgame

then you were after ptlowe and now me ,both of us are on the bottom of the list which seems so far town,the top looks like town that got their wanted roles and that leaves the middle for most likely scum, where are you :?:

oh yeah the middle :-s

well let me start this off VOTE AOG $\:D/$

by **Endgame422** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 11:27 am

Also the only living player wing expressed that he thought might be scum is pix.
Not real sure what to make of pix myself but throwing it out there.

by **Army of GOD** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 12:20 pm

madmitch wrote:
Army of GOD wrote:I feel like Endgame is scummy. He's pushing so hard to try to get out of the joke vote stage when he's the only one that sees any danger. I feel like he's scum or an sk trying too hard to act townie

unvote vote endgame

then you were after ptlowe and now me ,both of us are on the bottom of the list which seems so far town,the top looks like town that got their wanted roles and that leaves the middle for most likely scum, where are you oh yeah the middle well let me start this off VOTE AOG $\:D/$

I hope you realize how ridiculous this logic is

ok, let's do it vote madmitch

by **Endgame422** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 12:57 pm

Certainly OMGUS kind of logic.
Out of the 3 unforced VT claims mitch is the only 1 left.
I could go with a mitch lynch but i want to hear from everyone before voting anyone.
Tim what did you decide last night?
Mets,thoughts now that epi has flipped town?

by **HotShot53** on Thu Oct 01, 2015 1:06 pm

Well, both of my scum reads are now dead, and they were both town... sounds about usual for day 1 reads lol.

And now mitch and AoG have decided to fight... I sure hope one of them is scum, because otherwise we could very easily mislynch them, as they are usually both easy mislynch targets for scum. Right now I would be more on AoG's side... as he says, mitch's logic isn't logical, which pretty much makes it a OMGUS vote.

FP by end