mtamburini wrote:You should want to lynch dazza then, also end should be in your sights as well for his comments about confirming people, im pretty sure theres at least one between charm and mudpuppy.
Speaking of charm, does anyone feel like that's the strangest role so far? All the others that we've seen have been standard-ish, and even the odd ones seem to make some sort of in-game sense. But a magic candy that does anything? And you haven't found a use for it yet? For sure there are scum hiding in the VT claims, but I'm half tempted to lynch charm just to test the limits of wacky claims. I don't know if we can afford to, though.
Here's the thing that really weirds me out about Mudpuppy, that I just realized today. Gets a spell that specifically blocks out two spells - a vigi kill and what I believe to be a roleblock. I'm willing to buy that scum has an X-shot vigi kill to get a 2nd night kill, or even that Storr is playing a safe serial killer. But why would scum make up blocking Cruciatus? They would know that it's not poison, and Mud's claim came out after I a)lived through the night, b)reported being struck by it again, and c) cast Protego on sempai and sempai still died. (Cruciatus being rb also makes sense if you consider that the mafia would assume that Pix would have targeted dega again N3, so why would they make that their night kill if they didn't either strong man or roleblock, and strong man is usually 1-shot, so they likely wouldn't have used it up on both dega and sempai) A spell that doesn't stop the night kill but does stop the roleblock might be handy, and with the way that mud's been defending, I'm starting to lean a bit less scum with him.
I'm still torn on madmitch. On the one hand, getting rid of him might actually help the town, because he does more harm than good, and he's been playing fairly scummy even by his own standards of weirdness. On the other hand, the scum vote on him feels, in my opinion, like trying to get in on a fast wagon.
I'm really, really not getting a scum read from aage - sure, a bit of flavour posting, but it seems to be balanced with stuff that happened in-game.
mtam, could you give a really quick reason for why End and dd are on your list?
