Moderator: Community Team
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
StorrZerg wrote:i find no joy in this
charm wrote:Well I was going back and forth between Mitch and mudpuppy until mudpuppy slipped and said...I'm saying I can stop multiple people with the same evil power.
I don't understand why a townie would have an evil power.
degaston wrote:aage wrote:Degaston
This analysis I like the least because Deg gives us two scenarios for each player and then connects a read to it with no particular motivation. His "strongly town"-read on Mudpuppy seems based on the fact that MP believed his claim. His other reads are not substantially supported at all.
It's not just that he believed my claim. It's that he believed both my claim and Pershy's, and made a strong effort to not have either one of us lynched, even though it would have looked very scummy if he had been successful.
You now know that Pershy was town, so MudPuppy's votes could not have been a case of one scum trying to protect two others.
If just MudPuppy and I were scum, then what possible reason could he have had for unvoting Pershy at the last minute to try to create a tie? He could just leave his vote as is, and let aage take the heat for being the vote that pushed Pershy over the edge.
If just MudPuppy was scum, then there is absolutely no reason for him to try to create a tie. If he is successful, then not only will he have prevented a townie lynch, but it would draw a huge amount of attention to him and be very likely to get him lynched on D2.
So whether you believe I'm town or not, there is no logical reason for MudPuppy to vote the way he did except as a potentially suicidal effort to protect what he thought were two high value town roles.
virus90 wrote:and that mud doesnt vote mitch but goes to aage seems like a desperate/angry attempt at aage.
Maxleod wrote:Not strike, he's the only one with a functioning brain.
StorrZerg wrote:Virus90 is town
StorrZerg wrote:And by that, I believe madmitch to be town.
got tonkaed wrote:StorrZerg wrote:Virus90 is town
Why change your mind, you kinda pushed for him over the past few days.
Unvote
Vote madmitch
strike wolf wrote:I dont think so. Marashu I think has been on Mudpuppy since the start more or less.
Screw it. Mudpuppy is town. The fact that Streaker has resorted to flawed flavor arguments to push the lynch and discrediting me to avoid talking about other cases that might cause town to slow down the lynch on Mud is proof enough for me. Mud has also not contradicted himself directly. He clarified a vague statement but that does not make it a contradiction. Aage's argument isnt much better
got tonkaed wrote:StorrZerg wrote:And by that, I believe madmitch to be town.
Why wouldn't we get any info from him about any of the abilities he has if he was town?
StorrZerg wrote:i find no joy in this
StorrZerg wrote:Anyone wanna talk about virus, mafia vote, madmitch situation?
mtamburini wrote:StorrZerg wrote:Anyone wanna talk about virus, mafia vote, madmitch situation?
How about the dazza claim and my reasoning for lynching him?
Endgame422 wrote:HP disarming makes sense to me via expelliarmus. If mtam confirms he disarmed charm/MP on those nights id say it fairly clears them.
StorrZerg wrote:mtamburini wrote:StorrZerg wrote:Anyone wanna talk about virus, mafia vote, madmitch situation?
How about the dazza claim and my reasoning for lynching him?
Ignoring you till you full claim.
got tonkaed wrote:Why don't you just do it? Everyone else has. It is like you are literally trying to pull votes to yourself for being obstinate.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users