[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[mtamburini]

You still wanting to lynch Storr, even though he is one of the main contributors to building cases on D1 this game. There is absolutely zero scuminess in his play,

An unsolicited claim? Thats scummy
Claiming 3rd party survivor, yet almost everyone agrees he isnt giving us the full story? Thats scummy
"Building Cases" is questionable at best. He probably posted 4 pages of role playing that was NOT an actual post restriction.. Thats scummy


I think you have confused quantity with quality.

I also cant keep up with this game. So to me, worst case on being wrong about Storr, is that we lose a 3rd party survivor, but we gain the removal of countless posts that make the game harder to follow.

unvote vote Storr

Facepalms

[StorrZerg]

Ignore him. Lynching him won't prove useful. He basically is claiming no fucks till the game gets smaller.

[virus90]

mudpuppy; was busy with work, can relate to that, but his posts in my opinion have a high chit-chatty level. he "might"be considering looking into hotshot.... either do it or not, this is 50% ... ahh he might be scum, yeah everybody might be scum.
i would consider voting mudpuppy

So far i dont see why not to believe the mtam claim, so lets switch.
as i said in my previous post (see quote above) my 2nd pick would be mudpuppy for reasons now noted by others aswell.
so ill stick to that.
unvote vote mudpuppy

[dazza2008]

Dazza, show me where you actively contributed to both wagons you sheeped. That's what you say, and that's mostly why i'm voting you.
Now, don't say go look yourself because I have.

Agree with Degaston if need be. Still plenty of time before deadline.

Clearly you don't think I added any thought. I can't see the point of trying to convince you. I have better things to do with my time like reading back though all this to see what I think.

[Metsfanmax]

UNVOTE
The bit mtam posted about Voldemort not being vulnerable to night actions while Harry lives is what makes me believe his claim - no one who doesn't know HP would know that, and even people who know HP wouldn't think of it right away (I sure didn't).

I still don't like mtam's play, but I realize it's more about his attitude for me than anything else.

Need to read through again before I revote.

sempai

Next person who talks about my attitude gets my night action used on them

What a childish thing to threaten.

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[dazza2008]

UNVOTE
The bit mtam posted about Voldemort not being vulnerable to night actions while Harry lives is what makes me believe his claim - no one who doesn't know HP would know that, and even people who know HP wouldn't think of it right away (I sure didn't).

I still don't like mtam's play, but I realize it's more about his attitude for me than anything else.

Need to read through again before I revote.

sempai

Next person who talks about my attitude gets my night action used on them

What a childish thing to threaten.

I think he is a child. Got to be. He got upset cos I called his friend names lol

Fastposted

[Epitaph1]

Guys, let's tone down the antagonizing.

[dazza2008]

Had a reread. Never read everything or I would get no sleep tonight but here are my thoughts on everyone. Not strong reads on most but I will post it all.

BG - I agreed and still do with his thoughts on Storr. Seemed strange that he wanted to keep on mtam after he claimed. BG as scum is normally hopeless so I lean town for now but he could be anything.

Storr - Might be what he says. Might be scum. I still think a good lynch but nobody agrees so I needed to move on.

Pix - being pix. Could be scum could be town but I can't pressure him for playing like him. I disagree with his play and have tried lots to explain it to him in our clan forum games.

Got - Seems town as I said before.

Strike - I have no read either way.

Mtam - I'm not allowed to say what i think so i will just say Harry and leave it there.

Mets - No read.

Tal - Replacement. Hard to read. When he posts they seem well thought but they would be if he was town or scum so no read yet.

End - Possibly scummy. At 1 point said he just wants a claim. Made it sound like he didn't care who.

Streaker - Seems town. Has a case on me but i can't hold that against him. People quite often think I am scummy. Maybe I am just a twat.

aage - Seems town as said.

Skill - No idea.

Pershy - Quiet for him. Said he was busy but still very quiet. Said he will catch up and post and never.

Virus - Dunno.

Mitch - Scummy. Laying low most of the game. Skimmed the mtam thing and voted. Seems to be on any case going.

Mud - Maybe scummy. Only a joke vote then no votes. Still posting but never voting. Maybe trying to appear active without comitting to anything.

Deg - Seems town. New player. Posted lots. Seems to be trying hard to figure shit out.

Rage - No read. The only case on him was really that he never read the books or watched the movies. I haven't either.

Semp - Town. Proven role. Ability can be anything but in my opinion it has to be town.

Hotshot - Don't know.

dd - Seemed involved the "forgot" he was playing. I don't know how you can just forget you are playing. Maybe laying low for a bit?

JB - Seems town. Played lots of games with him. He seems to be playing as he does as town.

Charm - No idea.

[pershy]

f**k sake! Get your votes off me. There are only 48hrs left and no reason to vote me apart from the fact that I've been quiet. Hello? How many other people have been quiet?!?!? If I was scum I would have bandwagoned a vote trend by now - but I wanted something to go on unlike some and actually want to believe in my vote and find a decent case which is difficult enough on D1.

Now we are running out of time and like 7 people have voted me so I have to waste time defending myself before we can get anywhere and now I don't think we will b4 the deadline.

I'm Snape alright? Just gonna get that out there. I am a frickin' hero. I am faithful and loyal to Dumbledore. Voldemort killed the woman I loved and I will do my part to bring him down.

Also I have a power similar to what mtam suggested so I wanted to look at him. I want to look at a lot of stuff but still have 10 pages to read and I can't do that right now for rl reasons. I will though. Now is there actually a decent case going? In our forum games BG usually nails scum pretty early and he's adamant about Storr still, so I find that interesting. As I say though - I ain't voting until I'm all caught up and actually believe there is a half decent case.
We need a lynch and we need a good lynch. This is a shit time to vote a quiet person just because when the deadline is so close. Also I will be v active soon enough. More soon.

[degaston]

Pershy, I never had much of a positive reason to vote for you - how could I when you've hardly said anything. But 9 posts in 9 days with nothing of substance doesn't give me much reason not to vote for you, either. There's still a day and 1/2 left, so something could still happen.

So now we have 4 claims - is that enough? Do we go with one of these, or take a crapshoot on someone else who hasn't been active?

I have no idea if these claims are believable, but if they are all telling the truth, then it seems like lynching Storr/Filch is the safest option.

[mtamburini]

UNVOTE
The bit mtam posted about Voldemort not being vulnerable to night actions while Harry lives is what makes me believe his claim - no one who doesn't know HP would know that, and even people who know HP wouldn't think of it right away (I sure didn't).

I still don't like mtam's play, but I realize it's more about his attitude for me than anything else.

Need to read through again before I revote.

sempai

Next person who talks about my attitude gets my night action used on them

What a childish thing to threaten.

Do you expect anything better?
Dont worry though, Storr will come in soon and clarify that Mtam was just joking...

Inputs winking face

[mtamburini]

UNVOTE VOTE DEG

[MudPuppy]

I will go through the leading candidates later today and put a vote out there tonight.

Was hoping to... but still haven't finished reviewing and am too tired to finish tonight. Will try to vote by mid-afternoon tomorrow. Won't be voting any of the 3 claimed town. Storr is still an option but I think there are better ones out there.

[dazza2008]

what is the point in voting Deg at this point in the day? There is not enough time to actually do anything.

All he did was ask a question. Why is it bad for a newer player to ask a question? I think most would.

[Streaker]

Dazza, show me where you actively contributed to both wagons you sheeped. That's what you say, and that's mostly why i'm voting you.
Now, don't say go look yourself because I have.

Agree with Degaston if need be. Still plenty of time before deadline.

Clearly you don't think I added any thought. I can't see the point of trying to convince you. I have better things to do with my time like reading back though all this to see what I think.

This is exactly the answer I was expecting from you. You can't go back and look for an answer because you know that would be pointless. It's basicly a confession to what I am voting you for.
Luckily for you, everyone else is ignoring this.

I'd love to lynch Pershy for that weak post. If you don't want to get voted, then maybe you should consider playing the actual game you signed up for.
We know we are running out of time, and it's because of players like you that we are now facing a difficult lynch situation. No contribution, until you get voted for. Then you can suddenly come out and post? If it wasn't for you claim (and I mean, Snape could in this game flavourwise be a very good fake claim) I'd be already voting for you. But I know you are faithfull to Dumbledore

Now, in any other game you'd be already lynched. Yes we need a lynch and a good one but you did NOTHING to help us with that. Cheesus.

Dazza's reads are interesting. A few I can fully understand and support, but seriously. WHY IS NOBODY VOTING DAZ????

dd's read: not scummy? He said he 'forgot' and now is still not posting.
Charm: no idea? She's had some very interesting posts to form an opinion about.
Virus: same story how can you not have an idea here. Looks like you are soft defending these 2 here.

Come on people, he's even refusing to defend himself...

[Streaker]

what is the point in voting Deg at this point in the day? There is not enough time to actually do anything.

All he did was ask a question. Why is it bad for a newer player to ask a question? I think most would.

How the hell are you defending the scummy list, and getting away with it? The point is to lynch him. It's not about asking a question.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

mtamburini - madmitch, Pixar
Ragian - dd
charm - HotShot, Ragian
pershy - floyd, dazza, degaston, aage, tonkaed
dd- Talapus, Endgame
degaston - metsfan, mtam
dazza - Streaker, Storr
MudPuppy - charm, virus
Storr - BG

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

Deadline Friday, noon Eastern Time.

[aage]

Pershy, I never had much of a positive reason to vote for you - how could I when you've hardly said anything. But 9 posts in 9 days with nothing of substance doesn't give me much reason not to vote for you, either. There's still a day and 1/2 left, so something could still happen.

So now we have 4 claims - is that enough? Do we go with one of these, or take a crapshoot on someone else who hasn't been active?

I have no idea if these claims are believable, but if they are all telling the truth, then it seems like lynching Storr/Filch is the safest option.

unvote vote deg

Safe options are for scum who don't want to get lynched. You're assuming the are all telling the truth, but you still want to lynch them? If Storr is telling the truth, there is no reason to kill him at all - he's not mafia, and not a threat.

[StorrZerg]

unvote
vote deg
going with my town reads on this.
still pondering dazza.

[Epitaph1]

MOD NOTE

To avoid any confusion about what may be claimed, I'm going to resend role pms. They will be color coded--anything in blue may be revealed and anything in red may not.

I'll update the Rules section at the beginning of the thread as well.

[StorrZerg]

Update on my role, I don't have a flipping wand. I can't cast spells.

[Epitaph1]

Rule #2 has been amended:

2. You may only cite/refer to the blue portions of your role pm. Any other part of your role pm may not be referenced. (This rule has been edited since the beginning of the game).

[HotShot53]

Well, since not enough people seem to have agreed that charm has been acting scummy, it seems unlikely she will be pressured or lynched today, so I will unvote

degaston had been my initial case, and his recent posts haven't sounded very towny, so for previous reasons (and so pershy isn't on the lynching block), I will vote degaston

[degaston]

You're assuming the are all telling the truth, but you still want to lynch them?

Either your reading comprehension is not too good, or you're a liar.

I have no idea if these claims are believable.

If Storr is telling the truth, there is no reason to kill him at all - he's not mafia, and not a threat.

This is also a lie. If he is telling the truth, then he will side with whoever will end the game with him alive. If we start lynching townies, then he will quickly become a threat. If you do not know who is telling the truth, then it makes sense to lynch the only one that we know is not town. If you do know who's telling the truth, then you're scum. I see that Storr just OMGUS'ed me because I pointed out that he is the safest option to lynch. I think this shows how quickly he'll turn on anyone he thinks is a threat to his win condition..

But if you want a risky option, then lynch Mtam, because I know he's lying about something:

I can never die in the night because if I do it makes Voldemort vulernarable to night actions...

So which is it, Mtam?
1. You can never die in the night?
2. If you die in the night, Voldemort becomes vulnerable.
They can't both be true.