strike wolf wrote:Yeah sorry. I've been busy trying to keep up with the other game and with limited time over the weekend, I was reading along for the most part but not really able to post much.
As far as what Mtam said regarding his claim being the reason he thought as he did...the logic is a bit sketchy. A role blocker, Doctor and Jailkeeper all being in the same game is not that uncommon in a game this size, especially non-vanilla. A jailkeeper would be a likely addition in a game with two anti-town killers (or even just a mafia/SK and a vig) but doesn't prove any specific kind of killer or if the killers were unrelated.
Frankly, I could see two protective roles in this game after 3 deaths on night 1. I wouldn't even completely rule out 3. Assuming Rishaed is telling the truth though and I strongly feel he is there are probably two not including himself at most. Overall I am leaning slightly towards believing your claim right now and there is the option of testing it with IB. Not a fool proof option but the old you and IB both target player B. Player B dying would not prove that your role is fake but it would look bad for you. Player B living gives reasonable proof that you are telling the truth. The problem would come in with MTam lying and a mafia busdriver existing. If they could clinch end game that way or felt Mtam was screwed regardless than things could fall apart.
What I wanted to know from you Mtam (I stated the apparent knowledge in a few posts one of which you replied in part with your feelings towards Storr) is that early on you made it known that you knew there were 3rd party in the game. I wanted to know how, why and what you knew about third parties in the game.
Strike could you please link that or let us know what page Mtam made that statement about third party.
I have played in games with jailkeeper, doc and blocker so not impossible.
Mtam who did you jail keep night one and why??