[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[aage]

I notice that rule 2 says that you may not discuss anything about your role. Would that include denying that you have a role?

It doesn't say "you may not discuss anything". It's in place to prevent role pm-related 'cheating'. You can claim a name and a power, and surely you can claim that you have a role

[degaston]

I notice that rule 2 says that you may not discuss anything about your role. Would that include denying that you have a role?

It doesn't say "you may not discuss anything". It's in place to prevent role pm-related 'cheating'. You can claim a name and a power, and surely you can claim that you have a role

I was paraphrasing :

2. You may NOT quote your role pm. You may NOT reveal your win condition. You may NOT discuss the flavor of your role pm. You may NOT say how many words are in it, their color, or discuss anything else about your role pm outside of the usual ability, character name, or any items you possess.

Is having a power a "usual ability", or not? If not, then it seems you would not be allowed to claim it.

[got tonkaed]

It would be incredibly hard to play this game if no one could talk about their abilities.

Playing the mod is rather unnecessary here as there has not been any indication from the mod that Storr has done anything wrong.

[Endgame422]

I notice that rule 2 says that you may not discuss anything about your role. Would that include denying that you have a role?

There will likely be lots of claims of roles in the coming days and lots of people denying what role they are.
Which rounds back to my point.
Im not particularly set on mtam as scum but i think pressure needs to be applied to a few folks to force a claim.
Clear some of the fog that clings to the castle this evening.
Plenty of candidates that is for sure.
Unless we have anymore volunteers?

[degaston]

It would be incredibly hard to play this game if no one could talk about their abilities.

Playing the mod is rather unnecessary here as there has not been any indication from the mod that Storr has done anything wrong.

Nobody talked about their roles in my last game, and someone even said that making an unforced claim was scummy, so I didn't know what was allowed. I wasn't saying that Storr had done anything wrong. It appears that he is restricted in what he is allowed to say, and I was asking if that could include being required to deny having a power role, such as day cop.

Does anyone have a logical explanation for Storr's posts?
Is Storr's statement that he's just a squib meant to imply that he has no powers?
Streaker says he thought that this was No Vanilla, but I don't recall seeing that anywhere.

[mtamburini]

How about you explain your point of view on the dude first, and I'll see if I can agree or not to it.
You didn't say anything about him except either him or Storr gets lynched today... I'm not gonna make your case for you.

His interactions about storr have been weird as f*ck, I would out him under the accusation of having too much information defending a townie or soft defending his partner. Regardless of storrzerg alignment I think he's scum and could be with storr, I'm more inined inclined to believe they are not together but this really has been one of the worst openers from storr I have ever seen and the defence of storr from him is not warranted as I'm pretty sure they have no history together.

We'll wait and see how it develops. While his 'interaction' has indeed been weird, so has Storr been weird lol. But I actually honestly believe Storr is under a post restriction, and he IS throwing out his usual D1 accusations all over the place despite his restriction.

I like endgame's post on dd. Another spot filled.

I do not believe storr has a PR and is doing this to get out of getting lynched, storr is not one to troll or joke d1 so thats a load of crap

[mtamburini]

Unvote storrzerg

Seems fair to assume at this point that post restriction isn't likely to be anti-town day 1.

The worst thing Ive ever heard, hes not under a PR hes being a peice of shit and most likely scum

[got tonkaed]

Have you caught up reading or are you just now parsing through? I have backed off from assuming storr is under a pr if that helps.

[mtamburini]

Oh and most importantly VOTE STORR

[mtamburini]

Have you caught up reading or are you just now parsing through? I have backed off from assuming storr is under a pr if that helps.

Passing through, most the the posts are fucking retarded and useless and makes me want to not read a thing

[mtamburini]

Oh and most importantly VOTE STORR

UNVOTE VOTE RAIGAN or whatever the f*ck his name is, Ill just use my ability on storr tonight since I wont be able to get him lynched anyways

[mtamburini]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

[*Pixar*]

I totally forgot I signed up for this lmfao. Looks like its between storr and mtam, I never like day1 with a lynch and doubt it will happen with 24 of us here. I say we let mtam kill storr and let him prove his role to us? Seems logical

[StorrZerg]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.
I labeled you as scum (death eater ) because you are so late to jump on me being weird. You called it out, but didn't hound me till others jumped on me.


Can I please go back to my character? ??
I'm willing to town side, and give reads which I have been.
student = town read. Some people all ready figured me out.

I'd like to point out sempai since I'm out of character . Pushed me for being 3rd party possibly turning mafia latter. He was pushing an easy lynch. That obviously wouldn't show who is scum or not upon the flip. He jumps very quickly on mtamburini when he thinks I could be cop.
He isn't reading people.

As a group we have no idea if character indicates alignment. If it does, filch is obviously 3rd party. Doesn't give a shit about the students. Has been at hogwarts in bad times and good, his loyalties lie in the school because it accepted him as a Squib. Which also means I can't turn into a death eater because I lack magic. based on what I am I think it does indicate, and it means imo mafia have good fake claims. Like Voldemort fake claim could be hairy potter. Hence we need to be lynching people based on their scummy play.

I believe mafia to be death Eaters with fake claims as students. Or it could be no fake claims and alignment isn't indicative by flavor.

[mtamburini]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.
I labeled you as scum (death eater ) because you are so late to jump on me being weird. You called it out, but didn't hound me till others jumped on me.


Can I please go back to my character? ??
I'm willing to town side, and give reads which I have been.
student = town read. Some people all ready figured me out.

I'd like to point out sempai since I'm out of character . Pushed me for being 3rd party possibly turning mafia latter. He was pushing an easy lynch. That obviously wouldn't show who is scum or not upon the flip. He jumps very quickly on mtamburini when he thinks I could be cop.
He isn't reading people.

As a group we have no idea if character indicates alignment. If it does, filch is obviously 3rd party. Doesn't give a shit about the students. Has been at hogwarts in bad times and good, his loyalties lie in the school because it accepted him as a Squib. Which also means I can't turn into a death eater because I lack magic. based on what I am I think it does indicate, and it means imo mafia have good fake claims. Like Voldemort fake claim could be hairy potter. Hence we need to be lynching people based on their scummy play.

I believe mafia to be death Eaters with fake claims as students. Or it could be no fake claims and alignment isn't indicative by flavor.

If this is true then you shall survive in the night good luck

[StorrZerg]

I'll see you tomorrow for your punishment, threatening hogwarts staff!


unvote tambo
vote sempai

[aage]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor

You're third party survivor and you're claiming right off the bat on day one? That deserves a lynch, and I'm totally willing to risk being a dick over it.

[sempaispellcheck]

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess.

3rd party yes, survivor no.

I'd like to point out sempai since I'm out of character . Pushed me for being 3rd party possibly turning mafia latter. He was pushing an easy lynch. That obviously wouldn't show who is scum or not upon the flip. He jumps very quickly on mtamburini when he thinks I could be cop.
He isn't reading people.

I'm going by the flavor because I know HP. I'm pretty new to mafia (this is my 3rd game), so I'm not sure how to read people and am trying to use what little I've been given.
I'm not trying to push lynches - just trying to put pressure on people to get info.

As a group we have no idea if character indicates alignment. If it does, filch is obviously 3rd party. Doesn't give a shit about the students. Has been at hogwarts in bad times and good, his loyalties lie in the school because it accepted him as a Squib. Which also means I can't turn into a death eater because I lack magic.

I've been playing as if character does indicate alignment. Even if Filch can't turn into a death eater, the death eaters could try to use him to get at certain students (Harry, etc.) Filch was all for helping Umbridge, and Umbridge was all too happy to work at the Ministry when Voldemort controlled it. He may not be scum, and he could provide some helpful information, but I'm not sure town should trust him completely - I say he be watched carefully, at the very least.

I believe mafia to be death Eaters with fake claims as students.

Or students who are death eaters in training (Draco Malfoy, etc.) with fakeclaims as other students.

sempai

[StorrZerg]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor

You're third party survivor and you're claiming right off the bat on day one? That deserves a lynch, and I'm totally willing to risk being a dick over it.

only a death eater would know my true intentions, so only a death eater could be a dick.... self proclaimING to know the results. ... I'm finding students, and sniffing out death eaters, yet it blows right by you. I think the bloody barron will want a word with you

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[StorrZerg]

@bg what do you think of the possible death Eaters I've pointed out?

[StorrZerg]

@bg, you threatening the head master to kick me out of hogwarts? What grounds? When have I ever sided with evil? I maybe cruel to the students, but they cause messes, they need to be punished and taught a lesson.

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[mtamburini]

I KNOW YOURE READING THIS AT WORK BETCH YOU DIE TODAY OR TONIGHT CHOOSE STORR

You are so dumb. I've claimed 3rd party survivor

You're third party survivor and you're claiming right off the bat on day one? That deserves a lynch, and I'm totally willing to risk being a dick over it.

If hes not he will die tonight, you should be fousing on finding mafia.

[mtamburini]

Storr says he had no PR yet he posted like this, then he outs himself as 3rd party survivor.

I dont buy it. Seems like a bad play if he is telling the truth OR more realistically a proactive move to make the best of a bad situation (being scum)

Anyways, my vote isnt moving. Storr's got to go

If you think hes scum he will die in the night, sheep my vote instead