Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

by **pancakemix** on Thu May 24, 2007 6:44 pm

OK then. I like my theories.

Vote Selin

by **Incandenza** on Thu May 24, 2007 6:48 pm

pancakemix wrote:Look, I've got a theory!

AK was the Sheriff of Nottingham, right? He may have had a special day power for today, like GT did. And that may have been to unmask one of the contestants. That contestant was, undoubtedly, Selin.

I think we should run with a policy of lynching all liars and Selin dies today. Thoughts?

Normally I would concur, but I still don't feel that this is the right call. Selin got handed to us on a silver platter... doesn't that get your spider-senses tingling?

by **pancakemix** on Thu May 24, 2007 6:54 pm

Incandenza wrote:
pancakemix wrote:Look, I've got a theory!

AK was the Sheriff of Nottingham, right? He may have had a special day power for today, like GT did. And that may have been to unmask one of the contestants. That contestant was, undoubtedly, Selin.

I think we should run with a policy of lynching all liars and Selin dies today. Thoughts?

Normally I would concur, but I still don't feel that this is the right call. Selin got handed to us on a silver platter... doesn't that get your spider-senses tingling?

My theory says he wasn't handed to us. He was unmasked by AK. He lied about his archery skill. Standard policy is lynch all liars.

That's the theory in a nutshell. The point is he lied and townies don't lie, if they're smart.

by **autoload** on Thu May 24, 2007 6:58 pm

AK_iceman wrote:GT, you fucking idiot!

Thanks for not letting me post a defense, or claim. I had 1 goddamn vote on me, and that was from dominationnation who I don't even take seriously... Jesus...

Good luck townies, it'll be a lot harder now that I never had a chance to share my investigations.

I'm guessing he investigated me for attacking him so hard and never really counter attacked me since he got an innocent.

I know a WHOLE lot more just happened, but I just logged in here real quick before work and will weigh in on what all happened later.

Sorry AK, even I said I wasn't 100% sure on anything.

Unvote: Selin
Makes no sense to keep my vote on him now since he's not likely to get lynched now. Who has AK been defending and who has he been attacking? His votes? These may be clues as to who he investigated.

by **Incandenza** on Thu May 24, 2007 6:59 pm

pancakemix wrote:
Incandenza wrote:
pancakemix wrote:Look, I've got a theory!

AK was the Sheriff of Nottingham, right? He may have had a special day power for today, like GT did. And that may have been to unmask one of the contestants. That contestant was, undoubtedly, Selin.

I think we should run with a policy of lynching all liars and Selin dies today. Thoughts?

Normally I would concur, but I still don't feel that this is the right call. Selin got handed to us on a silver platter... doesn't that get your spider-senses tingling?

My theory says he wasn't handed to us. He was unmasked by AK. He lied about his archery skill. Standard policy is lynch all liars.

That's the theory in a nutshell. The point is he lied and townies don't lie, if they're smart.

Ah. And AK unmasked him because (if memory serves) Selin had been doing extremely well up to that point and was but one of two players left. So AK rolled the dice, so to speak.

That's not bad. That's not bad at all. Let me ponder this wisdom for a moment.

by **autoload** on Thu May 24, 2007 7:00 pm

Aegnor wrote:
AK_iceman wrote:Vote-moz

I have a theory on why the night phase lasted so long, and I'm 80% sure I'm correct.

Hmm this has already been discussed, and AK even admitted he was wrong with his theory. On the other hand, do you think he had the chance to investigate MOZ?

FOS MOZ for now

Exactly, I've noticed moz agreeing with me a lot and it is possible AK investigated moz. But with little else to build a case against moz (he never really posted anything scummy) AK might have been reaching for a reason to start a bandwagon on one of his potential guilty investigations.

by **Aimless** on Thu May 24, 2007 7:02 pm

Vote Count!
Aimless - 1 (Selin)
Selin - 5 (willis, XenHu, Colaalone, Aegnor, pancakemix)

Not Voting - 11

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

by **autoload** on Thu May 24, 2007 7:06 pm

pancakemix wrote:
pancakemix wrote:Look, I've got a theory!

AK was the Sheriff of Nottingham, right? He may have had a special day power for today, like GT did. And that may have been to unmask one of the contestants. That contestant was, undoubtedly, Selin.

I think we should run with a policy of lynching all liars and Selin dies today. Thoughts?

My theory says he wasn't handed to us. He was unmasked by AK. He lied about his archery skill. Standard policy is lynch all liars.

That's the theory in a nutshell. The point is he lied and townies don't lie, if they're smart.

pancakemix you might be onto something...

Vote: Selin

by **dominationnation** on Thu May 24, 2007 7:49 pm

I agree with your logic pancake

vote selin

by **red bull** on Thu May 24, 2007 8:59 pm

Aimless wrote:Vote Count!
Aimless - 1 (Selin)
Selin - 5 (willis, XenHu, Colaalone, Aegnor, pancakemix)

Not Voting - 11

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

first of all look who still has a vote on them AIMLESS i think he might be playing and might just be robin hood just thinking thats all

by **for dummies** on Fri May 25, 2007 6:11 am

that would be totally weird. i don't think that can happen. aimless knows everybodys role. it would be like having god on the mafias side. the town would have no chance. i think aimlesss kept that upi as a joke, he isn't really playing.

by **for dummies** on Fri May 25, 2007 6:12 am

oh yeah. Lynch all liars is always the best policy. Vote Selin if he comes up something else then we can always go back re-read and discuss.

by **moz976** on Fri May 25, 2007 6:58 am

I think I'm going to have to agree with pancake. Selin has not been consistent in what he has said and what has happened in the game. I think we will have some good leads for tomorrow after we find out where he stands.

vote selin

by **nagerous** on Fri May 25, 2007 6:59 am

Stop! Its Hammer Time! I personally will wait to see if selin has one last thing to say, maybe a final riddle lol

by **nagerous** on Fri May 25, 2007 7:00 am

too late fastposted and the hammers been dropped

by **autoload** on Fri May 25, 2007 7:02 am

Any words from anybody before the death scene is posted?

by **moz976** on Fri May 25, 2007 7:33 am

Well if he comes up as innocent we should go back and cross reference all the lynches so far and see who comes up.
If he comes up as guilty we should look at who was against lynching him and since he was almost lynched once before we should be able to get something from that.

I also think that we should look at people that AK was reluctant to go after because he might have gotten an innocent reading from them. We should also look at his FOS and when they changed (for example if one day he was FOS someone and then dropped it the next day that could be a sign of an investigation)

That's all I have for now anyone have any comments on that?

by **autoload** on Fri May 25, 2007 8:00 am

moz976 wrote:Well if he comes up as innocent we should go back and cross reference all the lynches so far and see who comes up.
If he comes up as guilty we should look at who was against lynching him and since he was almost lynched once before we should be able to get something from that.

I also think that we should look at people that AK was reluctant to go after because he might have gotten an innocent reading from them. We should also look at his FOS and when they changed (for example if one day he was FOS someone and then dropped it the next day that could be a sign of an investigation)

That's all I have for now anyone have any comments on that?

I think we were thinking the same thing.

Does anybody want to go back and find people that might need prodding? I hope someone can man up and take on the challenge since I posted quite a bit already.

by **Guilty_Biscuit** on Fri May 25, 2007 8:06 am

I'm going to post a bit later, so much has happened and there is so much to check back on. I doubt that selin is scum, bullet-proof survivor sounds about right.

by **moz976** on Fri May 25, 2007 8:26 am

autoload wrote:Does anybody want to go back and find people that might need prodding? I hope someone can man up and take on the challenge since I posted quite a bit already.

I looked through Day 3 and most everyone was posting pretty well. The only exception was Guilty Biscuit and LSU.

LSU said he was going to be out of town in several threads so he has an excuse not to post.

Guilty Biscuit hasn't posted an excuse for not posting.

I would like to examine Xenhu's mason claim tomorrow since AK didn't show up as a mason after he died. Just seems a little strange.

by **Selin** on Fri May 25, 2007 9:00 am

as far as i counted there are 9 votes and i will be lynched. so, you will find out that everything, but everything I wrote was correct. look who attacked me most in their posts knowing that i can't be killed by mafia and decide who to lynch next.

as summary my role: Alan-a dale, minstrel, i can't be killed in night, i have to post in verses to have this protection in night, otherwise protection does not work, all rest is like townie, no option to change sides (as some of you thought) and no skill in archery

my biggest fosses are:

BIG BIG FOS: autoload and moz

don't get mislead by their arguments/voting, then unvoting/ or like in one of the last posts of auto arguing that ak investigated him/moz etc.
again don't believe them easily, both are very good players!

on top of those i posted two more in my earlier posts:

FOS:LSU, dwightschrute

lsu was part of bandwagons on day 1 > scummy
dwight voted me also, but i'm not so sure about him

last word:

i'm happy now not to have to write in verses and good luck townies

.

by **Selin** on Fri May 25, 2007 9:04 am

by the way during day 1 i thought i won' be able to survive day one. it was actually a success for me to live until archery contest, because defending myself in a foreign language in verses is really a nightmare :lol: