Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

[legionnare]

All night actions are now in. i am good to go if everyone is ready.

I will be back from work and ready to go at 11pm Alba time

Thats what i like to see legionaire. confidence.

Yeah confidence...just remember I like my death scenes bloody!

[King Edward 3rd]

@ Legionarre I think your assessment of the players was very good. Your assessment of yourself was the most convincing ( Screams Mafia Scum ) It was a toss up between you & Gabs. who I wanted to check out last night & I guess it should've been you. You seem to be scrambling just like Sirius was doing when he got busted for not reviving anyone. It's funny that you voted for DB just like Sirius did right before he was strung up With that being said I Vote Legionarre

[King Edward 3rd]

oooooh, I knew it! DB4 is one of the mafia! Just in case that Killuminati is actually not a mafia, that he is telling the truth, then we would lose 2 towns by killing him. I would rather pursue another one that I think is mafia. I vote DB4. Cmon people, bring him down!

By the way. My list of those who I think are town:
Gab
ed
joak

My list of those who I think are mafia:
Kill
DB4

The rest I am still unsure.

@ Legionarre Why would Sirius vote for DB4 & put him on a list of scum when he knew who scum was & now you vote for him now when we know He's not scum

[King Edward 3rd]

@ Leg. One other thing why are all the know townies only 99% but yours is 100% are you trying to make yourself believe your a townie & not mafia scum.

[legionnare]

@ Leg. One other thing why are all the know townies only 99% but yours is 100% are you trying to make yourself believe your a townie & not mafia scum.

I'm at 100% because I know I am Town, everyone else is 99% because you can never be 100% right about other players IMO

[legionnare]

oooooh, I knew it! DB4 is one of the mafia! Just in case that Killuminati is actually not a mafia, that he is telling the truth, then we would lose 2 towns by killing him. I would rather pursue another one that I think is mafia. I vote DB4. Cmon people, bring him down!

By the way. My list of those who I think are town:
Gab
ed
joak

My list of those who I think are mafia:
Kill
DB4

The rest I am still unsure.

@ Legionarre Why would Sirius vote for DB4 & put him on a list of scum when he knew who scum was & now you vote for him now when we know He's not scum

A fair point, but consider that he may have been trying to throw people off as who would believe once he was revealed as scum?

[legionnare]

@ Legionarre I think your assessment of the players was very good. Your assessment of yourself was the most convincing ( Screams Mafia Scum ) It was a toss up between you & Gabs. who I wanted to check out last night & I guess it should've been you. You seem to be scrambling just like Sirius was doing when he got busted for not reviving anyone. It's funny that you voted for DB just like Sirius did right before he was strung up With that being said I Vote Legionarre

I ain't scrambling, I'm not trying to obscure opinion, I'm laying everything out as I see it. You should definately have checked me as you would have found me Regular Town.
So you think my assessment is good and you believe the remaining scum is between me Tuffy DB4 and Charm?
Let's say 2 scum left, you have already cast your vote on me and believe DB4 to be Town because both Sirius and I have voted on him - a fair assumption. So that leaves Tuffy and Charm, who do think most likely?

[DB4Christ]

Re: (GON 3rd game)Paranoia. Day 3

Postby King Edward 3rd on Wed Apr 09, 2014 6:55 pm




SiriusCowKing wrote:
oooooh, I knew it! DB4 is one of the mafia! Just in case that Killuminati is actually not a mafia, that he is telling the truth, then we would lose 2 towns by killing him. I would rather pursue another one that I think is mafia. I vote DB4. Cmon people, bring him down!

By the way. My list of those who I think are town:
Gab
ed
joak

My list of those who I think are mafia:
Kill
DB4

The rest I am still unsure.
@ Legionarre Why would Sirius vote for DB4 & put him on a list of scum when he knew who scum was & now you vote for him now when we know He's not scum

I was waiting to see who jumped to wash their hands first, and clear themselves of all that was wrong.....didn't take Leg long! You made a great case for yourself, and I agree whole heartedly Leg! I believe you are the scum who is hiding among the townies. I will go with KE3 on this one. Vote: Legionarre

[legionnare]

Re: (GON 3rd game)Paranoia. Day 3

Postby King Edward 3rd on Wed Apr 09, 2014 6:55 pm




SiriusCowKing wrote:
oooooh, I knew it! DB4 is one of the mafia! Just in case that Killuminati is actually not a mafia, that he is telling the truth, then we would lose 2 towns by killing him. I would rather pursue another one that I think is mafia. I vote DB4. Cmon people, bring him down!

By the way. My list of those who I think are town:
Gab
ed
joak

My list of those who I think are mafia:
Kill
DB4

The rest I am still unsure.
@ Legionarre Why would Sirius vote for DB4 & put him on a list of scum when he knew who scum was & now you vote for him now when we know He's not scum

I was waiting to see who jumped to wash their hands first, and clear themselves of all that was wrong.....didn't take Leg long! You made a great case for yourself, and I agree whole heartedly Leg! I believe you are the scum who is hiding among the townies. I will go with KE3 on this one. Vote: Legionarre

Well it's been fun, you'd think pointing out my errors and putting explanations with them would help but apparently not. Townies make sure you keep an eye on who votes for me and who put's down the hammer, whoever hammer's is certainly Mafia.
So far KE3 and DB4 have voted on me, KE3 is almost certainly the Cop, I still think DB4 is scum.

[TuffyLess]

For what it's worth here's my list
Tuffy - no claim, no vouch - 30%

I claimed already yesterday regular townie - all i have is a vote.
A vote that Ive used twice and killed a SK & Mafia - 100%.

[TuffyLess]

oooooh, I knew it! DB4 is one of the mafia! Just in case that Killuminati is actually not a mafia, that he is telling the truth, then we would lose 2 towns by killing him. I would rather pursue another one that I think is mafia. I vote DB4. Cmon people, bring him down!

By the way. My list of those who I think are town:
Gab
ed
joak

My list of those who I think are mafia:
Kill
DB4

The rest I am still unsure.

@ Legionarre Why would Sirius vote for DB4 & put him on a list of scum when he knew who scum was & now you vote for him now when we know He's not scum

A fair point, but consider that he may have been trying to throw people off as who would believe once he was revealed as scum?

So Sirius mislead us as long as he did; now you want to put faith in his vote before his death Legion?
Quite the cover he developed ... a townie rollblocker imagined to cover for the mafia hitman claiming to be a townie reviver.
In light of, you're voting only for DB4 because of stock you have in Sirius?

Vote Legion

and where the hell is Killum (not just Charm)?

[charm]

Hi Guys! This month is getting quite busy for me at work!

DB4 has been on my watch list since this began. I'm thinking he might be the GodFather considering he is so quiet. Besides GodFather would be so appropriate - I could just see JC laughing at that one!!

Vote DB4

[legionnare]

For what it's worth here's my list
Tuffy - no claim, no vouch - 30%

I claimed already yesterday regular townie - all i have is a vote.
A vote that Ive used twice and killed a SK & Mafia - 100%.

Just because you dropped the hammer on Sirius does not prove you are Town

[legionnare]

For what it's worth here's my list
Tuffy - no claim, no vouch - 30%

I claimed already yesterday regular townie - all i have is a vote.
A vote that Ive used twice and killed a SK & Mafia - 100%.

Just because you dropped the hammer on Sirius does not prove you are Town

And helping to vote the SK doesn't prove your allegiance either

[legionnare]

oooooh, I knew it! DB4 is one of the mafia! Just in case that Killuminati is actually not a mafia, that he is telling the truth, then we would lose 2 towns by killing him. I would rather pursue another one that I think is mafia. I vote DB4. Cmon people, bring him down!

By the way. My list of those who I think are town:
Gab
ed
joak

My list of those who I think are mafia:
Kill
DB4

The rest I am still unsure.

@ Legionarre Why would Sirius vote for DB4 & put him on a list of scum when he knew who scum was & now you vote for him now when we know He's not scum

A fair point, but consider that he may have been trying to throw people off as who would believe once he was revealed as scum?

So Sirius mislead us as long as he did; now you want to put faith in his vote before his death Legion?
Quite the cover he developed ... a townie rollblocker imagined to cover for the mafia hitman claiming to be a townie reviver.
In light of, you're voting only for DB4 because of stock you have in Sirius?

Vote Legion

and where the hell is Killum (not just Charm)?

No I am saying that DB4 is scum precisely because Sirius voted on him, think about it, he was smart enough to have you me and Gab come to his defense, as soon as he realised that he would be lynched, what would you do? Throw a vote on a fellow mafia, then when you're hung and the Town sees you are scum any votes you placed immediately suggest that the person you voted on are Town because we assume that Mafia wouldn't vote on each other. Do you follow?

[Killuminati19]

I was expecting day 4 to start later tonight. I was also expecting to come in here and throw a vote down on Tuffy. This is a jumbled mess.

My top suspects coming into the day were:
1. Tuffy
2. Legion
3. DB4
4. Charm

It looked like we were going to get a quick Sirius lynch on day 3 until Tuffy chimed in. After my claim, Tuffy refused to take his vote off of me when it was looking like the tide was turning against me. Finally, when common sense ruled, Sirius and Tuffy take their vote off. When Sirius still thought he had a chance at survival, he suggested that Tuffy was town. When it was evident that Sirius was done, Tuffy dropped the hammer like the rest of us townies thought it would mean something.

I think Tuffy is mafia. This Legion-DB4 mess is interesting. It could have been Sirius' last stroke of genius to vote DB4. On the other hand, Legion is now saying he kept his vote on me out of spite. That doesn't do us much good when we are just hearing it now, under duress. I don't think I called you an idiot btw, I probably called you a moron though, indirectly. I'm not sure who to believe out of those two yet. That's why I would prefer to go in the direction of what I think is more of a sure thing.

vote Tuffy

[Killuminati19]

Also, Tuffy voted Legion, which makes me suspect DB4.

[crasp]

with 8 in it takes 5 to lynch. Daytime ends Saturday 19th April'


Vote Count
DB4- legionaire, charm
Legionaire- King Ed, DB4, Tuffy
Tuffy- Kill.

legioniare is L-2
still to vote. Joak, Mookie.
Believe mookie is on vacation but has internet access so will be along.

[SiriusCowKing]

The only thing I'm afraid of is there's a role that when the cop checks out that player they look innocent to him.

The possibilities of this would be:
Mafia godfather
Mafia spy

or if you are:
Naive cop
Insane cop


People, could you stop putting yourself at 100% town in your own posts. That's just stating the obvious in the most douchy possible way. Just write the reasons why people should know you are town, not that you indeed are town at 100% chance, lol.

[crasp]

The only thing I'm afraid of is there's a role that when the cop checks out that player they look innocent to him.

The possibilities of this would be:
Mafia godfather
Mafia spy

or if you are:
Naive cop
Insane cop

Mod intervention.
This game was made up of mostly very new or new players. The balance and complexity of the roles were discussed and set up to reflect this. While this does not confirm or deny the existence of any of the above roles please bear this in mind when evaluating the above post.

Dead Players. while i am happy to have harmless comments from beyond the grave please make sure it contains nothing that can influence a game, discredit another players claim or information they receive.

[charm]

The only thing I'm afraid of is there's a role that when the cop checks out that player they look innocent to him.

The possibilities of this would be:
Mafia godfather
Mafia spy

or if you are:
Naive cop
Insane cop


People, could you stop putting yourself at 100% town in your own posts. That's just stating the obvious in the most douchy possible way. Just write the reasons why people should know you are town, not that you indeed are town at 100% chance, lol.

@King Ed - I thought you said you were the cop?? If you're the cop, then why would you not know what kind of cop you are? We all may need to revisit KE3 - he might not be as innocent as he previously stated.

[crasp]

The only thing I'm afraid of is there's a role that when the cop checks out that player they look innocent to him.

The possibilities of this would be:
Mafia godfather
Mafia spy

or if you are:
Naive cop
Insane cop


People, could you stop putting yourself at 100% town in your own posts. That's just stating the obvious in the most douchy possible way. Just write the reasons why people should know you are town, not that you indeed are town at 100% chance, lol.

@King Ed - I thought you said you were the cop?? If you're the cop, then why would you not know what kind of cop you are? We all may need to revisit KE3 - he might not be as innocent as he previously stated.

The reason he would not know charm is because if that post did exist in this game, which it doesent, the person would not know and think all the information he received was true.

[Killuminati19]

The only thing I'm afraid of is there's a role that when the cop checks out that player they look innocent to him.

The possibilities of this would be:
Mafia godfather
Mafia spy

or if you are:
Naive cop
Insane cop


People, could you stop putting yourself at 100% town in your own posts. That's just stating the obvious in the most douchy possible way. Just write the reasons why people should know you are town, not that you indeed are town at 100% chance, lol.

@King Ed - I thought you said you were the cop?? If you're the cop, then why would you not know what kind of cop you are? We all may need to revisit KE3 - he might not be as innocent as he previously stated.

King Ed never questioned what type of cop he is. He questioned whether someone he followed would have the ability to give misleading information. King Ed is a townie. I am a bit surprised the mafia did not go for the cop. I was happy with their decision though. I had no interest in hearing from Gabs today.

FP'd by crasp

[Killuminati19]

And thanks for the note to Sirius, crasp, I was about to say something myself.

[SiriusCowKing]

I only posted every possibilities that would explain how the cop could get a townie result on a mafia member, as ed feared himself. I did not implied any of these are in the game, I just wanted to save time to players searching through the possible roles, and maybe make them learn about the roles at the same time. I do not think that particular post would influance anyone, especially not at this point.