Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

[TheCrown]

just thought of this for archer....

You can also see if lynched townie was defended or attacked by players vehemently... that can also give you a hint on people's agenda.

[H8 AFK]

Just an FYI, I'm going to be in Vegas the next 3 days but will try on be on here as much as I can.

Vegas!!!

The home of the Mob!!?

[DB4Christ]

Would help if you pair would stop flirting while i am counting.
Post count since Scene 1 start.
Players Upt 14/3 since
archer3base (4) 8
Bantam (1) 5
charm (9) 6
DB4Christ (9) 9
Gabsensei (7) 14
jusplay4fun (9) 6
Killuminati19 (5) 18
King Edward 3rd (11) 1
legionnaire (14) 9
mookiemcgee (2) 2
SiriusCowKing (8) 15
TheCrown (17) 24
TuffyLess (6) 2
Joak (6) 11
H8 AFK (7) 1
That is up to this post.

Crasp.....can we get a post count, or at least the 5 players with the fewest plz? I don't know about Legion TC......I do have Charm on my list though. Are you saying you think Charm fits #7 and #8 from your list, and that's why your voting her??

I think based off this....it should be Mook or Bant. Very little activity, which is on TC's list, and no "Good Explanation" for it. IMO What think Ye fellow townies??

[charm]

Well now this is getting to be a lot more fun! Especially since TC is just flat out wrong about me being scummy! Au contraire!

It is so much fun making the master put so much thought into an equation and then when he finds out he is wrong by lynching me, well, I can only I've been busy riding around on the back of Joak's bike, hence my delay in responding.

So for those that are on the fence about me, I give you occum's razor to determine your decision...

TheCrown would have you lynch me based on a bunch of stuff he said I said/did
or
As Sirus points out, just typical teasing from me! And I really have no clue what I'm doing because I'm a noob, but dang I am obviously one smart chick! I even impressed myself.

Regardless of your decision...I will definitely have the last laugh and plan to break the rules by bugging you guys all through out the game. So, it might be better just to keep me around for the fun of it. Besides, I'm the only girl and there will be plenty of chances to burn me at the stake.

[King Edward 3rd]

I've been very busy with work & haven't been able to post as much as I like to. I'm sticking with Mookie He's just to quiet even for a newbie.

[TuffyLess]

Well boys and a girl ... are we lynching or no voting?
I can see the valid aspects of both sides.

With 2 townie claims already, adding a townie lynch to the mix just makes an ugly day for us plus then the night 1 kills to follow.
If we go no lynch (which with the time remaining seems to be the way we're going to go), then we'll be depending heavily on our power roles to discover something useful.

[SiriusCowKing]

3 times she denied me (like Peter ;) ), and I mentioned about having proof and she never came back with anything. She sounded so much like she knew something definite (which I knew would have been false). Then she throws in the words "boobs" and "blonde" and says she is having fun, and these are just all back-peddling words, trying to get you all to think about other things than her lack of showing proof. "OOOPS, he's on to me, better say 'boobs' to distract all the testosterone monkeys about." Just all fishy to me, and if she were a veteran mafia player, I'd be pushing people to vote her, but she's not and I'm not. AND she has said nothing since. Maybe I am harping on this a bit much, but like I said, it seems the scummiest to me.

I don't know, it just sound like noob talk from her part to me.

More thoughts on Charm:

1. Just after mookie "randomly" voted on Sirius, who had previously voted oh him, charm comes in less than an hour and bandwagon votes to get Sirius up to 2 votes. Was she pushing for a quick lynch on Sirius?

I think she was just voting me because I was one of the firsts to vote. This is expected after I randomly vote at the start of the game and I was not surprised. I was trying to stir things up, she got stirred. If there is no action, how will you catch a mafia in a lie?

then later, charm tries to vote for Tuffy AND Bantam.... that's at least 3 votes is a quick time, plus the accusations on me.

She voted bantam and tuffy after I voted on bantam. I think she read my argument and figured it made sense, so she came along. Why she voted tuffy, that I have no idea lol. And why she is now pushing on you, well we already settled the fact that you sound pushy in the mafia game, especially from a noob perspective. So for me it all makes sense.


I guess we will know more about this later on.

[legionnare]

And if DB4 wants to look, Legion talked like crazy the first 4 pages or so of this game.... and is now scarce... anything there DB4?

Sorry haven't been as active as much as I was at first; it's been a hectic week, working everyday, colleagues phoning in sick at the last minute leaving me to run around like a headless chicken to arrange extra staff, caught a chest infection over the weekend and had up to 50 active games since Friday with all the training sessions has left me little energy.

I stick to my guns by saying that jusplay4fun is the scummiest IMO, over-reacted to my vote then constantly trying to throw suspicion onto me and now been silent for awhile as well so I haven't had my sparring partner to respond to.

I think Bantam is definately scum because when the vote started (by me) to get him to contribute more jusplay posted after the 3rd vote 'who's the next bandwagon' or something along those lines but then didn't vote for Bantam. Making Bantam scum by association IMO.

Anyway to move this along to a lynch I'll unvote, Vote Bantam

[archer3base]

just thought of this for archer....

You can also see if lynched townie was defended or attacked by players vehemently... that can also give you a hint on people's agenda.

I think you can see some people's agenda by who they defend... I think scum is more likely to be defended by one of there own in the first round because they are the only ones who know who is on there team. Townies won't know who is on their team so they won't be as likely to defend someone.

I can see your point though... I just think you can gather info without the lynch in the first round.

[Killuminati19]

TC has good points on Charm. I would rather follow up later on. What has bantam done that's suspicious? He said he made himself clear when he did nothing of the sort. He has also been called out and has not shown his face to defend himself. I also am really suspicious of Justplay. He has moved up to my number 2.

[TheCrown]

jusplay does seem aweful quick on the defense and voting when mad... but this is just his history of play repeating itself... it's just "jusplay". I think if it were anyone else, other than Wolfz, I would probably seek a claim.

[jusplay4fun]

what do you want me to say? make a claim? repeat my vote? I am like you, jus seeking information and trying to figure out this game. This is only my second Mafia game

And I sound scummy..?? cos....???

jusplay does seem aweful quick on the defense and voting when mad... but this is just his history of play repeating itself... it's just "jusplay". I think if it were anyone else, other than Wolfz, I would probably seek a claim.

[mookiemcgee]

Sorry, I haven't posted in the last couple days, I've been out of town with only internet access through my phone. I'll post again shortly after I catch up on chat.

[mookiemcgee]

So based on the prod from crasp, I'm now under the impression I must vote for someone and give a reason in the next 24 hours.

I see alot of back and forth (was that flirting crasp? I'm out of practice) between Crown and Charm, but its not clear to me at all which is more believable.

The 1-10 list of most to least scummy tells was helpful to at least give me a basic grasp of what is meant by scummy. However I'm still somewhat confused... I guess I could see either Crown or Charm being accused of #4, #5 or #6 but only one of them and no idea which. So i guess you then go down the list to #9 or #10 and as said that would be Me, Bant or AFK.

If I have to pick one, I guess I shouldn't vote for myself. Do i flip a coin? Do I go with Bant because he's #9 lower on the list then #10 me and AFK? I'll vote Bantam for now and check again in the morning if new info comes to light.

[Gabsensei]

all i have to say is while i was working alot happened xD

there is valid point from most of everyone but i think i will stay with archer till the end and i dont think bantam should be lynch since for what i saw he is ok in my book but IGMEOY

[Bantam]

Well it looks as though I'm the 1 to go - so for the rest of my fellow townies - just take note of all those scum aboard my bandwagon.

I've outlined my position fairly consistently - god gave us two eyes and one mouth for a reason.

No you haven't

Can I suggest you read the posts again then - when i read the arguments they don''t stack up,

It would seem that a number of people wear the rose-coloured glasses when rating their own judgement.

[DB4Christ]

I will lay off Bant, as enough feel he has earned some credibility. I don't like Mook's explanation...sorry Mook. Vote: Mook for severe in-activity

[joak]

Right I suppose I need to vote but have slight voting nerves lol if you have your own ideas and vote for someone not being targeted all you do is raise suspiscion on yourself so its not healthy to be your own person and im not one for going with the flow will read some more posts and vo with my gut instincts I think

[SiriusCowKing]

Why I think bantam is suspicious:

-Veteran yet not talk for a good amount of days. The only way to gather info is to make people talk, and to make them talk is by talking. You should know that.

-When he does talk, he says that the evidence is flimsy at most and will not vote. This is mafia on day 1, of course the evidence is flimsy. But if you don't start suspecting anyone just because they might not be the bad guys, how are you gonna find the bad guys. Using that reasoning I could say that I will not ever vote anyone until a cop found them out and let the mafia win.

-People started voting for you and you didn't react. Trying to fall under the radar again? My bet is that you are waiting for someone to make a mistake in a post and let the town jump on him instead. It could have worked since some other player got a lot of attention too.

[Killuminati19]

Well it looks as though I'm the 1 to go - so for the rest of my fellow townies - just take note of all those scum aboard my bandwagon.

I've outlined my position fairly consistently - god gave us two eyes and one mouth for a reason.

No you haven't

Can I suggest you read the posts again then - when i read the arguments they don''t stack up,

It would seem that a number of people wear the rose-coloured glasses when rating their own judgement.

Why would I go through 22 pages of comments to re-read your two posts?

[crasp]

With 15 in it takes 8 to lynch. Day ends 23.59 CAT. Thursday 20th march. (8pm CC time)

I will lay off Bant, as enough feel he has earned some credibility. I don't like Mook's explanation...sorry Mook. Vote: Mook for severe in-activity

I will give you it this time Db but remember to put unvote in red next time.

Vote.

Charm- TheCrown
Killuminati19- Bantam
Archer- Gabseni (1)
Joak - H8 AFK (1)
Bantam- , charm, sirius Kill, Legionaire, mookie mcghee, (5)
Legionaire- jusplay4fun(1)
Mookie- king Ed , DB (2)

Last few hours and last update before Lynch.For you new guys there are three things that can happen. We reach a majority before deadline in which case we will go straight into night as soon as I acknowledge. We reach deadline and someone has a clear lead in the lynch vote. No votes posted after deadline time will count. Both of these will be signified by a lynch scene. We have a tie break where 2 or more players Tie. In this case we will go into a tie break with only those players involved. No one else can be added. I will allow innocuous posts during night however any game discussion will be dealt with severely.
Can I ask those of you who are allowed to communicate by pm during night to copy me in.[/quote]

[TheCrown]

Just a note from me:

I hate the "leader gets lynched" part of this in mafia. I had never played it that way before, and hate it. It just seems wrong, and it should be that if there is no consensus, then it is a "no lynch" for the day. I think the rules need to change, as the way we play now caters to the lazy people and makes them lazier.

[SiriusCowKing]

Just a note from me:

I hate the "leader gets lynched" part of this in mafia. I had never played it that way before, and hate it. It just seems wrong, and it should be that if there is no consensus, then it is a "no lynch" for the day. I think the rules need to change, as the way we play now caters to the lazy people and makes them lazier. :x

Good point, I will try that next time I mod the game.

[SiriusCowKing]

Just a note from me:

I hate the "leader gets lynched" part of this in mafia. I had never played it that way before, and hate it. It just seems wrong, and it should be that if there is no consensus, then it is a "no lynch" for the day. I think the rules need to change, as the way we play now caters to the lazy people and makes them lazier. :x

You know what, it does give an edge to those who don't want any lynch this way. I think the rule should stay the same but the mod kills to be more aggressive with the inactives. Remember on my game after day 3? I mod killed 2 people and the game has been just crazy active afterward. I should have mod killed after day 2.

[crasp]

Just a note from me:

I hate the "leader gets lynched" part of this in mafia. I had never played it that way before, and hate it. It just seems wrong, and it should be that if there is no consensus, then it is a "no lynch" for the day. I think the rules need to change, as the way we play now caters to the lazy people and makes them lazier.

Think this would be okay with really experienced players. Remember that while people may not be posting they might still be playing e-mail tennis with me.Its not really my place to tell people when to post or what to say although i will help if I can. Not that I would call my self experienced but i think participation has been quite high considering the number of noobs we have. Well looking forward to the next one.