Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

by **crasp** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 1:12 pm

DB4Christ wrote:LOL......how is it on my head? I think all would like to hear from the in-active's! I don't think the Mod should make inferences like that....... But if that's the way you want to look at it....so be it!

That wasnt quite how I meant it. There is currently three inactives worthy of a prod. If i prod and they pull out then it would be unfair on the people already up for lynch. Just over 24 hours to go shit creek and paddle springs to mind.

FP Sirius.

by **crasp** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 1:17 pm

Prods sent, king ed, H8, Mookie.

by **DB4Christ** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 1:24 pm

Thanks for the grammar lesson mate....I'm hillbilly...so it makes for perfect Greek to me! In Greek...two negatives strongly enforce/convey the point being communicated.

Gotcha Crasp.

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 1:41 pm

@ Sirius

show

@ DB4

show

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 1:43 pm

Sorry, I didn't put it, but I was FP'ed by about 6 people...

by **H8 AFK** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 1:58 pm

Geez, silence definitely ISN'T golden on here!

It's been interesting, I've been on here, reading all these posts and deliberately saying nothing.....waiting and waiting...and waiting....and it finally happened....you've started to turn on me with no apparent reason!

I've done everything you've asked, I've claimed and I've told you what I do and I've voted, I've even given you reasons why I voted and for whom.

Finally one of you broke ranks and decided to pick on the quiet one....then the sheep weren't far behind.....

Perhaps I'll go watch one of my favourite movies 'Twelve angry men' and see how Henry Fonda turns it round.....looks like I'm going to need it!

h8afk

by **Gabsensei** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 2:05 pm

TheCrown wrote:Well, looks like H8 will end up getting kicked out of the game if he has lost interest, so maybe it would be better to lynch him because of:

1. He claimed townie rather easily
2. He'll be mod-killed anyways
3. If he is townie, as he claimed, not a big loss
4. Gives us more time to figure out why the others aren't talking so much
5. Keeps us from getting more claims today (I say again, I think we have enough, don't want too much out on the table for the scum to pick through)

So for those:
Unvote, Vote H8

i am not going to vote h8 afk since i think he might not be scum cuz of multiple thing he said i didnt want to say it before i knew for sure and it would've been in day 2 but since you want to ga ahead and lynch him i will tell you this much:

i think he might be a power role and he is not worth lynching since if he is what i think he will die on night 2 for sure

re-read all the role there is only one that is sure to die on night 2 and i think he is that since he talk about his 'job' and night time

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 2:15 pm

How TheCrown sees things (maybe this will clear up some things) as far as someone looking scummy:

In order (pretty much) of most scummy to least scummy
#1 Night action revealed someone scummy
#2 duplicate claim
#3 caught in a lie
#4 wild accusations
#5 hammer vote without consensus
#6 throw off the trail accusations
#7 voting with no reason behind it
#8 over-voting
#9 quiet player
#10 quiet newbie

This is not all-inclusive, I may have forgot a few...but you get my point.

@archer, you may not like lynching townies, as no one does that is town, but think of it this way... if we hit townie on our lynch, there is less places for the scum to hide. I know that kind of sounds backward, but if you have 10 town and 5 scum, it's hard to find scum. If you have 8 town and 5 scum, your chances increase at finding a scum. So, that's another reason it's not as horrible as you may think about accidentally lynching a townie. But, you also have a 33%, or something like that, chance of hitting a scum. Worth it at the beginning.

FP'ed by H8(er) :lol:

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 2:18 pm

Unvote H8, I guess he is playing still. Sorry bud.

@Gab, I'll look into what you posted

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 2:19 pm

H8, you're confusion is making me confused about you. You're soft-claiming something and I prefer more direct posts.

by **Killuminati19** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 2:25 pm

Unvote, vote bantam

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 2:27 pm

@Gab, do you think H8 is a "lightning Rod"? He has mentioned electricity a lot.

Vote Charm, sorry, I got to vote who I think is the scummiest, and Bantam is not it. Charm tried to throw suspicion on me from out of nowhere, to see if it would stick.

by **DB4Christ** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 3:21 pm

H8, if you do have a pro townie power roll, do not be pressured in to claiming further by anyone. You will be the first one targeted by the scum on night one. In my opinion, your as clear for now as Joak by the same merits.....IMO. I think it has come down to Bant, Archer, Charm and Mook. I still think Bant and Kill have made the best arguments, although TC may have something right about Charm....don't know yet. Mook is on the radar, but is newb as well. What say ye-al??

by **SiriusCowKing** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 3:38 pm

TheCrown wrote:@Gab, do you think H8 is a "lightning Rod"? He has mentioned electricity a lot.

Vote Charm, sorry, I got to vote who I think is the scummiest, and Bantam is not it. Charm tried to throw suspicion on me from out of nowhere, to see if it would stick.

I don't think charm is out of her ordinary behavior as she tend to tease a lot. Also, she doesn't know you from mafia, and you seem pushy from new eyes. I think a noob voting for you is expected.

As for AFK, he is still in my suspect list, but it will be clearer on day 2 on his case (like I said on page 11). Whatever the outcome (dead, role reveal, know nothing more) I am pretty sure I can deduce who he is.

by **Killuminati19** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 3:48 pm

@ TC

I'm confused by the Charm vote. Her back and forth has seemed pretty inconsequential to me. Maybe you are testing the waters to see if you can get more people to jump, but I don't think she is seriously on anyone's radar. I would concur with Moo, being a noob last time, I found you highly suspicious.

Why the hesitation to vote Bantam? The guy is mostly silent and what he has said hasn't done him any favors.

by **DB4Christ** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:01 pm

DB4Christ wrote:H8, if you do have a pro townie power roll, do not be pressured in to claiming further by anyone. You will be the first one targeted by the scum on night one. In my opinion, your as clear for now as Joak by the same merits.....IMO. I think it has come down to Bant, Archer, Charm and Mook. I still think Bant and Kill have made the best arguments, although TC may have something right about Charm....don't know yet. Mook is on the radar, but is newb as well. What say ye-al??

Correction > Gab and Kill have made the best arguments.
Vote: Bant

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:13 pm

Killuminati19 wrote:@ TC

I'm confused by the Charm vote. Her back and forth has seemed pretty inconsequential to me. Maybe you are testing the waters to see if you can get more people to jump, but I don't think she is seriously on anyone's radar. I would concur with Moo, being a noob last time, I found you highly suspicious.

Why the hesitation to vote Bantam? The guy is mostly silent and what he has said hasn't done him any favors.

When this happened:

show

And about Bantam, like I have said numerous times, I don't think day 1 quietness is all that bad. Who REALLY has a lot to say? WHAT to say on this hard day?

bantam wrote:I've just spent 10 minutes pondering why everyone wants to hear from me when I'd already posted. I don't feel a particular need to make any other comment at this stage - I was taking stock of the situation and waiting to see what happens.

Please show me what he has said that is suspicious and I'll vote him.

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:20 pm

And if DB4 wants to look, Legion talked like crazy the first 4 pages or so of this game.... and is now scarce... anything there DB4?

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:28 pm

More thoughts on Charm:

1. Just after mookie "randomly" voted on Sirius, who had previously voted oh him, charm comes in less than an hour and bandwagon votes to get Sirius up to 2 votes. Was she pushing for a quick lynch on Sirius?

show

show

then later, charm tries to vote for Tuffy AND Bantam.... that's at least 3 votes is a quick time, plus the accusations on me.

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:41 pm

And twice now I've seen Bantam say something about not wanting more than the 2 claims we got. That is a townie thing to say, IMO.

I"M SORRY ALL, Bantam is just not looking scummy yet. And please refer to my list, as I see Bantam as a #9 right now for day 1:

In order (pretty much) of most scummy to least scummy
#1 Night action revealed someone scummy
#2 duplicate claim
#3 caught in a lie
#4 wild accusations
#5 hammer vote without consensus
#6 throw off the trail accusations
#7 voting with no reason behind it
#8 over-voting
#9 quiet player
#10 quiet newbie

by **DB4Christ** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 4:46 pm

Crasp.....can we get a post count, or at least the 5 players with the fewest plz? I don't know about Legion TC......I do have Charm on my list though. Are you saying you think Charm fits #7 and #8 from your list, and that's why your voting her??

by **TheCrown** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:03 pm

More like #6 & #7, and now #9 too... who knows. I am fine with leaving her alone at this time, and I see no reason to go after Archer or Bantam, that is credible, either.

And mookie may have quit because he doesn't get it yet... but I hope he hangs on and starts to understand more and more.

by **DB4Christ** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:15 pm

Credible no.....but on day 1 with no more to go on, it comes down to suspicions, responses and activity. There seems to be some scattered consensus on at least 6.
Bant, Archer, H8, Mook, Charm and Joak. 4 Newbs, 2 Vets. I know you don't agree, but I do see that you made an argument to Archer regarding the benefit of voting and the resulting positive effects. Not a peep in response.....????

by **crasp** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:40 pm

Would help if you pair would stop flirting while i am counting.
Post count since Scene 1 start.
Players Upt 14/3 since
archer3base (4) 8
Bantam (1) 5
charm (9) 6
DB4Christ (9) 9
Gabsensei (7) 14
jusplay4fun (9) 6
Killuminati19 (5) 18
King Edward 3rd (11) 1
legionnaire (14) 9
mookiemcgee (2) 2
SiriusCowKing (8) 15
TheCrown (17) 24
TuffyLess (6) 2
Joak (6) 11
H8 AFK (7) 1
That is up to this post.

DB4Christ wrote:Crasp.....can we get a post count, or at least the 5 players with the fewest plz? I don't know about Legion TC......I do have Charm on my list though. Are you saying you think Charm fits #7 and #8 from your list, and that's why your voting her??

by **archer3base** on Wed Mar 19, 2014 5:48 pm

DB4Christ wrote:Credible no.....but on day 1 with no more to go on, it comes down to suspicions, responses and activity. There seems to be some scattered consensus on at least 6.
Bant, Archer, H8, Mook, Charm and Joak. 4 Newbs, 2 Vets. I know you don't agree, but I do see that you made an argument to Archer regarding the benefit of voting and the resulting positive effects. Not a peep in response.....????

How often do you expect me to check this thread?...lol. I am at work and posting on my phone. I have said my peace and I don't really get crown's reasoning because the object of the game is to keep the townies alive. While I do agree it is easier to find scum when there are less townies around you still don't want to sacrifice townies when you aren't gaining much from it. I'd rather have better odds on finding scum day 2 than randomly lynching someone day 1. I'm a numbers guy and I think it's beneficial for some night actions to occur before we ring someone up. It's guess it's just a different unpopular view unfortunately for me. I wish it were a more popular view cause a lot of people don't agree which puts attention on me.

Just an FYI, I'm going to be in Vegas the next 3 days but will try on be on here as much as I can.

Re: (GON 3rd game)Town wins. Day 5

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Re: (GON 3rd game)No Mac for Donald - Day 1

Who is online