Nobunaga wrote:... Some people say we should have mandatory service, like say Korea... But that's a bad idea, imho. Granted, it's their military service time that tends to make Korean men some of the toughest and respectable people I've ever met, but mandatory service runs contrary to the ideas of liberty.
... I highly recommend military service to anybody who wishes to "graduate to manhood". It changes everything, even long after you've left it behind. There were times I hated it, but looking back, it was the best thing that I've ever done.
...
Well said. Part of me does agree with some sort of mandatory service. I believe Finland, Norway & Germany require it. I believe it helps instill a sense of pride of where your from, and a sense of duty. It doesn't have to be military service either. In Germany, consciencious objectors may do their service as civil servants instead of the military.
It is a slippery slope though. If I had to vote on it, I would say no.
There were certainly times when I said "what the hell am I doing?". Typically those thoughts arive when you show up at basic training.
Later I realized that it was a good thing I was saying that to myself, it meant they were doing their job.
There are 30+ year olds I know that still have the maturity of a 17 yr old. There are 18 yr old military personnel that have the maturity of a 35 yr old. THAT'S what the service will do for you. Make you grow up.
But hey, some 17 & 18 yr olds would prefer to keep their maturity at that level. Their choice.........