Mini-Mafia 2 [5/9] N3 - going quietly into the dark

by **vodean** on Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:56 pm

DiM wrote:so he was a bodyguard or a mason?
or both?
can he be both?

both.
he can be both.

by **DiM** on Fri Jul 27, 2012 4:57 pm

can he also be an elite bodyguard?

by **Iron Butterfly** on Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:18 pm

That changes things. I doubt very much he would be a mason ed elite body guard. He said he had an extra ability NOT abilities.

by **MeDeFe** on Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:56 pm

vodean wrote:
DiM wrote:so he was a bodyguard or a mason?
or both?
can he be both?

both.
he can be both.

Just edit the mason into the role description to make it less confusing if someone wants to go back and read up on things on day 4 or something.

Also: Awesome! The godfather is dead!

Considering that IB's claim is pretty much safe, that means LV is cleared. As such we have only 4 suspects left.
2. crazymilkshake5
3. DiM
4. MeDeFe
5. militant

Seeing how I'm ever so slightly inebriated atm I won't go into details and speculations, but keep this as a note for myself as well as use it as a starting point for tomorrow or whenever.

by **vodean** on Fri Jul 27, 2012 6:26 pm

MeDeFe wrote:
vodean wrote:
DiM wrote:so he was a bodyguard or a mason?
or both?
can he be both?

both.
he can be both.

Just edit the mason into the role description to make it less confusing if someone wants to go back and read up on things on day 4 or something.

Also: Awesome! The godfather is dead!

Considering that IB's claim is pretty much safe, that means LV is cleared. As such we have only 4 suspects left.
2. crazymilkshake5
3. DiM
4. MeDeFe
5. militant

Seeing how I'm ever so slightly inebriated atm I won't go into details and speculations, but keep this as a note for myself as well as use it as a starting point for tomorrow or whenever.

ever so slightly. riiiight

by **MeDeFe** on Fri Jul 27, 2012 8:28 pm

Yes, "ever so slightly".

But some posting is better than no posting, right?

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 12:14 am

You people join this game for a reason?

by **DiM** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 5:28 am

ok so i'd like to fos cms5 and militant for submarining.
cms has been logging in each day and even posting in other mafia games and all sorts of other threads except this one. his last post here was 6 days ago and it came after vodean said he'll prod him. also in the meantime he posted 29 times in other places. so he clearly has the time to post but for some reason not in this thread. i'm very suspicious about this.
as for militant he's simply very inactive. only 3 posts in the last 11 days. at least all 3 posts were in this game but still i find it too little. i'm less suspicious here since militant seems to be inactive everywhere not just this thread but still i don't like it.

by **vodean** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 10:05 am

yes. ill prod both of them tomorrow. i do request that all players do try to make at least one post each day! thats not that much to ask...

by **militant** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 11:26 am

I've been away for a while but does a serial killer usually have a knife and the mafia have a gun? With regard to speculation about how we had three deaths, I don't think it is worth it. Vodean said this would be a classic mafia game but we already have a bodyguard/mason and a possible serial killer so I don't think we'll be able to predict a whole lot. As for DiM's point about submarining, if cms5 has been posting elsewhere and seemingly been avoiding this thread then it is very suspicious and worthy of pressure (he might post soon anyway as Vodean has threatened a prod) . As for me, I told you in Jak's game my meta was to be somewhat lethargic, and I proved it to my embarrassment in that game. I'll re-read anyway.

As we have nine players, three are probably scum. One is dead so we have two left. If one is a serial killer as the scene seemed to suggest, the two don't know each other. Of the four possible candidates for today's lynch, two are town and the other two are scum. Supposing we lynch town today, and perhaps as many as two more die in the night (they'll kill the confirmed and the cop if lucky and don't both go for the same one), we'd have three left with one scum and as much information as we have now. If my assumptions are correct, no lynching would mean we'd have four alive tomorrow but it would still be lynch or lose because the scum could easily joint by forcing a no lynch. Therefore we must take our chances today and hope we hit scum so we'd have four alive with either the confirmed or the cop and we'd be in a much better position.

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 1:05 pm

Yes i would say we would have 3 anti town at most.
2 mafia and one third party.

sk usually uses a knife but that is not written in stone.

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 1:07 pm

If CM5 is gonna sub

vote crazy milkshake

by **vodean** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 1:21 pm

i have a replacement lined up if CMS doesnt post within 48 hours (prod goes tomorrow early)

by **Iron Butterfly** on Sat Jul 28, 2012 8:55 pm

Lord Voldemort posted in another game today.

I just realize he could easily be mafia.

The bus driver could have switched me and LV, which would be the reason I got a Town on him.

So he is not clear.

by **lord voldemort** on Sun Jul 29, 2012 2:22 am

With neb dying that means whoever hippo bodyguarded was targeted by scum. Though there is the bus driver...so its confusing. Means that the cops results could of been off.

by **MeDeFe** on Sun Jul 29, 2012 7:23 am

Iron Butterfly wrote:Lord Voldemort posted in another game today.

I just realize he could easily be mafia.

The bus driver could have switched me and LV, which would be the reason I got a Town on him.

So he is not clear.

True, I hadn't considered that. It is, however, not very likely that both you and the busdriver decided to target LV. Still, it means LV is not 100% in the clear yet.

I doubt this game started with more than 3 anti-town roles. A 3-1-5 setup would be nearly impossible to win, if it was 4-5 Town could already have lost. So either there's a SK and 1 scum left, and town can make a comeback even from a position where it doesn't have the absolute majority, or there're 2 scum left. Considering the number of deaths there must be some kind of killer besides the scum, SK, joat/vig, or maybe even both.

I agree with militants assessment that we need to lynch today. The question is who.
CMS and militant himself would be the obvious targets because of their previous low activity, but with CMS about to be replaced maybe we should put him on hold.