Battle of the Bulge - CLOSED

[Ragian]

@pmc, why would mafia want to off a survivor? (I'm asking because I'm not too sure, not because I don't think it's true.)

They would much rather lynch a townie but a survivor isn't bad for them. At least its not one of the core group, lynching a survivor may not move them much closer to victory in itself but with the night time kill it does improve their position overall.

Obviously, it takes them to the night phase without losing any. Of course...

[ghostly447]

Official Simplified Vote Count

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch

Jgordon – /, Rodion, Spartacus, thechuck, Jgordon
DoomYoshi – CMS – Vote wiped as of next vote count
PMC – Spartacus
CMS (Gimili)– Dazza, SG7 – Votes Wiped as of next vote count
Gimili (votes after he replaced) – Safariguy, doomyoshi – will not be wiped next vote count
New guy1 – Chapcrap
Everywhere – Leehar
Chapcrap – PMC, Jak

Solid Deadline is 5/7/12 at around 9pm EST

I will attempt to recruit 1 more player to replace the one who needs it.

If I messed up, please point it out. Great activity guys, lots of interesting reading! Keep it up .

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Official Simplified Vote Count

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch

Jgordon – /, Rodion, Spartacus, thechuck, Jgordon
DoomYoshi – CMS – Vote wiped as of next vote count
PMC – Spartacus
CMS (Gimili)– Dazza, SG7 – Votes Wiped as of next vote count
Gimili (votes after he replaced) – Safariguy, doomyoshi – will not be wiped next vote count
New guy1 – Chapcrap
Everywhere – Leehar
Chapcrap – PMC, Jak

Solid Deadline is 5/7/12 at around 9pm EST

I will attempt to recruit 1 more player to replace the one who needs it.

If I messed up, please point it out. Great activity guys, lots of interesting reading! Keep it up .

FINALLY A FREAKIN VOTE COUNT!

[new guy1]

Official Simplified Vote Count

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch

Jgordon – /, Rodion, Spartacus, thechuck, Jgordon
DoomYoshi – CMS – Vote wiped as of next vote count
PMC – Spartacus
CMS (Gimili)– Dazza, SG7 – Votes Wiped as of next vote count
Gimili (votes after he replaced) – Safariguy, doomyoshi – will not be wiped next vote count
New guy1 – Chapcrap
Everywhere – Leehar
Chapcrap – PMC, Jak

Solid Deadline is 5/7/12 at around 9pm EST

I will attempt to recruit 1 more player to replace the one who needs it.

If I messed up, please point it out. Great activity guys, lots of interesting reading! Keep it up .

FINALLY A FREAKIN VOTE COUNT!

IKR?!?! Just kidding, we know ghost so we can critisize

[ghostly447]

Official Simplified Vote Count

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch

Jgordon – /, Rodion, Spartacus, thechuck, Jgordon
DoomYoshi – CMS – Vote wiped as of next vote count
PMC – Spartacus
CMS (Gimili)– Dazza, SG7 – Votes Wiped as of next vote count
Gimili (votes after he replaced) – Safariguy, doomyoshi – will not be wiped next vote count
New guy1 – Chapcrap
Everywhere – Leehar
Chapcrap – PMC, Jak

Solid Deadline is 5/7/12 at around 9pm EST

I will attempt to recruit 1 more player to replace the one who needs it.

If I messed up, please point it out. Great activity guys, lots of interesting reading! Keep it up .

FINALLY A FREAKIN VOTE COUNT!

IKR?!?! Just kidding, we know ghost so we can critisize

Modkill on Clever and New guy1.

Night 1 begin!

joking by the way.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Official Simplified Vote Count

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch

Jgordon – /, Rodion, Spartacus, thechuck, Jgordon
DoomYoshi – CMS – Vote wiped as of next vote count
PMC – Spartacus
CMS (Gimili)– Dazza, SG7 – Votes Wiped as of next vote count
Gimili (votes after he replaced) – Safariguy, doomyoshi – will not be wiped next vote count
New guy1 – Chapcrap
Everywhere – Leehar
Chapcrap – PMC, Jak

Solid Deadline is 5/7/12 at around 9pm EST

I will attempt to recruit 1 more player to replace the one who needs it.

If I messed up, please point it out. Great activity guys, lots of interesting reading! Keep it up .

FINALLY A FREAKIN VOTE COUNT!

IKR?!?! Just kidding, we know ghost so we can critisize

Modkill on Clever and New guy1.

Night 1 begin!

joking by the way.

i dare you please please dont do that

[new guy1]

@pmc, why would mafia want to off a survivor? (I'm asking because I'm not too sure, not because I don't think it's true.)

They would much rather lynch a townie but a survivor isn't bad for them. At least its not one of the core group, lynching a survivor may not move them much closer to victory in itself but with the night time kill it does improve their position overall.

I'm going to go with gimli. Promised reading and posting, hasn't done it.

unvote vote gimli

Well that seems like a piss poor excuse to me. Even as an active player it is hard for me to catch up in matrix which has a similar number of pages. It seems like you just picked a name out the hat to satisfy me and I can tell you that you failed.

I agree with this, but also they might want to keep the survivor around for the swing vote in the end, but thats just if the survivor doesnt follow through on his word and help town, which I could see happening. And it does appear that Safari gave a bad excuse to vote someone, but I suppose that it would make sense as we have kind of ran ourselves to the end of the rope. I believe that we should start working out who we plan to lynch out of the candidates we pressured, if anyone, as we have around 5 days to get it done and it seems like this group disagrees on a fair amount of things.

fastposted

[pmchugh]

Yeah I think we need a way of reaching a consensus. We need some way of nominating a few players for us to discuss as the possible lynches. One way would be the people currently being voted or else we could all post the names of our top 3 lynch picks and then we take those with the most votes as nominees. Whadayathunk?

[new guy1]

Yeah I think we need a way of reaching a consensus. We need some way of nominating a few players for us to discuss as the possible lynches. One way would be the people currently being voted or else we could all post the names of our top 3 lynch picks and then we take those with the most votes as nominees. Whadayathunk?

I think that could work, but some people may not be on the current list while someone wants to vote them. So I dont think we should go by the vote list, more like the list of players and just list off who we think is scummy.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Yeah I think we need a way of reaching a consensus. We need some way of nominating a few players for us to discuss as the possible lynches. One way would be the people currently being voted or else we could all post the names of our top 3 lynch picks and then we take those with the most votes as nominees. Whadayathunk?

I think that could work, but some people may not be on the current list while someone wants to vote them. So I dont think we should go by the vote list, more like the list of players and just list off who we think is scummy.

agreed everyone should just say the top three and we can compile them togethor and then the top one we can lynch. i think that would work cause were not gonna reack a majority anytime soon.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

double post...i didnt even realize that pmc said the same exact thing....Well i agree.

[new guy1]

double post...i didnt even realize that pmc said the same exact thing....Well i agree.

Skimming now? I wouldnt have admitted to that .

[Some7hingCLEVER]

double post...i didnt even realize that pmc said the same exact thing....Well i agree.

Skimming now? I wouldnt have admitted to that .

lol i dont see how i skimmed if you think about it i replied to it therefore i would have had to read it. i noticed what he said it must have just stuck in my tiny brain...

[pmchugh]

Lol, maybe "lynch" is a bit harsh for the top one. We can certainly discuss the top few. I guess then we have to decide the order in which we say it, assuming nobody disagrees. If we do it randomly like the "yoshi role call" I have been hearing so much about then I think jak has to do the randomising, as he is the least likely to corrupt it IMO.

[Ragian]

Sounds like a plan that could spawn a lot of OMGUS

I don't think anyone has made any major slip-up just yet even though a lot of people have pounded blindfolded in various directions for 50 pages. I'm not convinced by any of the cases so far anyway (hence no voting from me as it is right now).

As I see it, there's a 3rd party and some scum-mariners in the mix. That would the safest bet for a lynch in my eyes. (Prolly gonna get players with the number 1 in their names on my back now.)

FASTPOSTED. Didn't read it yet...

[Ragian]

Sounds like a plan that could spawn a lot of OMGUS

I don't think anyone has made any major slip-up just yet even though a lot of people have pounded blindfolded in various directions for 50 pages. I'm not convinced by any of the cases so far anyway (hence no voting from me as it is right now).

As I see it, there's a 3rd party and some scum-mariners in the mix. That would be the safest bet for a lynch in my eyes. (Prolly gonna get players with the number 1 in their names on my back now.)

FASTPOSTED. Didn't read it yet...

EBWOP

[everywhere116]

Vote gimli

Welcome to the Game.

Safari guy, why are you voting for someone who may not have received a role PM yet?

I am overwhelmed by the irony.

[shieldgenerator7]

Prod recieved. I'm still gone and still at page 37 but I'll catch up when I can when I get back

-SG7 ( )

[chapcrap]

As of now, the only people I would consider are

• jgordon
• pmc
• newguy
• safari

I wouldn't have put safari on the list until he voted gimli. Maybe he was joking...It seemed serious and really ridiculous.

The reason I (half-jokingly) agreed with Doom about a post limit is because not everything you guys have posted is helpful at all, especially jgordon. You have been giving almost no helpful posts. All of your posts are just commentary on others' gameplay. It's kind of ridiculous.

@pmc, I can have justified votes and want to bandwagon on Day 1. Those do not have to be mutually exclusive.

[safariguy5]

As of now, the only people I would consider are

• jgordon
• pmc
• newguy
• safari

I wouldn't have put safari on the list until he voted gimli. Maybe he was joking...It seemed serious and really ridiculous.

The reason I (half-jokingly) agreed with Doom about a post limit is because not everything you guys have posted is helpful at all, especially jgordon. You have been giving almost no helpful posts. All of your posts are just commentary on others' gameplay. It's kind of ridiculous.

@pmc, I can have justified votes and want to bandwagon on Day 1. Those do not have to be mutually exclusive.

Again, pmc pushed me to pick somebody. I've already said I think we have enough information for me. How many more claims do you guys really want? At this point, I think it's either we lynch jgordon to minimize town losses or we no lynch and see what the night brings us.

[chapcrap]

saf, I saw that you said that earlier. I responded with the same feelings, but said one more claim wouldn't hurt in a game this size. We really only have 2 claims so far, which isn't a lot, IMO.

[jak111]

Hmm, my top THREE would probably be
[*]Saf
Chap
Doom[/*]

If only ones who are currently have at least one vote on them
[*]Chap
NG
No lynch[/*]

Saf has been jumpier than Hippo does in games with him. Which seems odd to me, but perhaps I haven't played with him enough. Also his lack of explanations lately seem doubly odd. He's pushing for the lynch but he'll settle for a no lynch.

Chap, well again, another player who's playing style is a bit off from what I've seen of him. He started the game quiet but got more active as lynching time grew closer.

Doom, whom I still have FOS on from earlier, at this point he could or could not be a mafia. Although his name as definitely sunk in activity since the case was pulled from him.

NG, not much of a reason, just a few gut feelings of late and everyone else being voted for are either being pulled off or they don't seem scummy/inactive.

No vote because everyones all over the place, and really those who think we must lynch the survivor if we lynch anyone, why not just no lynch and add to our numbers a potential ally? You all seem odd to be for pushing it so hard.

[jak111]

Hmm, my top THREE would probably be

Saf
Chap
Doom

If only ones who are currently have at least one vote on them

Chap
NG
No lynch

EBWOP

[DoomYoshi]

Even though I am on your top 3 list, I agree with it. However, chap and safari are both great players and I am not sure I want to take them on day 1. That seems like a lot of effort. I will let jak pick one and will follow along.

[/]

My top three, by suspicion would include jak, because frankly I don't believe his claimed name or special ability, but I will leave him redacted from the list because it is the type of thing that needs later confirmation and definitely not a lynch at this point.

The true three would be
Jgordon, obviously, I still believe the most info can be gained from his death, and it is possible he is scum, if not now we will probably lose him through the cracks until endgame, and be in a situation similar to what PMC described.

everywhere116, doesn't really contribute much beyond the occasional quip, his last serious vote, as I have noted panned out poorly, and wasn't thought through seemingly.

Safari, I find it odd to pressure the replacement like that out of nowhere, there are cases abound that will actually generate data because there have been tons of posts, I wonder if there is a reason he wants to detract from them and on to a completely random case on someone with no in game posts, besides supposedly not reading fast enough. One would think someone so read up would have an actual case by P.50


newguy narrowly is bumped down to fourth, for the reasons I mentioned a few pages back, and possibly for trying to prematurely put that line to bed. (ie: saying in advance "that's all I have to say" then literally not responding further, moving on to the definition of "OMGUS")