thechuck51 wrote:The odds of us outing and lynching any scum are small (approx. 1 in 4 I would guess). We can continue to go back and forth, casting suspicions here and there, creating fake cases to see who joins the bandwagon, and in my opinion continue to accomplish very little or we can lynch somebody we know is not town, JGordon. If we wait, our focus in the following days will be on finding/lynching scum, allowing JGordon to survive further into the game which would only make him more dangerous to the town. He says he wants the town to win but if we end up in a lynch or lose situation it would be to easy for him to vote with the mafia and meet his win condition.
I've started a pro/con list for lynching JGordon. please add to it if you like
Pros:
- we do not lose a town member to a lynch
- we do not mistakenly out another power role by continuing to pressure with more bandwagons
- we prevent the potential LyLo condition described above.
- we prevent the chance of our vig being busdriven while trying to NK him (if both roles are present in the game)
- we move the game to the next phase where we can use our power roles to build real cases
Cons:
- we do not lynch scum
- if JGordon is a jester, he wins (will the game end with his lynch? if not, then this may not be much of a con)
And commence my tearing apart of Chap's post here.
CONS:
We lose a person who's been contributing more than other players to the game on the town's side.
We lose any more info I can give for tomorrow if he's lynched quickly because he's not adolf, people will die tonight.
But hey, I'm only the town doc and posted a hell of a lot more useful things than Chuck, so what do I know, right? Jg has posted a lot more helpful things than you Chuck.
So here's a thought. Pro's and Con's for putting pressure on Chuck
Pro's
~ He may very well be scum, trying to push jg's lynch ONCE AGAIN with still a week left.
~ If he's Adolf we get to get through a night without anyone dying.
~ Chuck has generally been inactive in the current cases, so hasn't added much.
Con's
~ Nothing.
Sorry, I'm just getting tired of people pushing jg's lynch when he's been contributing more than many of the people in the game. I'd prefer a No Lynch over just lynching jg because he's "not town". He's a potential town player, if you really have something against that you're crazy. Sure kill him if it gets down to pressure, but for now he's useful and adds to the numbers.
If I hear one more bs case on jg between tonight and tomorrow in rl time, I'm going to flip and not use my power. (NOT JOKING) So be warned.
Fastposted by Clever