CLUE Mafia- Mafia Win!!!! MVP- Rodion

by **Rodion** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 7:19 pm

About Boddy: if the cellar cards are the equivalent of a cop investigation and SKs can appear innocent, Mr. Boddy can be anyone (except for Freezie, Shm and maybe / since the latter appeared in Safari's role PM).

by **F1fth** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 7:46 pm

Nark's been dead a long time (Mr. Gold, town, daykilled). The original post is a little inaccurate.

safariguy5 wrote:Well F1fth made a mistake in his player list.

Yes, sorry about that. :oops:

Here, hopefully this list is a little more informative.

show: The Revised List

The difficult thing is though, Mrs. Silver appeared in one of the scenes so we know they can contain false information. I would consider anyone not proven town by cellar cards to be suspect, including myself if I didn't know better.

freezie wrote:I would have prefered this to go another way, but it surely won't at this point:

Shm is my old mafia member. You are all right by saying he is mafia, however I will recruit him tonight. And he's the only one with a shot at the sk until we lynch someone XD

Of course, if your partner wasn't one of the two he would have taken the shot by now.

But you need to not recruit him tonight, else you both might be killed. You should make it a secret who you recruit, but make sure you choose someone who will accept it.

by **safariguy5** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 7:52 pm

F1fth wrote:Nark's been dead a long time (Mr. Gold, town, daykilled). The original post is a little inaccurate.

safariguy5 wrote:Well F1fth made a mistake in his player list.

Yes, sorry about that. Here, hopefully this list is a little more informative.

show: The Revised List

The difficult thing is though, Mrs. Silver appeared in one of the scenes so we know they can contain false information. I would consider anyone not proven town by cellar cards to be suspect, including myself if I didn't know better.

freezie wrote:I would have prefered this to go another way, but it surely won't at this point:

Shm is my old mafia member. You are all right by saying he is mafia, however I will recruit him tonight. And he's the only one with a shot at the sk until we lynch someone XD
Of course, if your partner wasn't one of the two he would have taken the shot by now. But you need to not recruit him tonight, else you both might be killed. You should make it a secret who you recruit, but make sure you choose someone who will accept it.

Wait, didn't Rodion try voting Nark yesterday and it was counted? So maybe he's just muted?

by **shm78** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 8:05 pm

I guess the cat is now out of the bag, thanks for saving me from the hangman's knot Freezie. My role is that of Yvette. I had to try for a fake claim when the mass claim and cards were being revealed. I tried to pick a non descript role from the movie with the hopes that no one had it or in this case that the role was underdefined and I could at least last longer in the game to a. figure it out and b. try to develop an end game strategy. I guess I am only trying to avoid a potential SK.

by **freezie** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 10:01 pm

Violet, talapus, is there a mistake in the alive player list on the first page?

When a mod answers that, we'Ll know what to do with Nark..for now..let's think of who exactly might be mr. Boddy

by **Mass Miracle** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 11:08 pm

vote Mass Miracle[/quote]
I believe that Debra hill was one of the characters mentioned in the candlestick investigation day two by Daze. So it is likely the claimed is an actual character in the game... However as I mentioned I Sergeant Grey Knew before anything started knew Mass doesn't belong here for some reason or another, so I am curious to hear more about your role?[/quote]

If we go back to early in the game there was talk about slash or /

Falkomagno wrote:
Victor Sullivan wrote:I believe it's "Inspector Brown", Yoshi.

-Sully

No is not. Is Captain Brown.

And i think that frenzie made a mistake. Revealing the guilty card it takes away the possibility to unmask a fake claim. That's it like a mafia though that Monsiueur Brunnete is town and ends up in a claim that can be debated. In any case, i think that kind of information make easier the job to the mafia faction.

Btw, I think that there is another character not listed: Slash.Not sure if is from the game or if it's referred to "/". It's just mentioned in my role message

The same / is mentioned in my role pm and it says all the guests are quite nice except for /. So I guess I will ask you what is it you have for Debra?

I will also ask a question since my experience in this game is limited...why do the mods refer to a cc name (/) as opposed to the Clue name (Sgt Grey)...at the time I would not know who / was so why the warning about a cc player?

Also / says he knew Mass didn't belong not Debra...can someone explain that?

by **VioIet** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 11:33 pm

Vote Count

no lynch(1)- rodion
shm (2) - doomyoshi, ben,
mass (1)- mass
safari (1)- dazey

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

The first page/original post is accurate. Check the Day 3 opening scene for reference.

by **Rodion** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 11:36 pm

Can you please prod Anarkist Dream?

by **freezie** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 11:46 pm

Do we take the chance that Mr Gold kept his original allignment? I know he's going to hate me for originally killing him but anyway XD I doubt hyis alignment changed, yet.

A mass DK sounds good to me, then we'll see who to lynch.

by **freezie** on Thu Jul 21, 2011 11:49 pm

Oh and that beeing said

Vote: Gimli

According to F1th's list

by **safariguy5** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 12:43 am

freezie wrote:Do we take the chance that Mr Gold kept his original allignment? I know he's going to hate me for originally killing him but anyway XD I doubt hyis alignment changed, yet.

A mass DK sounds good to me, then we'll see who to lynch.

I'm concerned about any assumptions about Gold, I actually think he might have some sort of alignment change that was triggered upon killing him. That or Nark is just submarining the crap out of this game and I'm being paranoid. But yeah, I support a DK on Mass, we'll see what we have afterwards.

by **ben.cleuch** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 3:16 am

Do we all have to agree on a day kill, or is it a majority decision?

by **DoomYoshi** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 12:14 pm

We don't all have to agree. I am pretty weakly opinionated right now, so a kill on Mass seems fine for me.

by **F1fth** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 1:35 pm

Sure. Killing Mass is fine by me though I would prefer it be gimli since as my list points out, he has the weakest claim for his character existing. But aside from that...

VioIet wrote:The first page/original post is accurate. Check the Day 3 opening scene for reference.

JESUS, VOTE ANARK!! I'm willing to bet money he's Boddy. I was really confused because too many people's stories were checking out. Of course I wasn't paying attention to the guy I took to be dead. He sure played the part well though, not one post since he "died."

by **dazerazer** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 2:50 pm

unvote, vote anark

by **freezie** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 4:49 pm

ben.cleuch wrote:Do we all have to agree on a day kill, or is it a majority decision?

You could all disagree and it wouldn't change the fact shm could do it anyway. However, if he wants to be on the good side ( and on my good side ) he better do it for the town rather than for himself XD

by **safariguy5** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:16 pm

F1fth wrote:Sure. Killing Mass is fine by me though I would prefer it be gimli since as my list points out, he has the weakest claim for his character existing. But aside from that...

VioIet wrote:The first page/original post is accurate. Check the Day 3 opening scene for reference.

JESUS, VOTE ANARK!! I'm willing to bet money he's Boddy. I was really confused because too many people's stories were checking out. Of course I wasn't paying attention to the guy I took to be dead. He sure played the part well though, not one post since he "died."

I think we kill Mass since he obviously doesn't want to give us the full story, and then we lynch Nark, taking care of our Boddy Sker problem.

by **DoomYoshi** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:25 pm

safariguy5 wrote:
F1fth wrote:Sure. Killing Mass is fine by me though I would prefer it be gimli since as my list points out, he has the weakest claim for his character existing. But aside from that...

VioIet wrote:The first page/original post is accurate. Check the Day 3 opening scene for reference.

JESUS, VOTE ANARK!! I'm willing to bet money he's Boddy. I was really confused because too many people's stories were checking out. Of course I wasn't paying attention to the guy I took to be dead. He sure played the part well though, not one post since he "died."

I think we kill Mass since he obviously doesn't want to give us the full story, and then we lynch Nark, taking care of our Boddy Sker problem.

Why is this in color? Are you sending a message to someone?

by **safariguy5** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 5:27 pm

DoomYoshi wrote:
safariguy5 wrote:
F1fth wrote:Sure. Killing Mass is fine by me though I would prefer it be gimli since as my list points out, he has the weakest claim for his character existing. But aside from that...

VioIet wrote:The first page/original post is accurate. Check the Day 3 opening scene for reference.

JESUS, VOTE ANARK!! I'm willing to bet money he's Boddy. I was really confused because too many people's stories were checking out. Of course I wasn't paying attention to the guy I took to be dead. He sure played the part well though, not one post since he "died."

I think we kill Mass since he obviously doesn't want to give us the full story, and then we lynch Nark, taking care of our Boddy Sker problem.

Why is this in color? Are you sending a message to someone?

Just posting in purple today. In honor of IR.

by **VioIet** on Fri Jul 22, 2011 10:35 pm

Vote Count

no lynch(1)- rodion
shm (2) - doomyoshi, ben,
mass (1)- mass
gimli (1) - freezie
anark (2)- f1fth, dazey

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch