South Park Mafia [Scum Win]

[lalaland]

So, any other ramifications of the night that we need to know going into today?

[chapcrap]

So, any other ramifications of the night that we need to know going into today?

It's hard for me to think because of this bad soup I had. It's making me weary and has sapped my ability to vote.

[lalaland]

Commander, I know that you maintain that you don't know anything about soup, but any light you can shed on the situation?

[40kguy]

I found out who tail is, don't vote for him.

[40kguy]

Commander, I know that you maintain that you don't know anything about soup, but any light you can shed on the situation?

Maybe he is making the soup against bad people, or maybe he is a bad guy hurting good people!
FOS commander9

[strike wolf]

Dear god I want to vote both of them for that night spam...Honestly I just finished rereading the thread and this game has given me a major headache. Not so much because I haven't found any leads but because the behavior of the players you would think were pro-town is not only the most suspicious in this game but among the most suspicious in any games I have played recently. This is not to say I do not have a case to make but it may take a while to put together and I spent most of tonight reading through this game.

[evilchaos]

I found out who tail is, don't vote for him.

Info please? I'm not going to blindly obey you. If you want me to not vote tail regardless of what he does, then I better see a pretty good reason.

[Talapus]

I found out who tail is, don't vote for him.

Info please? I'm not going to blindly obey you. If you want me to not vote tail regardless of what he does, then I better see a pretty good reason.

Ya 40k, I really hope you plan on using more then 1 sentence posts for elaborations today as your 5 word, 1 sentence posts all day yesterday were hard to get anything from. The assumption is that tails is ok based on what you said, however you've already claimed so there really isn't a point in keeping anything you found out from the rest of us. You are already a target for scum, so please share a bit more.

[chapcrap]

I found out who tail is, don't vote for him.

Info please? I'm not going to blindly obey you. If you want me to not vote tail regardless of what he does, then I better see a pretty good reason.

Ya 40k, I really hope you plan on using more then 1 sentence posts for elaborations today as your 5 word, 1 sentence posts all day yesterday were hard to get anything from. The assumption is that tails is ok based on what you said, however you've already claimed so there really isn't a point in keeping anything you found out from the rest of us. You are already a target for scum, so please share a bit more.

Seems like he might be trying to protect Tails if he is a doc or something. Of course, that might just be the soup talking.

[lalaland]

If Tails was a doc, why would 40k bring attention to him when there is absolutely zero pressure on him today? That doesn't make sense to me. Maybe if Tails had a few votes on him it would make sense to say that.

40k, I know you've claimed and everything and look town by the facts, but I swear you make scummier posts than anybody.

[evilchaos]

40k, I know you've claimed and everything and look town by the facts, but I swear you make scummier posts than anybody.

This. I'm inclined to believe that 40k is town based on his claimed role, but everything he does is extra scummy.

[chapcrap]

40k, I know you've claimed and everything and look town by the facts, but I swear you make scummier posts than anybody.

This. I'm inclined to believe that 40k is town based on his claimed role, but everything he does is extra scummy.

This soup is killing me. I just puked, but it didn't help.

I think he might just be new and thought the info would help. Of course, it was info that didn't need to be revealed yet.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Haha this is funny. I got info on 40k, but I don't know how reliable it is. I'll post later when I search through 40k's posts.

-Tails

[40kguy]

Haha this is funny. I got info on 40k, but I don't know how reliable it is. I'll post later when I search through 40k's posts.

-Tails

What info do you have?

[strike wolf]

Still here but my internet isn't working. Typing from my phone which makes constructing long posts very tedious.

[/]

Hmm, so we have another player who has been fed some bad soup, safari was definitely town, so at the very least we know it wasn't some kind of weird nerfed cult recruiter role.

[strike wolf]

Okay so I am not going to have time to post my full analysis and work on my analysis in unknown so I'm biting the bullet and writing what I can. First there really have been a lot of distractions in this game. People going after Kenny for no real reason *cough*naxus*cough*, 40k's erratic behavior, the whole soup/chef issue, and to a lesser extent evilchaos who has a fairly believable claim but imo has dropped more scum tells than anyone. This has unfortunately lead me to the conclusion that with all the distractions the real mafia have probably been able to hide easily enough. So I have tried looking through the inactives and one really stood out: kratos.

I would like for everyone to look back through the thread and note not onlyhow sparsely he has posted since the joke phase ended but the relatively short amount of time it takes him to respond to submarining allegations and his relatively high activity in other threads compared to this one. I would also like to note how through this whole process he has refrained from pushing any buttons or going away from the popular path. This could be just a newbie thing but along with the submarining I think it makes a decent case. fos kratos

I would also have to agree with other opinions about the soup and it not being chef's doing or at the very least I would not expect commander to start hinting heavily at being chef when a great deal of attention is being paid to him as a possible anti-town role.

I do find it interesting that tails says he has learned information on 40k and that 40k says he knows who tails is but this only really seems to support 40k's earlier role claim

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Wow. I read this game, and I have to agree with Strike, this game is frustrating.

With regard to the 40k thing--

I've two possibilities. Since a large portion of the roster is already claimed, and I'm sure no one will drop this anyway, I'll claim. I'm Officer Barbrady, Town Cop. However, anyone familiar with the show might feel as I felt about the role. I have my reservations about his sanity, because in the show he's completely incompetent. I investigated 40k last night because I wanted to test the sanity on what I assumed would be a town role (Stan). I got a roundabout guilty result (I didn't investigate anybody N1 due to my inactivity--sorrz). However, when I looked at role pm again, I was warned about any other players claiming cop, which, as I understood his role, 40k did.

1. I got a skewed result. Possible sanity variance.

2. 40k is scum who received a fake claim role in Stan Marsh.

It's hard for me to decide based on 40k's n00bness. He is erratic and posts fluff.

I'll leave this up to other players. For now, I'm gonna pursue other leads, if I can find them.

-Tails

[strike wolf]

Well that is unexpected. Stan Marsh is a pretty strong claim and unless Blake has decided to switch things around and made all four of the main characters anti-town of some sort or another, it doesn't really seem likely that 40k is scum. I have to agree that the sanity of Barbrady could be brought into question so I am not sure we should follow this but at the same time I would think that he would have been more likely naive than insane or paranoid (If someone more familiar with the character thinks otherwise I'd be more than welcome to hear the reasoning...the big deal here though is if Tails is telling the truth about what he has found it sounds like 40k was lying about being able to contact one person each night (I know there has since been some confusion on this role but he seemed to say fairly certainly day one that he did contact people directly). I'm tempted to believe one of three things.

A. 40k is lying in some fashion or another and is scum
B. Tails is lying and is scum.
C. Some other situation that would cause 40k to realize Tails role without actually directly contacting tails...though this one seems a bit less likely to me

Unfortunately this doesn't really clear the air much on this issue and it really comes down to do we want to trust Tails as a sane cop assuming there isn't any other factors that would affect result.

[strike wolf]

Well that is unexpected. Stan Marsh is a pretty strong claim and unless Blake has decided to switch things around and made all four of the main characters anti-town of some sort or another, it doesn't really seem likely that 40k is scum. I have to agree that the sanity of Barbrady could be brought into question so I am not sure we should follow this but at the same time I would think that he would have been more likely naive than insane or paranoid (If someone more familiar with the character thinks otherwise I'd be more than welcome to hear the reasoning...the big deal here though is if Tails is telling the truth about what he has found it sounds like 40k was lying about being able to contact one person each night (I know there has since been some confusion on this role but he seemed to say fairly certainly day one that he did contact people directly). I'm tempted to believe one of three things.

A. 40k is lying in some fashion or another and is scum
B. Tails is lying and is scum.
C. Some other situation that would cause 40k to realize Tails role without actually directly contacting tails...though this one seems a bit less likely to me

Unfortunately this doesn't really clear the air much on this issue and it really comes down to do we want to trust Tails as a sane cop assuming there isn't any other factors that would affect result.

Ebwop: I am a bit curious as to the not trusting other cop claims issue...I have never heard of any situation like that before.

[Commander9]

Commander, I know that you maintain that you don't know anything about soup, but any light you can shed on the situation?

... Gee, what more do you want me to say? I have already stated everything that I can - if you have problems and you don't believe me, feel free to vote me.

Maybe he is making the soup against bad people, or maybe he is a bad guy hurting good people!
FOS commander9

*Facepalm* You want to explain how I have earnt a FOS? And afraid to commit a vote?

Well that is unexpected. Stan Marsh is a pretty strong claim and unless Blake has decided to switch things around and made all four of the main characters anti-town of some sort or another, it doesn't really seem likely that 40k is scum. I have to agree that the sanity of Barbrady could be brought into question so I am not sure we should follow this but at the same time I would think that he would have been more likely naive than insane or paranoid (If someone more familiar with the character thinks otherwise I'd be more than welcome to hear the reasoning...the big deal here though is if Tails is telling the truth about what he has found it sounds like 40k was lying about being able to contact one person each night (I know there has since been some confusion on this role but he seemed to say fairly certainly day one that he did contact people directly). I'm tempted to believe one of three things.

A. 40k is lying in some fashion or another and is scum
B. Tails is lying and is scum.
C. Some other situation that would cause 40k to realize Tails role without actually directly contacting tails...though this one seems a bit less likely to me

Unfortunately this doesn't really clear the air much on this issue and it really comes down to do we want to trust Tails as a sane cop assuming there isn't any other factors that would affect result.

I would highly suggest waiting another day and having him produce another result to see what the outcome is (He should be protected).

[lalaland]

This new information, combined with the general uselessness and scumminess of 40k's posts, causes me to vote 40kguy but also lay a FOS Tailgunner .
I don't see how you both have the alignment that you say you do, although I do see the non-sane cop issue...
Basically this all looks really fishy to me.

[Commander9]

This new information, combined with the general uselessness and scumminess of 40k's posts, causes me to vote 40kguy but also lay a FOS Tailgunner .
I don't see how you both have the alignment that you say you do, although I do see the non-sane cop issue...
Basically this all looks really fishy to me.

Well, from what I'm getting, Stan Marsh is a flavour cop (or some sort of cop), so I'm not sure if lynching him is such a good idea. Let TG test his power one more time, because a mislynch here would be horrible for the town. FoS Lalaland for this.

[strike wolf]

I would like for 40k to explain his role specifically with no room for interpretation about whether he talks to people at night like a mason role which seemed to be the initial interpretation or if he is a cop of sorts. Depending on the answer I'll decide to wait or vote...

[chapcrap]

This new information, combined with the general uselessness and scumminess of 40k's posts, causes me to vote 40kguy but also lay a FOS Tailgunner .
I don't see how you both have the alignment that you say you do, although I do see the non-sane cop issue...
Basically this all looks really fishy to me.

Well, from what I'm getting, Stan Marsh is a flavour cop (or some sort of cop), so I'm not sure if lynching him is such a good idea. Let TG test his power one more time, because a mislynch here would be horrible for the town. FoS Lalaland for this.

If this soup weren't getting to me, I might've spent a vote on lala.

I would like for 40k to explain his role specifically with no room for interpretation about whether he talks to people at night like a mason role which seemed to be the initial interpretation or if he is a cop of sorts. Depending on the answer I'll decide to wait or vote...

Good luck with this. It seems like he's been eating this soup the whole game.