POTC Mafia Game Thread Day 7 Town Win! Premium goes to Sully

[nagerous]

Maybe so, but at least this way they may have the satisfaction of seeing edocsil hung up by a tree! Also, day six, Victor would get lynched and then mafia can pick off culties at night and also with falko giving the townies swords the balance could well be redressed.

[strike wolf]

Balance cannot be redressed for mafia you know that. As long as their names are out there there will be no rebalancing for them.

[nagerous]

Maybe a tie?

[DoomYoshi]

Their names are not out there though. Assuming that edocsil was telling the truth about how many mafia there are, at least 1 (or 2) are still hidden. That seems like a good chance for a rebalance.

[pancakemix]

Their names are not out there though. Assuming that edocsil was telling the truth about how many mafia there are, at least 1 (or 2) are still hidden. That seems like a good chance for a rebalance.

Assuming he was telling the truth, you're mafia. Also screwed.

I will say that the mafia's best chance lies in lynching Victor, or else lose without a doubt.

[nagerous]

Their names are not out there though. Assuming that edocsil was telling the truth about how many mafia there are, at least 1 (or 2) are still hidden. That seems like a good chance for a rebalance.

Assuming he was telling the truth, you're mafia. Also screwed.

I will say that the mafia's best chance lies in lynching Victor, or else lose without a doubt.

Nice misinformation there and also a contradiction.. and Doom everyone knows you're mafia so there is no point denying it.

[pancakemix]

Their names are not out there though. Assuming that edocsil was telling the truth about how many mafia there are, at least 1 (or 2) are still hidden. That seems like a good chance for a rebalance.

Assuming he was telling the truth, you're mafia. Also screwed.

I will say that the mafia's best chance lies in lynching Victor, or else lose without a doubt.

Nice misinformation there and also a contradiction.. and Doom everyone knows you're mafia so there is no point denying it.

Admit it. They're shafted either way.

Also, you're cult. Your argument is invalid.

[nagerous]

Their names are not out there though. Assuming that edocsil was telling the truth about how many mafia there are, at least 1 (or 2) are still hidden. That seems like a good chance for a rebalance.

Assuming he was telling the truth, you're mafia. Also screwed.

I will say that the mafia's best chance lies in lynching Victor, or else lose without a doubt.

Nice misinformation there and also a contradiction.. and Doom everyone knows you're mafia so there is no point denying it.

Admit it. They're shafted either way.

Also, you're cult. Your argument is invalid.

Why's it any more invalid than your arguments? You're just being an ass saying that. Town don't have a majority, you're just another faction now.

[Victor Sullivan]

Hear, hear! Your dear friend, Davy Jones, has words of wisdom to share (though mostly covered by his dear cult friend):

I and my three cult recruits count for four votes, and will stick together in our vote.
Mafia is 100% screwed with siding with town. They can't kill enough townies in time if they lynch me, town will pick them off Days 6 and 7.
Mandy may want me dead, but surely this isn't the only way you can win?
Town has 5 members, hardly a majority.

I'm a reasonable man, open to compromise and interested in the betterment of all parties. How about we lynch edocsil? I have no issue sacrificing one of my recruits, it helps mafia gain a larger percentage of our alliance, Mandy wants him dead, and edocsil isn't a townie and has no further use to the town. Fair enough?

Vote edocsil

[edocsil]

Oh, f*ck you. Go hang someone else, they are still going to kill you, even if you kiss ass.

[mandalorian2298]

By lynching Victor, they are effectively signing their own death warrant, better to survive than be lynched.

Yeah but Mandy said something about his WC having something to do with the death of Jones. I doubt we can recover the townies the cult has claimed but it'd be nice.

Oh yeah, about that...I lied. The Town was out to lynch me, so I figured that I should give them a reason to keep me alive.

I guess it worked.

and now the freaking davy jones have a sword. mea culpa
vote victor

How do you figure that Davey Jones has a sword?

Also, I am faced with a dilemma. On one hand, I really don't feel like helping this town out since they are a pack of treacherous dogs. On the other hand, the Mayor helped me out, and I would sure like him to win. I'll have think about it.

In the meantime, vote Edoc since, well, he is Mafia.

C'mon...I'm always wanted you in our side, and now that the people who vote for you can feel regret of their actions there is no need to keep a grudge on town. Lets work together we still have the majority and all the bad guys are uncovered...Let's win this. Let's eliminate damn VS, since at night he will be really dangerous and protected, and if we don't lynch him right now we can lose right away.

Townies of the Caribean!!!! There is a day in which the cult won a mafia game...BUT NOT THIS DAY!!! THIS DAY WE FIGHT!!!!

God's speed, Leonides.

After much deliberation I decided that I don't really want to help this Town to win. As many of you pointed out yesterday, people would remember for a long time that I helped out those who lynched me, not because it was the best move for their side to win, but because their code of honor says that lynching innocent's in order to honor deal with Scum Traitors is OK.

Well, my code says: Ke nu jurkad ti Mando'ade, burc'ya! You guys decided against my help by a majority vote. Now face the consequences.

12 alive... and also mandy is only third party - or playing like it anyway.

Why not just lynch edoc, I'm sure the mafia and mandy are baying for his blood

Fourth party, actually. I appreciate the offer, but I would look less dashing with tentacles growing where my goatee used to be.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

Hm... Well I guess actually lynching Vic will be difficult since there's so few townies, but whatever Vote Vic. I think maf and town should be on a united front here at this point. f*ck the cult.

-Tails

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

Victor(5)- falko, sheep, pcm, strike, tails
edoc(2)- Mandy, VS
/(1)- edoc
falko(1)- nag

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Quick clarification as I don't think it will have any bearing on the game. The Sao Feng character is a Town traitor, meaning he's not mafia as he doesn't count as mafia, he's best described as town with different win conditions. Also, he counts as town in any endgame scenario unless changed otherwise.

[/]

..... well, I can't care anymore in that case... both sides are equally unappealing in every aspect but edoc's death, tell you what if victor No-backsies, no finger or testicle crossing, pinkie-promises to not use the sword or recruit on either mafia tonight, I will agree to lynch edoc out of compromise, otherwise my vote is going on victor.

[DoomYoshi]

I don't think it is necessary for edoc to be lynched. That is not an appropriate candidate. Edoc already lost this game, which is retribution enough. Furthermore, he proved he was a liar in the process. The mafia are screwed either way. So for now, I [b]unvote[/b]. I won't vote for anyone, I will just let the deadline run out until it goes back to night, which I am the master of. If you decide to lynch me, the town loses. The cult do not have enough votes to lynch me themselves.

[DoomYoshi]

Oh, and Mandy, if you join my no-lynch wagon I will promise to not kill you.

[safariguy5]

FYI I haven't set a deadline yet. That's only going to happen if activity flags, and it's been very good so far.

[freezie]

Oh, and Mandy, if you join my no-lynch wagon I will promise to not kill you.

Simply vote no lynch if that's what you really want..

[Victor Sullivan]

I don't think it is necessary for edoc to be lynched. That is not an appropriate candidate. Edoc already lost this game, which is retribution enough. Furthermore, he proved he was a liar in the process. The mafia are screwed either way. So for now, I unvote. I won't vote for anyone, I will just let the deadline run out until it goes back to night, which I am the master of. If you decide to lynch me, the town loses. The cult do not have enough votes to lynch me themselves.

Um...what? I seriously hope / is more rational than you are... Who the hell is going to vote no lynch? Absolutely no one! You do realize you literally have no chance if you don't side with cult on this one, I'm extending my tentacle in good faith and compromise, let's not pass up a done deal, shall we? I honestly don't understand what the hell you're doing... And I have no intention of lynching you, so I'm not sure why you're feeling so paranoid. Look at this rationally Doom, if mafia (you and /) side with cult you have a better chance and we would have the numbers! If you side with town, they'll NK one of you tonight and lynch the other tomorrow, or at the very least, lynch you two Days 6 and 7. Lynching edocsil is best for all parties, like I already explained, and we don't technically have majority without Mandy, who only seems keen on lynching edocsil - a fair compromise, don't you think?

-Sully

[DoomYoshi]

Actually a no lynch seems better. With no lynch, the town is forced to use their NK on you Victor. Then, since cult still outnumbers mafia they have to use their next kill on another cult. I have no chance of winning if I side with town, no chance if I side with cult. I am voting No Lynch. Yes it is scummy, now you see why. I don't need a majority to vote no lynch. I am sticking to my guns. I will not negotiate. Eventually saf will have to put in a time limit.

I appreciate the tentacle, and if / takes it that is his choice. All I am trying to do is turn my 0% chance of Victory into a slim chance of victory. I have never lost a game as scum and I don't intend to start now.

[mandalorian2298]

Oh, and Mandy, if you join my no-lynch wagon I will promise to not kill you.

Many have tried, mate. Give me your best shot.

[nagerous]

Actually a no lynch seems better. With no lynch, the town is forced to use their NK on you Victor. Then, since cult still outnumbers mafia they have to use their next kill on another cult. I have no chance of winning if I side with town, no chance if I side with cult. I am voting No Lynch. Yes it is scummy, now you see why. I don't need a majority to vote no lynch. I am sticking to my guns. I will not negotiate. Eventually saf will have to put in a time limit.

I appreciate the tentacle, and if / takes it that is his choice. All I am trying to do is turn my 0% chance of Victory into a slim chance of victory. I have never lost a game as scum and I don't intend to start now.

You kinda lost Lebowski.

Either way, both sides have arguments. I'm not adverse to playing to the deadline and forcing a no lynch. I think lynching a cultie, either edoc or me would be a fairer compromise for you guys but if you'd rather no lynch it works better for us.

[DoomYoshi]

It works better for everyone but town. Since town lost Mandy, it works better for the majority.

[Falkomagno]

No Doom, is one problem at the time...you have night to act, but first we have to solve the cult problem. You can not win with cult becaasue as soon as they try to recruit both of you, u will be dead as Mr. Squirrel. If we hang Davy I think some character will be endgamed, and the scenario will change. We can not afford to oversight the cult problem right now. If Mandy joins to the wagon, we only need your vote or / vote or even Edoc vote so still we can act together in this case, and see what happens after...

[sheepofdumb]

Welp, I figured Mandy was lying. Cult is set to win. I will take you on your offer victor. Did my best to win it for the town but you can't always get what you want can you?
Unvote vote edoc