Just some Lyncher Mafia-Lyncher Wins, everyone dies horribly

by **edocsil** on Tue Apr 26, 2011 8:08 pm

Wait what!?! He was supposed to be endgamed, not have everyone else get endgamed!!!!! Then I kill someone in the night, that combined with my NK would leave just me and one VT alive and my victory. What is this bullshit? So as soon as the wrong person was put at l-2 the whole fucking game is over? I assumed it wasn't to be the case because of how idiotic that scenario was. I misjudged.

by **Commander9** on Tue Apr 26, 2011 8:11 pm

edocsil wrote:Wait what!?! He was supposed to be endgamed, not have everyone else get endgamed!!!!! Then I kill someone in the night, that combined with my NK would leave just me and one VT alive and my victory. What is this bullshit? So as soon as the wrong person was put at l-2 the whole fucking game is over? I assumed it wasn't to be the case because of how idiotic that scenario was. I misjudged.

To be fair, rules specifically stated what would happen...

by **pancakemix** on Tue Apr 26, 2011 8:17 pm

edocsil wrote:Wait what!?! He was supposed to be endgamed, not have everyone else get endgamed!!!!! Then I kill someone in the night, that combined with my NK would leave just me and one VT alive and my victory. What is this bullshit? So as soon as the wrong person was put at l-2 the whole fucking game is over? I assumed it wasn't to be the case because of how idiotic that scenario was. I misjudged.

Yeah, lyncher's kinda dumb like that.

by **Haggis_McMutton** on Tue Apr 26, 2011 8:18 pm

edocsil wrote:Wait what!?! He was supposed to be endgamed, not have everyone else get endgamed!!!!! Then I kill someone in the night, that combined with my NK would leave just me and one VT alive and my victory. What is this bullshit? So as soon as the wrong person was put at l-2 the whole fucking game is over? I assumed it wasn't to be the case because of how idiotic that scenario was. I misjudged.

Sorry mate
1. it was in the OP( and I actually bolded it

):

1 mafia
1 lyncher
3 vanilla townies

Lyncher has one of the townies as his target, this person shall be known as the lynchee. The lynchee doesn't know he is the lynchee, and isn't revealed as the lynchee if night killed.

Win conditions:
mafia wins if it's just him and one townie left
lyncher wins if he's alive when his target is lynched, if this happens the game ends
town wins when both the lyncher and the mafia are gone OR if it's just the lyncher and the lynchee left(the lyncher is endgamed in this scenario).

If the lynchee is night killed and the lyncher is still alive, he becomes a vanilla townie as well.

2. If it'd happened that way, then basically a lyncher win would almost always mean a scum win as well (minus the 1/5 shot you get lynched D1), gives you an unfair advantage.
Hell assuming the 1 mafia, 1 lyncher, 1 town situation, you guys could just lynch the town and both win ...

Edit: fastposted.

by **Haggis_McMutton** on Tue Apr 26, 2011 8:23 pm

I mean, assuming game continues, look at your odds:

lynchee killed D1 - you win
lyncher killed D1 - 2/3 odds you win
VT killed D1 - more than 2/3 odds you win (cause if you NK the other VT, your win is guaranteed, like I said above, and if you don't, you still have 2/3 odds).

Yeah, that'd be pretty unfair.

by **edocsil** on Wed Apr 27, 2011 5:57 am

It was in the op, I just missed it. My fault there. I just don't like the whole putting the wrong guy at 2 votes causes the game to end.

by **TheSaxlad** on Wed Apr 27, 2011 12:00 pm

TheSaxlad wrote:Yes. I am a vanilla townie just the same as the rest of you, and if commander doesnt come out scum or lyncher I will be very suprised. Im not stupid, you dont play lyncher that agressively because this happens. :/

I truly think he is scum. That is all.

I direct you to this post.

... I was right!