Nostalgia Mafia ~ Commander wins!

[VioIet]

So Vio kinda has ragequit for the day I believe. I have seen her post in other mafia threads, Mod do you suppose you could ask her to come back? if we are going to hang Fir we will need her vote.

My vote has been on Fir from the beginning of Day 2, and I have never unvoted.

The way I counted the votes, he should have already been lynched.

[Commander9]

My vote has been on Fir from the beginning of Day 2, and I have never unvoted.

The way I counted the votes, he should have already been lynched.

Would you mind actually contributing something to the discussion and explaining why you posted what you posted?

[VioIet]

My vote has been on Fir from the beginning of Day 2, and I have never unvoted.

The way I counted the votes, he should have already been lynched.

Would you mind actually contributing something to the discussion and explaining why you posted what you posted?

Why do you insist on antagonizing me?

I thought "I'm done," was loud and clear. I posted because edoc kindly enquired about my status and the game, and wanted me to vote Fir to help move things along. Also all of edoc's posts have been QFT.


And, I think my above post was pretty self-explanatory.

The mod has most likely not checked this game for about 2-3 days. If i have counted the votes correctly, Fir should have already been lynched yesterday and game should have already been over. Therefore there would be no more discussion.

Yesterday:
-I gave my last post -
- I did state i would be in church all day and probably not post when i got back
- I did check the forums when i got back last night- and as this game should have already been over, I did not post here.

I don't really know what you are looking for commander, but I guess you are not going to get it.

[Commander9]

Why do you insist on antagonizing me?

I thought "I'm done," was loud and clear. I posted because edoc kindly enquired about my status and the game, and wanted me to vote Fir to help move things along. Also all of edoc's posts have been QFT.


And, I think my above post was pretty self-explanatory.

The mod has most likely not checked this game for about 2-3 days. If i have counted the votes correctly, Fir should have already been lynched yesterday and game should have already been over. Therefore there would be no more discussion.

Yesterday:
-I gave my last post -
- I did state i would be in church all day and probably not post when i got back
- I did check the forums when i got back last night- and as this game should have already been over, I did not post here.

I don't really know what you are looking for commander, but I guess you are not going to get it.

No one is antagonizing you here, Vio. I just wanted to know why you'd claim busdriver and then make that post. Despite all of your actions, I still think that you're pro-town, but I'd like to understand your line of thought with those posts.

[edocsil]

So Vio kinda has ragequit for the day I believe. I have seen her post in other mafia threads, Mod do you suppose you could ask her to come back? if we are going to hang Fir we will need her vote.

My vote has been on Fir from the beginning of Day 2, and I have never unvoted.

The way I counted the votes, he should have already been lynched.

She is correct, that is 4 votes, Fir has been hung. Let's hope we guessed right.

[VioIet]

The tone of your post calmed me down, so I appreciate that. I think there have been some things that frustrated me and edoc summed it up pretty well in all of his post- but I will quote the following one.

Vio isn't the doc, and if she was the cop she would have claimed so. Also because we know there is a doc the odds of anyone, much less her, being a cop are a slim 1 in 5 I knew what her claimed role was going to be so I said it. It annoyed her so she decided to screw around and claim RB. I really can't say I blame her. The fact that fir (and you) went off so strongly on her was super scummy imo.

Everything in that post as well as his others is QFT, and he reads me well. But also I will mention other things that I was also frustrated with .

I was also a little surprised with how scummy people thought I was for hammering Nag.
It has been brought up a few times by a few different people that it made no sense for me to give a post about how i thought Fir was scummy and keeping my vote on him, then out of nowhere, hammering Nag at the very end of my post.

To me it can be more scummy to keep the conversation divided. I was the lone person bringing up Fir; everyone else was more concerned with edoc and nag. Even if i had inner feelings about Fir's scuminess, I would only be prolonging things and causing a possible distraction by keeping my vote on Fir. Nag was L-1 at the time, Edoc was L-3, and the deadline was close.

From some observations in recent games, one mafia mistake can be to not vote a scummate who is close to being lynched- and instead try to divert attention to someone else, to look as though you are helping the town.

I felt i was basically in a situation where darned if i do and darned if i don't. If i stayed on Fir over nag, that would have looked scummy. So I took the risk and hammered Nag. I knew i might receive some comments for it, but not that much heat. This might be considered WIFOM, but I don't think that the mafia - in a game this small- would hammer someone they knew was a townie. That is just asking to be investigated and or voted. Most likely they would be the ones with the earlier votes, imo. Then wait and let the bandwagon grow larger and larger.

Also I felt frustrated with myself for never knowing when the deadline was. My eyes aren't playing tricks on me. The deadline said it was Saturday night or Sunday Morning and then i look at the thread today and in the title is says Deadline Monday, and that wasn't there before. The mod must have just put that or changed the deadline, but I can't always be wrong about it. Same thing day 1. The deadline was in a few hours and I hammer Nag, and everyone says, no we still had over 24 hours until the deadline.

[Commander9]

@ Vio

I just wanted you to confirm what Edoc said before - and now I'm happy. I really disliked the way Fir tried to manipulate me into hammering, although this still doesn't mean he was scum. I would have still preferred to take a look at Cena/Safari, but as I've said before, I'm fine with Fir too. I guess we will know the results soon enough.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Vote Count
vio (2) - safariguy, fircoal
fircoal (4) - vio, edoc, commander, streaker


Fircoal has been lynched! Scene coming shortly.

[edocsil]

*crosses fingers*

[Mr. Squirrel]

The dull residents of the town all gathered and started to accuse Violet after she claimed to be a bus driver. Because Boringsville had no public transportation, the town members were very close to killing her. However, just as the final vote was about to be cast, Fircoal dropped a spork from his pocket. In seconds the town ambushed him and sporked him to death in return.

Fircoal - Mafia goon has been killed!

Night 2 begins!
Dawn breaks on tuesday.

[Commander9]

The dull residents of the town all gathered and started to accuse Violet after she claimed to be a bus driver. Because Boringsville had no public transportation, the town members were very close to killing her. However, just as the final vote was about to be cast, Fircoal dropped a spork from his pocket. In seconds the town ambushed him and sporked him to death in return.

Fircoal - Mafia goon has been killed!

Night 2 begins!
Dawn breaks on tuesday.

[edocsil]

The dull residents of the town all gathered and started to accuse Violet after she claimed to be a bus driver. Because Boringsville had no public transportation, the town members were very close to killing her. However, just as the final vote was about to be cast, Fircoal dropped a spork from his pocket. In seconds the town ambushed him and sporked him to death in return.

Fircoal - Mafia goon has been killed!

Night 2 begins!
Dawn breaks on tuesday.

I will sleep soundly.

[Streaker]

Boom Headshot

[VioIet]

Whew! That was a relief, especially for me. Had been hounding fir all game.

[Fircoal]

YOU'RE ALL SO MEAN!!!!! ;A;

[VioIet]

Yeah poor Fir. I was quite mean to you this game

[Mr. Squirrel]

Streaker walked the streets that night. He had woken up after having a dream that he had turned into an orb of light and ascended into the sky. He believed that this was some sort of heavenly sign of his goodness.

The mafia man stalking streaker heard this mumbling and decided to grant the doctor his wish. The goon knocked him out, set him on fire, and launched him from a catapult. The doctor's body was never found.

Streaker - Town Doctor has been killed!

Day 3 begins!
With 4 alive, 3 to lynch. Deadline on friday night.


Streaker anticipated his death and asked to ascend into the sky in the night scene. I saw it fit to grant him this wish.

[VioIet]

Hmm, I didn't see that at all.

Did anyone else have a hunch that streaker was the doctor? And I guess the doc couldn't protect himself- which seems odd to me. I've always protected myself when i was the doctor. Guess I've only been a doctor under mods who allowed self-protection. I didn't know it wasn't allowed in some games.

This leaves me, edoc, commander and cena/safari. Of the three, I am most suspicious of safari.

Vote Safari

[edocsil]

Hmm, I didn't see that at all.

Did anyone else have a hunch that streaker was the doctor? And I guess the doc couldn't protect himself- which seems odd to me. I've always protected myself when i was the doctor. Guess I've only been a doctor under mods who allowed self-protection. I didn't know it wasn't allowed in some games.

This leaves me, edoc, commander and cena/safari. Of the three, I am most suspicious of safari.

Vote Safari

Yes, I knew that yesterday. I was hoping the scum didn't notice, but unfortunately they did. My suspicion is on saf too due to his obvious defense of Fircoal. So here is the thing, still lylo. Do we go with saf? Or do we talk for a day and hope a better lead comes up?

[safariguy5]

Yes, obviously my following fircoal automatically paints me as very suspicious. I admit I completely misinterpreted him pushing for the lynch. At this point, I know nothing short of a hidden cop in the game will clear me for sure, but I swear that I'm a VT. Still, if you all want to vote me, that's understandable, I do look pretty bad for supporting chu yesterday.

[edocsil]

Yes, if there was a cop, now would be the time to claim, we would have the game in the bag.

[Commander9]

Hmm, I didn't see that at all.

Did anyone else have a hunch that streaker was the doctor? And I guess the doc couldn't protect himself- which seems odd to me. I've always protected myself when i was the doctor. Guess I've only been a doctor under mods who allowed self-protection. I didn't know it wasn't allowed in some games.

This leaves me, edoc, commander and cena/safari. Of the three, I am most suspicious of safari.

Vote Safari

Yes, I knew that yesterday. I was hoping the scum didn't notice, but unfortunately they did. My suspicion is on saf too due to his obvious defense of Fircoal. So here is the thing, still lylo. Do we go with saf? Or do we talk for a day and hope a better lead comes up?

I've had a feeling that he'd be the doc. He did dropped some hints and I'm not terribly surprised to see him dead. Still, whoever he protected on Night 1 (gah, I would love to know that so much, because then we'd have at least 1 cleared townie), he still guessed it well and for that we've got to thank him. Also, if I'm not mistaken, generally docs can't protected themselves.

As far as lynching goes, there's no hurry just yet - I'm 95% sure he's scum, but there's no point of hammering him before letting him speak. It's LyLo, so we want to be sure before we make your lynch.

Yes, obviously my following fircoal automatically paints me as very suspicious. I admit I completely misinterpreted him pushing for the lynch. At this point, I know nothing short of a hidden cop in the game will clear me for sure, but I swear that I'm a VT. Still, if you all want to vote me, that's understandable, I do look pretty bad for supporting chu yesterday.

Well, if it was a misinterpretation, what were you reasons for wanting a quick hammer?

EDIT:
Edoc, I'm pretty sure we all already know that there is no cop and I honestly don't think you could manipulate scumming into assuming that role.

[safariguy5]

Hmm, I didn't see that at all.

Did anyone else have a hunch that streaker was the doctor? And I guess the doc couldn't protect himself- which seems odd to me. I've always protected myself when i was the doctor. Guess I've only been a doctor under mods who allowed self-protection. I didn't know it wasn't allowed in some games.

This leaves me, edoc, commander and cena/safari. Of the three, I am most suspicious of safari.

Vote Safari

Yes, I knew that yesterday. I was hoping the scum didn't notice, but unfortunately they did. My suspicion is on saf too due to his obvious defense of Fircoal. So here is the thing, still lylo. Do we go with saf? Or do we talk for a day and hope a better lead comes up?

I've had a feeling that he'd be the doc. He did dropped some hints and I'm not terribly surprised to see him dead. Still, whoever he protected on Night 1 (gah, I would love to know that so much, because then we'd have at least 1 cleared townie), he still guessed it well and for that we've got to thank him. Also, if I'm not mistaken, generally docs can't protected themselves.

As far as lynching goes, there's no hurry just yet - I'm 95% sure he's scum, but there's no point of hammering him before letting him speak. It's LyLo, so we want to be sure before we make your lynch.

Yes, obviously my following fircoal automatically paints me as very suspicious. I admit I completely misinterpreted him pushing for the lynch. At this point, I know nothing short of a hidden cop in the game will clear me for sure, but I swear that I'm a VT. Still, if you all want to vote me, that's understandable, I do look pretty bad for supporting chu yesterday.

Well, if it was a misinterpretation, what were you reasons for wanting a quick hammer?

EDIT:
Edoc, I'm pretty sure we all already know that there is no cop and I honestly don't think you could manipulate scumming into assuming that role.

Quite simply, LaL. As I stated yesterday, if you're at L-1, the time for joke claiming is over. We had a good idea what we thought she was and edoc spelled it out, but until I heard it from Vio herself, I cannot count what edoc said as her roleclaim. For her to then go and say that she was a busdriver was a sign of bad faith and general annoyance to me. It's like jokevoting on Day 5, serious circumstances require serious answers. A simple "yes edoc is right" would have been all that was needed. The tone was distasteful to me and really sounded like scum pitching it in.

[VioIet]

Hmm, I still wonder how I missed all the hints that streaker supposedly dropped.

I'm going to go back a do a re-read of Day 2- as I think we will be able to gain something from streaker's posts. For example, streaker would not have placed a vote on the person he protected- so his vote history will be crucial.

Although I think the last mafia is most likely safari, it would have been someone keen and observant enough to understand streaker's hints- so that fact doesn't clear commander or edoc either. Both admitted to understanding that streaker was the doctor.

Not saying that you aren't keen and observant saf- of course you are- its just that i hope the point i was trying to make was clear in this post. Its possible our last scum is someone who has played quite well and seems very town motivated.

[Streaker]

Great, I got my own scene
Though I still think the other one would be more interesting...

Go town!