POTC Mafia Game Thread Day 7 Town Win! Premium goes to Sully

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

Mandy(2)- PCM, Fircoal
Fircoal(1)-Mandy
got tonkaed(3)- Nark, Nag, Iliad
Falkomagno(2)-/, Streaker
Nagerous(2)- got tonkaed, Mr. Squirrel
Victor(1)- Haggis
edocsil(1)- Saxlad
Vio(1)- strike wolf
Haggis(1)- Falkomagno
River_Shark(1)- edocsil
Commander9(1)- VioIet
AnarkistsDream(1)- Comm9

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Deadline is on March 31st.

[strike wolf]

unvote semiserious vote victor he's been on at least twice since game started but hasn't confirmed.

[nagerous]

Victor's in this game?!

unvote vote victor

[edocsil]

Victor's in this game?!

unvote vote victor

I wagon that. He has annoyed me severely.

UNVOTE VOTE VICTOR

[Commander9]

unvote semiserious vote victor he's been on at least twice since game started but hasn't confirmed.

FoS Strike.

Isn't it one of the biggest scumtells when someone goes for an easy target (lynch) day 1? I'm even more worried how fast the BW formed. If what, I'm sure Safari will replace someone who hasn't opened his role PM - no need to use him as our lynch.

[strike wolf]

Depends on what you consider an easy lynch. Victor always acts erratically which often gets him a pass often when someone would regularly be lynched. I'm not so much saying lynch him right now so much as saying he has been ignoring this thread at the very least I want to try to draw his attention to the thread. I do fully suppport a small wagon on victor but I would agree its too early to fully press for his lynch (though if he continues to come on line but not post in this thread than I'll continue to put more pressure on him).

[got tonkaed]

Theres obviously nothing wrong with putting a vote out there. Should it get close to a lynch situation then we might want to take a step back and see why we are doing it.

The whole goal is to get victor to come in and play the game, if it does that, then a quick bandwagon can be said to have done its job and everyone can move on to the next target.

[Streaker]

It's a big game, and with a lynch at 11 there's nothing wrong with a wagon. Victor isn't active, and it's obvious he is ignoring this game.
At the very least we can draw his attention to the game, and if he doesn't show up or get replaced we can hang him. If he does show up the wagon moves...

I know i'm repetitive of above posts, but it's how I feel.

Unvote, vote Victor

[VioIet]

People keep mentioning that when Victor comes to the thread and posts, then we will move on to another target. I agree- except that- we don't exactly have another target. Victor is it. Until now, the game had been in the joke vote stage- and this is the welcome transition.

With a big game, and at this rate, and knowing Victor- he is probably already doomed to be the first lynch.

[got tonkaed]

People keep mentioning that when Victor comes to the thread and posts, then we will move on to another target. I agree- except that- we don't exactly have another target. Victor is it. Until now, the game had been in the joke vote stage- and this is the welcome transition.

With a big game, and at this rate, and knowing Victor- he is probably already doomed to be the first lynch.

This isnt exactly a problem though. You mention the idea of not having another target, when in fact we have plenty of other options. There is just as much of a reason to jump off a bandwagon should he arrive in a prompt fashion and move on to another target. Just because it is day 1 doesnt mean we have to throw a lynch out there as soon as we decide to stop joke voting.

[Commander9]

I'm sorry, but I don't agree with you all - Safari got reserves for exactly thing like this and if Victor doesn't show up, we replace him. I'd rather build up a good day 1 with discussions rather than just "Oh, lets go lynch Sully" and move on to Night 1.

[edocsil]

I'm sorry, but I don't agree with you all - Safari got reserves for exactly thing like this and if Victor doesn't show up, we replace him. I'd rather build up a good day 1 with discussions rather than just "Oh, lets go lynch Sully" and move on to Night 1.

He is of course right. If anyone else joined the wagon it would be quite suspicious. I can't speak for the others, but I (joke) voted for him because he has annoyed me in the PB mafia that I am hosting.

[nagerous]

People keep mentioning that when Victor comes to the thread and posts, then we will move on to another target. I agree- except that- we don't exactly have another target. Victor is it. Until now, the game had been in the joke vote stage- and this is the welcome transition.

With a big game, and at this rate, and knowing Victor- he is probably already doomed to be the first lynch.

No one is saying he is doomed to be the first lynch already. That's an extremely pessimistic thing to say - the point of the first wagon is to move the game from joke votes into a more frank and reasoned discussion. The man on the first wagon is rarely the man who is first lynched. Victor is a good target for the first wagon because of his activity elsewhere yet his inactivity here, the fact he collects 4 or so votes from 21 people does not instantly mean he is doomed.

[Commander9]

No one is saying he is doomed to be the first lynch already. That's an extremely pessimistic thing to say - the point of the first wagon is to move the game from joke votes into a more frank and reasoned discussion. The man on the first wagon is rarely the man who is first lynched. Victor is a good target for the first wagon because of his activity elsewhere yet his inactivity here, the fact he collects 4 or so votes from 21 people does not instantly mean he is doomed.

He's not active in pretty much any mafia games at this moment....

[edocsil]

No one is saying he is doomed to be the first lynch already. That's an extremely pessimistic thing to say - the point of the first wagon is to move the game from joke votes into a more frank and reasoned discussion. The man on the first wagon is rarely the man who is first lynched. Victor is a good target for the first wagon because of his activity elsewhere yet his inactivity here, the fact he collects 4 or so votes from 21 people does not instantly mean he is doomed.

He's not active in pretty much any mafia games at this moment....

Other places on CC, you are right, he is absent here in the mafia forum.

[strike wolf]

You may be right. I haven't looked that far into it. Regardless I'm not moving my vote until he starts posting or someone replaces him.

[safariguy5]

Yes, Victor has opened his role pm, and yes I have prodded him and River_Shark yesterday. Will wait and see if he responds, then am going to replace him/them.

[Commander9]

Yes, Victor has opened his role pm, and yes I have prodded him and River_Shark yesterday. Will wait and see if he responds, then am going to replace him/them.

Perfect. Thank you, mod.

[Anarkistsdream]

This idea was too awesome to not be followed through with now...

Unvote

I'll see who replaces and who finally shows up before I vote anybody.

[Commander9]

Unvote. Vote Streaker.;;

My first semi-serious vote goes to Streaker for being the 4th person on the BW (just a casual vote because people voted above him) and encouraging others to join (even if it wasn't completely serious.).

[safariguy5]

Announcement

freezie has replaced River_Shark.

Victor tells me RL got a bit hectic over the weekend, should be back ASAP.

[Victor Sullivan]

Yup yup. Sorry, I forgot to confirm

I'll get caught up soon

In the meantime I'll vote Commander9 for teh lolz.

[VioIet]

We are just a tad bit pass the joke vote stage Sully, but glad you decided to show up anyway

Will be a much more fun game with you active. Hope things in RL have calmed down as well.

And welcome freezie. Been a few months since I've seen you in mafia.

[Anarkistsdream]

Yup yup. Sorry, I forgot to confirm

I'll get caught up soon

In the meantime I'll vote Commander9 for teh lolz.

It's sad, but you are one of the few people who I trust when you say RL got too hardcore, I believe...

Hope things have calmed down, bro.

[Haggis_McMutton]

What, joke stage is over already?

Well, ... okay then.

Unvote. Vote Streaker.;;

My first semi-serious vote goes to Streaker for being the 4th person on the BW (just a casual vote because people voted above him) and encouraging others to join (even if it wasn't completely serious.).

Yeah, he did seem a bit too eager, and it's not like there's anything better right now, so vote streaker as well.