Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-TOWN WINS

by **Jace22** on Tue Jan 04, 2011 10:49 pm

ok, cool

by **Victor Sullivan** on Tue Jan 04, 2011 11:33 pm

Wait, what?

by **aage** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 8:07 am

Commander9 wrote:I am fairly sure that Jace is telling the truth because of the test and TG is also pro-town because he unvoted and didn't let the scum hammer. Because I could have hammered, but I didn't, that leaves us with to players - aage and sully. I've looked through and aage did no claim and I am still not convinced with all of those encouragements he gave us, so I'll vote aage.

Although, I wouldn't mind taking out Sully either seemingly as he didn't participate here at all.

I´ve been rereading the thread and I don´t see a claim from you either. I suppose we all know deep in our hearts that you are town?

vote commander. From what we have now, I think he and victor are our best guess.

As for my role, I'm Abraham Ryes. I'm a doc. I never counterclaimed Victor because without me town would probably be even more at loss right now. However, now I've got a pretty good idea of the role distribution.

by **Commander9** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 11:04 am

OMGUS vote Aage?

Role-claim analysis.

Commander9 - I am Landon Ricketts, Town Bodyguard. I was masoned with Edocsil. (thus why I was so pissed when Safari nuked without any reason). I can protect someone with the cost of my life. Claim in this analysis.

Aage - Abraham Ryes, Town Doctor. Claim here.

Sully - Uncle, claimed CPR Doc (haven't stated the name of the role). Claimed here.

Jace22 - Bonnie Mcfarlane,Town Priest. Claim here.

TG - Nigel West Dickens, Town Politician. Claim here.

I honestly don't think Jace is lying, so he's assured townie for me. TG's character doesn't look quite right, but his actions are screaming townie.

Sully has done lots stuff that wouldn't and shouldn't be considered pro-town and I still think he's scum, but after aage's claim, I definitely choose him as first.

Aage is a bit different case - he claims to be Abraham Reyes. According to this ( http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Abraham_Reyes ) I just can't see him being a doctor. I just can't... So my vote stays.

by **TA1LGUNN3R** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 12:22 pm

Hm good theory on aage's character, Commander. It doesn't fit doc at all. The link says he's a guerrilla who is known for sacrificing his comrades, and later becomes a tyrant. Seems good enough for me. Can you explain aage?

-Tails

by **Jace22** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 1:48 pm

As I can't lynch, I'll vote aage now, putting him L-1. Now no one else should vote till aage tries to defend.

by **aage** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 1:51 pm

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:Hm good theory on aage's character, Commander. It doesn't fit doc at all. The link says he's a guerrilla who is known for sacrificing his comrades, and later becomes a tyrant. Seems good enough for me. Can you explain aage?

-Tails

You're just quoting all the negative stuff you can find there.
My story mentions something about rescueing John Marston. Since I don't know the game I have no idea where and when that is, but I guess someone does. Is there anyone alive who knows the game?

by **aage** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 1:54 pm

Commander9 wrote:Commander9 - I am Landon Ricketts, Town Bodyguard. I was masoned with Edocsil. (thus why I was so pissed when Safari nuked without any reason). I can protect someone with the cost of my life. Claim in this analysis.

According to what I can find on the regular wikipedia (that rdr wiki link takes a long, long time to work and reads awfully on this computer...) the part of "at the cost of your own life" doesn't make any sense.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ch ... Redemption

by **Victor Sullivan** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 1:56 pm

vote aage. Your role claim doesnt make sense, as previously stated. Lets move on.

by **Commander9** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:19 pm

aage wrote:According to what I can find on the regular wikipedia (that rdr wiki link takes a long, long time to work and reads awfully on this computer...) the part of "at the cost of your own life" doesn't make any sense.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ch ... Redemption

You're not even defending and explained your character, rather look for offencive tools. As far as my role goes, it does make sense - I am like a bodyguard and in a gunshot, I could die. The only person I have protected was Edoc, so I don't know specific, but I assume I would take out the offender as well. Well, Sully just finished you, so I guess we will soon the truth.

by **aage** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:21 pm

Commander9 wrote:The only person I have protected was Edoc,

So when has that been? :roll:

Edoc hasn't survived a single day.

by **Commander9** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:35 pm

aage wrote:So when has that been? Edoc hasn't survived a single day.

Hmm, apparently you are right. I was almost completely sure that I've sent PM about that. Anyways, any comments about your own rule then?

by **Victor Sullivan** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:41 pm

elect Sully, by the way :mrgreen:

by **Commander9** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:42 pm

Victor Sullivan wrote:elect Sully, by the way

Lets wait till the results from Naxus..

by **TA1LGUNN3R** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 2:56 pm

Damnit Sully I was hoping for more discussion on this.

-Tails

by **Commander9** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 4:04 pm

TA1LGUNN3R wrote:Damnit Sully I was hoping for more discussion on this.

-Tails

This is why I have said that he hasn't been all that helpful to the town...

by **naxus** on Wed Jan 05, 2011 11:30 pm

of the five remaining townspeople, a few were still pointing fingers. A man was captured and a hasty trial set up. He was sentenced to death.

VC-1-Aage
Vc-2

Vote count Mayor
Victor(1)-Victor

4 alive, 3 to lynch

by **Commander9** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 1:40 am

Well, since the game has not ended, I assume we either lynched the scum or there was only one left. We don't have any investigative roles, so I don't honestly see a reason to go to the night stage. I honestly don't think we'll find any new information from this (barring the true aage's role), so we might as well finish it today. As I've pointed, I already know my suggestion, but let see what you guys can point out.

Naxus, if there would be equal amounts of citizens and players, would the game have ended?

by **TA1LGUNN3R** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 2:40 am

Well there is one scummy left.

Victor wrote:How about this - I won't use my action tonight. That way, I can't make excuses, right? I'm just saying, it'd be much better to try and lynch scum than lynch potentially the only doc.

After his bizarre claim of CPR doc, he offers this. Seems like a loophole he was trying to create.

vote Victor

-Tails

by **Commander9** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 11:35 am

Victor, got anything to clear about your role?

by **Victor Sullivan** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:25 pm

Commander9 wrote:Victor, got anything to clear about your role?

I dont know what you mean, I told you everything, I think...

by **Commander9** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:33 pm

Victor Sullivan wrote:
Commander9 wrote:Victor, got anything to clear about your role?

I dont know what you mean, I told you everything, I think...

As far as I remember, we never got the exact name of your role...

by **Victor Sullivan** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:35 pm

Commander9 wrote:
Victor Sullivan wrote:
Commander9 wrote:Victor, got anything to clear about your role?

I dont know what you mean, I told you everything, I think...

As far as I remember, we never got the exact name of your role...

Im Uncle, a CPR doc, essentially. Idk what youre looking for...

by **Jace22** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:37 pm

I think Uncle is the actual name of the character. see here: http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Uncle

by **Commander9** on Thu Jan 06, 2011 5:39 pm

Jace22 wrote:I think Uncle is the actual name of the character. see here: http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Uncle

Yup, this.

A role name of CPR doc wouldn't make any sense due to the time this took place.

Vote Sully.

Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-TOWN WINS

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Re: Red Dead Redemption Game Thread-Day 2

Who is online