Quentin Tarantino Mafia Night 3 (Mafia Win!)

[Haggis_McMutton]

Wait, what's the case against me again?

Well after rereading, haggis mostly looked like an inexperienced newbie. The one thing that stood out to me as far as him possibly being scum was the heavy use of adjectives like weak and farfetched in his arguments against people and the fact that while he's presented logic and cases he hasn't deviated much from general suspicions already brought forward.

Erm, I used adjectives. And i didn't start any radical wagons(maybe that's consistent with being a newbie?).
Also, I did start the tails wagon and was the only one to follow up on Commander's questioning of ga7.

Also:

FOS Haggis starting a case then wagonning, not the first time either. Coupled with heavy submarining, one of the players left the most shady so far, quite possibly regular mafia or SK.

Erm, I'm suspicious because I both started cases and wagonned? So basically, to quote mandy, I'm suspicious because I played the game, right?

Tbh, the whole Violet thing is very weird, why would the mod let someone who had that info be a replacement? But as long as no one counterclaims edoc there's no reason to doubt him.

I think it's pretty important at the moment for Violet and Victor to show up, they may have vital info.

[Victor Sullivan]

Well after rereading, haggis mostly looked like an inexperienced newbie. The one thing that stood out to me as far as him possibly being scum was the heavy use of adjectives like weak and farfetched in his arguments against people and the fact that while he's presented logic and cases he hasn't deviated much from general suspicions already brought forward.

Strange... Haggis has never acted newby before. I am gonna read up and see if I agree, as you may be on to something...

[ga7]

Erm, I'm suspicious because I both started cases and wagonned? So basically, to quote mandy, I'm suspicious because I played the game, right?

Err you misunderstood, I said you made some cases but then were hopping on whatever different wagon going on. Meaning you didn't really care either way as long as there was a townie lynched and that you were just "acting" like playing

Frankly Saf should never have let Vio replace if she knew a role, but now that the deed is done it is indeed more likely for her to be town, though it could be 3rd party too. Either way potentially unbalancing =/

Unvote Vote Haggis

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

VioIet-1 (strike wolf)
haggis-3 (naxus, edocsil, ga7)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline next Monday.

If VioIet doesn't come back, I could ask for a replacement although this late in the game, I'm leaning towards a modkill.

[Haggis_McMutton]

Strange... Haggis has never acted newby before. I am gonna read up and see if I agree, as you may be on to something...

When this started it was my second game. I wasn't born with knowledge of mafia, you know

And, fine, I'll claim, not much point in keeping it secret.

I'm Hugo Stieglitz, Vanilla Townie.

I've never been lynched while playing town, don't ruin my record guys.

[ga7]

Ugh, as I suspected claims won't help... Doesn't bring anything to the table one way or another. The noob excuse doesn't hold much water to me though as even in your first games you seemed to have a more decent grasp than in this; the holidays period explains at least the inactivity.
Well, we can't afford a no lynch, so we have till Monday to figure something out.

Edoc: cop
Naxus: doc
ga7: pro-town hero
Vio: assuming town...
Nag: insane doc? don't protect either way, and nice fake claim if it's one Just feels odd that in a game with few power roles there could be another doc but if there's no roleblocker it could explain Edoc's night 1 blocking
Tails: don't quite trust him
Strike: striked me as town just for the amount of effort he put in but might be playing us
Victor: f*ck knows, scummy
Haggis: claims VT.

I dunno if we have time to pressure Victor or just go through with Haggis, more input is needed anyway.

[strike wolf]

I have to be honest. I wasn't really expecting anyone to buy my argument on haggis I mean the part about "use of adjectives" especially was a bit tongue in cheek. He could be scum and his response to the comment made me wonder a bit but I feel more comfortable voting someone else who took the bait. unvote vote victor your response seemed like a cheap bandwagon response and the person you replaced (aog) as well as yourself to a lesser extent have had a lot of fluff posts and not many contributions to cases against people.

[nagerous]

Strange... Haggis has never acted newby before. I am gonna read up and see if I agree, as you may be on to something...

When this started it was my second game. I wasn't born with knowledge of mafia, you know

And, fine, I'll claim, not much point in keeping it secret.

I'm Hugo Stieglitz, Vanilla Townie.

I've never been lynched while playing town, don't ruin my record guys.

[img]
http://lh5.ggpht.com/_ZndmD7CcrNs/Sz6c9 ... iglitz.jpg[/img]

[nagerous]

Strange... Haggis has never acted newby before. I am gonna read up and see if I agree, as you may be on to something...

When this started it was my second game. I wasn't born with knowledge of mafia, you know

And, fine, I'll claim, not much point in keeping it secret.

I'm Hugo Stieglitz, Vanilla Townie.

I've never been lynched while playing town, don't ruin my record guys.

[edocsil]

Strange... Haggis has never acted newby before. I am gonna read up and see if I agree, as you may be on to something...

When this started it was my second game. I wasn't born with knowledge of mafia, you know

And, fine, I'll claim, not much point in keeping it secret.

I'm Hugo Stieglitz, Vanilla Townie.

I've never been lynched while playing town, don't ruin my record guys.

Did some research, there is so little about hugo on the net that I wouldn't doubt his VT status.

[edocsil]

Ugh, as I suspected claims won't help... Doesn't bring anything to the table one way or another. The noob excuse doesn't hold much water to me though as even in your first games you seemed to have a more decent grasp than in this; the holidays period explains at least the inactivity.
Well, we can't afford a no lynch, so we have till Monday to figure something out.

Edoc: cop
Naxus: doc
ga7: pro-town hero
Vio: assuming town...
Nag: insane doc? don't protect either way, and nice fake claim if it's one Just feels odd that in a game with few power roles there could be another doc but if there's no roleblocker it could explain Edoc's night 1 blocking
Tails: don't quite trust him
Strike: striked me as town just for the amount of effort he put in but might be playing us
Victor: f*ck knows, scummy
Haggis: claims VT.

I dunno if we have time to pressure Victor or just go through with Haggis, more input is needed anyway.

To me this leaves victor, no input to help the town really, bit o BW and the rest of the scum tells

[edocsil]

Ugh, as I suspected claims won't help... Doesn't bring anything to the table one way or another. The noob excuse doesn't hold much water to me though as even in your first games you seemed to have a more decent grasp than in this; the holidays period explains at least the inactivity.
Well, we can't afford a no lynch, so we have till Monday to figure something out.

Edoc: cop
Naxus: doc
ga7: pro-town hero
Vio: assuming town...
Nag: insane doc? don't protect either way, and nice fake claim if it's one Just feels odd that in a game with few power roles there could be another doc but if there's no roleblocker it could explain Edoc's night 1 blocking
Tails: don't quite trust him
Strike: striked me as town just for the amount of effort he put in but might be playing us
Victor: f*ck knows, scummy
Haggis: claims VT.

I dunno if we have time to pressure Victor or just go through with Haggis, more input is needed anyway.

To me this leaves victor, no input to help the town really, bit o BW and the rest of the scum tells

EBWOP vote victor

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

Victor-2 (strike wolf, edocsil)
haggis-2 (naxus, ga7)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline next Monday.

I remind everyone to remember to unvote before revoting. edocsil I'll count it this time, but next time the vote will not be changed.

[Haggis_McMutton]

All right. Let's get Victor to talk then.

vote Victor

[nagerous]

3 votes should be enough for now, victor talk...

[Victor Sullivan]

Vote Haggis. Youre welcome Vanilla claim doesnt cut it for me.

[nagerous]

Vote Haggis. Youre welcome Vanilla claim doesnt cut it for me.

Going to elaborate here? You're under pressure yourself..

[strike wolf]

Well I guess that's one way to respond to a bandwagon...I won't say its the right way but it's a way...

[Victor Sullivan]

Vote Haggis. Youre welcome Vanilla claim doesnt cut it for me.

Going to elaborate here? You're under pressure yourself..

Oh, am I? OR AM I??? Hehehehee...

Lol, in all seriousness, Vanilla town is a weak claim and would be little loss if he was actually telling the truth. Do I sound scummy? You may think so, but Im merely stating the truth.

[nagerous]

er.. how about a defence/claim of your own?

[Victor Sullivan]

er.. how about a defence/claim of your own?

With 3 votes?

[TA1LGUNN3R]

er.. how about a defence/claim of your own?

With 3 votes?

With 5 needed. Also, we're pretty close to endgame here. Even a VT is vitally important.

-Tails

[Victor Sullivan]

Very well: I am Aldo Raines, Town Bulletproof Bodyguard.

[nagerous]

Very well: I am Aldo Raines, Town Bulletproof Bodyguard.

Well it is much a stronger claim than Hugo to say the least. So bulletproof bodyguard as in you will kill anyone who targets the person who you are protecting or that you like an ultimate bodyguard in the fact that you take the hit and don't die?

[ga7]

I call BS. I'd also like to know the full extent of your role before I vote though.