Nashville Mafia Wars Mafia Night 3_Terror Subsides

[aage]

:lol: You guys are hilarious! Mr. E = Mystery (And yes, it was a reference)

Call me crazy, but I still think he knows what he's talking about.

-Sully

I admit, I like the wordplay


Anyone who pushes for night in this game will IMO be scum. Night will be bloody as hell since we have 2 mafia kills, and ALL night kill abilities that have ever been invented. Quoting the "in"-topic:

This mafia includes no vanilla townies

I don't feel like being shot, eaten and strung up just yet. Anyone who feels differently about this deserves a FoS.

[cena-rules]

So then, what do you propose?

[aage]

We have a lot of suspicion already. It's just that no-one is responding to it. You for one might want to explain why you feel like entering a blood bath called N1.

[oldrisky44]

ok aage, everybody here has posted suspicions and most have defended themselves. We all know there are 2 mafia factions and we figure they will be out for each other on the first night to tip the scales in their favor. With one godfather out of the picture, one scum is already nervous and probably anxious to hit the other mob.

If you have something convincing that will help us lynch scum, spit it out.

[lalaland]

We have a lot of suspicion already. It's just that no-one is responding to it. You for one might want to explain why you feel like entering a blood bath called N1.

And remember, it's not like we're gonna get out of Night 1... it's inevitable.

[cena-rules]

We have a lot of suspicion already. It's just that no-one is responding to it. You for one might want to explain why you feel like entering a blood bath called N1.

And remember, it's not like we're gonna get out of Night 1... it's inevitable.

Actually what I was going to post. If we go in now, we have 1 mafia and 0 town down. Which by any standard is a great day

[aage]

We have 1 mafia dead, but it didn't bring us anywhere...

[lalaland]

We have 1 mafia dead, but it didn't bring us anywhere...

It brought us to a point where we have one less scum to hunt down...

[aage]

We have 1 mafia dead, but it didn't bring us anywhere...

It brought us to a point where we have one less scum to hunt down...

Yes, the Modkill was in Town advantage. But what did we gain? Do we have a lead? Do we have anything we can use before going into this night? I don't think so.

[AceArtemis]

So cena, we already killed one mafia, so you are against trying to kill more mafia? Are you mafia who just wants to get to night so you can kill someone?

We gotta get greedy here. Let's not stop at only one mafia.

[aage]

I agree and I also believe Cena has some kind of night ability. Otherwise he wouldn't be so fond...

I think Lalaland is the right person to vote for at the moment for suggesting no lynch, attacking no lynch and then supporting no lynch. Vote lalaland.

[spiesr]

We all know there are 2 mafia factions and we figure they will be out for each other on the first night to tip the scales in their favor. With one godfather out of the picture, one scum is already nervous and probably anxious to hit the other mob.

While I agree that the scum factions will probably find it in their best interest to eliminate the opposing faction as quickly as possible, I have to ask how you expect them to find members of the other group to target tonight? It would be game breaking for the two groups to know the members of the other from the start. Unless they have cops or something in their group the only way they will be able to determine who is in the other group will be looking at what was posted during the day. As it stands if they just pick someone to kill they appear to be more likely to hit a town member than someone from the other scum group. In theory, if you want them to be able to find the other group to kill at night you will have to provide as much information in the day's posts as possible. So basically what I am saying is that you should not these scum groups to be primarily killing each other at night. They are liable to kill more townies than scum.

[oldrisky44]

spiesr makes a good point, however we are still no closer to a viable target. So far to me there are two players I will not be voting for...me and edocsil. That leaves me with 9 possible choices. The two most suspicious to me still are duday and fircoal; though neither of them seem to be attracting much attention from you more experienced players. lala's waffling seems semi-scummy, but she makes reasonable arguments and I too am conflicted with the choices so far. We have very little solid evidence to go on, and this is the first day. How much hard evidence do we expect to get?

Can we get an updated vote count?

[colton24]

I'm tired, but I'll get a vote count out there soon

[aage]

Guys, I don't know how many multiple scum faction mafia games you've been in, but I'll tell you, the first few nights are massacres. Townwise. If the mod is good he will have made up for that with a largish majority of town members and multiple ways of finding whether someone is scum or no.


Still voting Lalaland. His behaviour speaks for itself. And if this helps you guys overcome any doubt... there's no town power role we cannot miss. That is, if it gets as far as lynching without Lalaland claiming some fancy power role.

[colton24]

Vote Count
Fircoal(2)-freezie, lalaland
duday53(1)-AceArtemis
spiesr(2)-???, spiesr
no lunch(1)-cena-rules
lalaland(1)-aage

Not voting: Fircoal, duday53, edocsil, oldrisky44

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch

[oldrisky44]

Vote Count
Fircoal(2)-freezie, lalaland
duday53(1)-AceArtemis
spiesr(2)-???, spiesr
no lunch(1)-cena-rules
lalaland(1)-aage

Not voting: Fircoal, duday53, edocsil, oldrisky44

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch

Is spiesr really voting for himself? What is that?

[aage]

Is spiesr really voting for himself? What is that?

no. its a mistake.

[aage]

Is spiesr really voting for himself? What is that?

no. its a mistake.

or someone is vote-controlling.

[oldrisky44]

duday, is there any reason I should not vote for you?

[spiesr]

spiesr(2)-???, spiesr

Is spiesr really voting for himself? What is that?

That is interesting, I want to be voting for lalaland. I have not been informed that my vote has been stolen, nor have I changed it to myself myself...

[edocsil]

Do we want to just bandwagon Duday for not showing up? Nothing pisses me off like people who sign up and don't play.

[colton24]

Mod mistake spiesr....
Looking for a replacement

[colton24]

Vote Count
Fircoal(2)-freezie, lalaland
duday53(1)-AceArtemis
no lunch(1)-cena-rules
lalaland(3)-aage, spiesr, ???

Not voting: Fircoal, duday53, edocsil, oldrisky44

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch

[AceArtemis]

I will Unvote because I don't want to lynch someone who the mod is trying to replace. If colton isn't able to replace him, he'll get modkilled anyway.

And I will Vote: lalaland to put him at L-2 and hopefully force him to defend himself. Since the secret vote is already on this bandwagon, we don't have to worry about a secret vote quickhammer.