An Interesting Hypotetical (Part 4)

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:40 pm

Would you torture to death a baby in order to bring peace and happiness to all humanity?

This is a question my Ethics teacher brought up today.

Any comments?

(as always feel free to say f*ck you Vincent M) :lol:

by **hecter** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:42 pm

No I wouldn't. The means in which the peace brought would make it ill gotten and therfore wrong. I voted f*ck you for bringing up such a horrible hypothetical.

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:43 pm

hecter wrote:No I wouldn't. The means in which the peace brought would make it ill gotten and therfore wrong. I voted f*ck you for bringing up such a horrible hypothetical.

Ah Hecter always votes f*ck you Vincent M

by **static_ice** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:44 pm

I would... the baby would be a sacrifice for all humanity and I would ask the parents of course...hell if it were my kid I would give him/her up for humanity...I would even give myself up if it meant that the whole world lives in peace for the rest of time...

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:44 pm

Vincent M wrote:
hecter wrote:No I wouldn't. The means in which the peace brought would make it ill gotten and therfore wrong. I voted f*ck you for bringing up such a horrible hypothetical.

Ah Hecter always votes f*ck you Vincent M

Hecter I would like an opinion one day from you

by **hecter** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 12:46 pm

Vincent M wrote:
Vincent M wrote:
hecter wrote:No I wouldn't. The means in which the peace brought would make it ill gotten and therfore wrong. I voted f*ck you for bringing up such a horrible hypothetical.

Ah Hecter always votes f*ck you Vincent M

Hecter I would like an opinion one day from you

I think I might have given an opinion of one of you hypotheticals, but not sure which.

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:52 pm

static_ice wrote:I would... the baby would be a sacrifice for all humanity and I would ask the parents of course...hell if it were my kid I would give him/her up for humanity...I would even give myself up if it meant that the whole world lives in peace for the rest of time...

Not that I am a bible geek but it sounds like the bible :shock:

by **millej11** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:54 pm

Anyone who says no is either a liberal or mentally handicapped, not that there's a big difference.

by **static_ice** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:57 pm

Vincent M wrote:
static_ice wrote:I would... the baby would be a sacrifice for all humanity and I would ask the parents of course...hell if it were my kid I would give him/her up for humanity...I would even give myself up if it meant that the whole world lives in peace for the rest of time...

Not that I am a bible geek but it sounds like the bible

i really hate the kind of ppl that press the bible on your lap (even though I am kinda christian...)

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:58 pm

millej11 wrote:Anyone who says no is either a liberal or mentally handicapped, not that there's a big difference.

Well i can see why someone wont kill another regardless of the circumstance.

And I don't drool (often ................. :lol:

)

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 1:59 pm

static_ice wrote:
Vincent M wrote:
static_ice wrote:I would... the baby would be a sacrifice for all humanity and I would ask the parents of course...hell if it were my kid I would give him/her up for humanity...I would even give myself up if it meant that the whole world lives in peace for the rest of time...

Not that I am a bible geek but it sounds like the bible

i really hate the kind of ppl that press the bible on your lap (even though I am kinda christian...)

Hey I was just making it known I mean I'm Agnostic

by **static_ice** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:01 pm

Vincent M wrote:
static_ice wrote:
Vincent M wrote:
static_ice wrote:I would... the baby would be a sacrifice for all humanity and I would ask the parents of course...hell if it were my kid I would give him/her up for humanity...I would even give myself up if it meant that the whole world lives in peace for the rest of time...

Not that I am a bible geek but it sounds like the bible

i really hate the kind of ppl that press the bible on your lap (even though I am kinda christian...)

Hey I was just making it known I mean I'm Agnostic

hey I wasn't talking about you... I was just saying that I would never bring the bible in here because I hate the ppl that do...and its cool that you're agnostic...open minded...I like that better than aetheist cuz those guys are just bitches IMO...

by **Vincent M** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:03 pm

static_ice wrote:
Vincent M wrote:
static_ice wrote:
Vincent M wrote:
static_ice wrote:I would... the baby would be a sacrifice for all humanity and I would ask the parents of course...hell if it were my kid I would give him/her up for humanity...I would even give myself up if it meant that the whole world lives in peace for the rest of time...

Not that I am a bible geek but it sounds like the bible

i really hate the kind of ppl that press the bible on your lap (even though I am kinda christian...)

Hey I was just making it known I mean I'm Agnostic

hey I wasn't talking about you... I was just saying that I would never bring the bible in here because I hate the ppl that do...and its cool that you're agnostic...open minded...I like that better than aetheist cuz those guys are just bitches IMO...

*salutes*

by **static_ice** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 2:04 pm

*salutes back*

by **s.xkitten** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 9:11 pm

i voted f*ck you...

by **unriggable** on Fri Mar 02, 2007 9:25 pm

'Those who walk away from the Omelas'

An Interesting Hypotetical (Part 4)

Would you torture to death a baby in order to bring peace and happiness to all humanity?

An Interesting Hypotetical (Part 4)

Who is online