Cuban Revolution Mafia. The revolution is here!

[spiesr]

There is three factions besides the peasants. why was only one person killed? I know he was targeted by two factions, but why no action by the third? or maybe there was and someone did something about it?

It is possible The Havana mob and The Batista Regime might not both have killing powers.

The Havana mob calls the hits. they get a night kill, like a normal mafia, but they loose if they are eliminated, or if Batista's Regime is eliminated.

Batista's regime are the people who steal and beat up on the peasants, using various roles which I will not disclose yet. They win if the 26th of july movement is eliminated.

[safariguy5]

About his claim, I think its total BS.We lynched a Peasant day one and NK another one.Theres only what 12ish people in this game, so by claiming VT your almost assured a night kill against yourself as if you are a VT and they NK you then there would be only 1, or 2 or maybe even none left of the VT.

Why would either side purposefully target a vanilla peasant for a night kill? The scum would rather kill a member of the revolution and the revolution would rather kill a scum member.

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???

Did anyone else notice this bit here? Looks like a secret voter/double voter/politician. Is anyone missing their vote?

Uhm, no haven't noticed it. Very strange.. but why would a secret voter voter for Rainbow? If the secret voter is evil, he would have waited and placed the last vote on Voden (If vodean is not evil himself). If ??? is good, he might be the seer and point us towards Rainbow. But.. rather strange thing either way.

FYI, a cop (seer) and a double voter in the same role is incredibly powerful in such a small game and unlikely due to the triple faction setup. It would unbalance the sides.

[Rainbow Eater]

About his claim, I think its total BS.We lynched a Peasant day one and NK another one.Theres only what 12ish people in this game, so by claiming VT your almost assured a night kill against yourself as if you are a VT and they NK you then there would be only 1, or 2 or maybe even none left of the VT.

Why would either side purposefully target a vanilla peasant for a night kill? The scum would rather kill a member of the revolution and the revolution would rather kill a scum member.

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???

Did anyone else notice this bit here? Looks like a secret voter/double voter/politician. Is anyone missing their vote?

Uhm, no haven't noticed it. Very strange.. but why would a secret voter voter for Rainbow? If the secret voter is evil, he would have waited and placed the last vote on Voden (If vodean is not evil himself). If ??? is good, he might be the seer and point us towards Rainbow. But.. rather strange thing either way.

FYI, a cop (seer) and a double voter in the same role is incredibly powerful in such a small game and unlikely due to the triple faction setup. It would unbalance the sides.

The double voter is pretty much guaranteed.

[safariguy5]

About his claim, I think its total BS.We lynched a Peasant day one and NK another one.Theres only what 12ish people in this game, so by claiming VT your almost assured a night kill against yourself as if you are a VT and they NK you then there would be only 1, or 2 or maybe even none left of the VT.

Why would either side purposefully target a vanilla peasant for a night kill? The scum would rather kill a member of the revolution and the revolution would rather kill a scum member.

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???

Did anyone else notice this bit here? Looks like a secret voter/double voter/politician. Is anyone missing their vote?

Uhm, no haven't noticed it. Very strange.. but why would a secret voter voter for Rainbow? If the secret voter is evil, he would have waited and placed the last vote on Voden (If vodean is not evil himself). If ??? is good, he might be the seer and point us towards Rainbow. But.. rather strange thing either way.

FYI, a cop (seer) and a double voter in the same role is incredibly powerful in such a small game and unlikely due to the triple faction setup. It would unbalance the sides.

The double voter is pretty much guaranteed.

I know what you mean, I was saying one person being both a cop and a double voter is incredibly powerful.

[vodean]

About his claim, I think its total BS.We lynched a Peasant day one and NK another one.Theres only what 12ish people in this game, so by claiming VT your almost assured a night kill against yourself as if you are a VT and they NK you then there would be only 1, or 2 or maybe even none left of the VT.

Why would either side purposefully target a vanilla peasant for a night kill? The scum would rather kill a member of the revolution and the revolution would rather kill a scum member.

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???

Did anyone else notice this bit here? Looks like a secret voter/double voter/politician. Is anyone missing their vote?

Uhm, no haven't noticed it. Very strange.. but why would a secret voter voter for Rainbow? If the secret voter is evil, he would have waited and placed the last vote on Voden (If vodean is not evil himself). If ??? is good, he might be the seer and point us towards Rainbow. But.. rather strange thing either way.

someone has two votes. that is why it is a ?? and not a name. if there was a vote stealer, the name would appear but the person would not have cast the vote.

I am guessing that Vodean is not who he claims he is.

i maintain my claim. there should be room for 4 more.

As for 1 night kill, maybe 1 for mafia as a whole, and none for 26th, as they are good guys. In the set-up there was no mention of a stealer. This might be normal. Maybe an unannounced savior?

[naxus]

About his claim, I think its total BS.We lynched a Peasant day one and NK another one.Theres only what 12ish people in this game, so by claiming VT your almost assured a night kill against yourself as if you are a VT and they NK you then there would be only 1, or 2 or maybe even none left of the VT.

Why would either side purposefully target a vanilla peasant for a night kill? The scum would rather kill a member of the revolution and the revolution would rather kill a scum member.

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???

Did anyone else notice this bit here? Looks like a secret voter/double voter/politician. Is anyone missing their vote?

Well since its pretty much confusing as hell out there the mafia wont kill anyone completley randomly and so I think theyd target someone there suspicious of.Cause why kill someone random who might be good/bad when you can kill a VT?

Just my thoughts

[spiesr]

As for 1 night kill, maybe 1 for mafia as a whole, and none for 26th, as they are good guys. In the set-up there was no mention of a stealer. This might be normal. Maybe an unannounced savior?

What exactly do you mean when you refer to "an unannounced savior"? Do you mean such a role is stealing votes, or that it stopped a night kill, or what?

[vodean]

About his claim, I think its total BS.We lynched a Peasant day one and NK another one.Theres only what 12ish people in this game, so by claiming VT your almost assured a night kill against yourself as if you are a VT and they NK you then there would be only 1, or 2 or maybe even none left of the VT.

Why would either side purposefully target a vanilla peasant for a night kill? The scum would rather kill a member of the revolution and the revolution would rather kill a scum member.

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???

Did anyone else notice this bit here? Looks like a secret voter/double voter/politician. Is anyone missing their vote?

Well since its pretty much confusing as hell out there the mafia wont kill anyone completley randomly and so I think theyd target someone there suspicious of.Cause why kill someone random who might be good/bad when you can kill a VT?

Just my thoughts

well... in that case... who was targeting f1fth? not sure about that one

[vodean]

As for 1 night kill, maybe 1 for mafia as a whole, and none for 26th, as they are good guys. In the set-up there was no mention of a stealer. This might be normal. Maybe an unannounced savior?

What exactly do you mean when you refer to "an unannounced savior"? Do you mean such a role is stealing votes, or that it stopped a night kill, or what?

i mean stopping a night kill. a LOT of role speculation for 12 of us...
referring to my last post, is that what you mean? killing people who suspected them? or who they suspected? what would they suspect people of?

[safariguy5]

As for 1 night kill, maybe 1 for mafia as a whole, and none for 26th, as they are good guys. In the set-up there was no mention of a stealer. This might be normal. Maybe an unannounced savior?

What exactly do you mean when you refer to "an unannounced savior"? Do you mean such a role is stealing votes, or that it stopped a night kill, or what?

i mean stopping a night kill. a LOT of role speculation for 12 of us...
referring to my last post, is that what you mean? killing people who suspected them? or who they suspected? what would they suspect people of?

Stopping a night kill would probably mean either a doctor or a roleblocker.

[gregwolf121]

As for 1 night kill, maybe 1 for mafia as a whole, and none for 26th, as they are good guys. In the set-up there was no mention of a stealer. This might be normal. Maybe an unannounced savior?

What exactly do you mean when you refer to "an unannounced savior"? Do you mean such a role is stealing votes, or that it stopped a night kill, or what?

i mean stopping a night kill. a LOT of role speculation for 12 of us...
referring to my last post, is that what you mean? killing people who suspected them? or who they suspected? what would they suspect people of?

Stopping a night kill would probably mean either a doctor or a roleblocker.

didn't the scence say f1fth was shot then trampled, so two groups were trying to kill f1fth, i doubt that both scum groups would target the same player so i think we have a town vig

[lhcguy]

didn't the scence say f1fth was shot then trampled, so two groups were trying to kill f1fth, i doubt that both scum groups would target the same player so i think we have a town vig

It might have been flavour. Might have been that two groups tried. But why do you think that the scum groups wouldn't NK the same person? You think they can communicate? But two NKs from scum would be frightening.

[vodean]

didn't the scence say f1fth was shot then trampled, so two groups were trying to kill f1fth, i doubt that both scum groups would target the same player so i think we have a town vig

It might have been flavour. Might have been that two groups tried. But why do you think that the scum groups wouldn't NK the same person? You think they can communicate? But two NKs from scum would be frightening.

would be scary with two night kills, but it says one kills, the other steals and beats people up.

didn't the scence say f1fth was shot then trampled, so two groups were trying to kill f1fth, i doubt that both scum groups would target the same player so i think we have a town vig

that would be interesting. i think thats colton!

[naxus]

you do realize the duality might be a town cop or some other pro town power role?

Id like to Vote Rainbow Eater

In my rereading of the last 15ish pages i realized that when the Duality BW happened that RE was against voting for the inactive player(duality) as he said that dual might be a pro town person(above quote).But in the Wercool BW he was the last 2-3 votes which hammered wer and only because of him being inactive.Suspicious to me

[captainwalrus]

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 2 - ???, naxus

not voting: Gregwolf, UTA, /, vodean

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch, vodean is at l-2

Deadline set for sometime friday or saturday.

[spiesr]

would be scary with two night kills, but it says one kills, the other steals and beats people up.

One group steals huh? Well I think our mystery vote might just be a scum politician. Although nobody has reported their vote stolen, so maybe not.

[safariguy5]

would be scary with two night kills, but it says one kills, the other steals and beats people up.

One group steals huh? Well I think our mystery vote might just be a scum politician. Although nobody has reported their vote stolen, so maybe not.

I've played in the NV mafia game, and I'm pretty sure doublevoters get the ??? tag while if your vote was stolen, a red font was used to indicate the person who got his vote stolen. Pretty sure that's how it works.

[gregwolf121]

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???, naxus

not voting: Gregwolf, UTA, /, vodean

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch, vodean is at l-2

Deadline set for sometime friday or saturday.

doesnt re have 2 votes

[captainwalrus]

Vote count.
Vodean 4 - Rainbow Eater, Colton, lhcguy, spiser
UTA 1 - Safari
Rainbow Eater 1 - ???, naxus

not voting: Gregwolf, UTA, /, vodean

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch, vodean is at l-2

Deadline set for sometime friday or saturday.

doesnt re have 2 votes

Fixed.

[gregwolf121]

i thought editing a post wasn't allowed

[captainwalrus]

i thought editing a post wasn't allowed

It is if your mod
Mod can do anything.


Also, I am modding this on another site too, and you guys are much better. Their day one took forever, I had to threaten to modkill everyone who didn't post once every 24 hours and I put in a deadline before anyone even voted.

[gregwolf121]

what other site

[lhcguy]

I play also on boardgamegeek.com, games normally have a deadline once per day, leading to really high activity. Much more fun, but also much more time consuming, because you really should be there at lynch..

[vodean]

you do realize the duality might be a town cop or some other pro town power role?

Id like to Vote Rainbow Eater

In my rereading of the last 15ish pages i realized that when the Duality BW happened that RE was against voting for the inactive player(duality) as he said that dual might be a pro town person(above quote).But in the Wercool BW he was the last 2-3 votes which hammered wer and only because of him being inactive.Suspicious to me

that makes a lot of sense. im still reserving judgment for later, with more evidence for someone.
FOS RE

[captainwalrus]

what other site

the xkcd forums.
http://xkcd.com/ Go to forums, but I figured I would link the comic too cause it is hilarious.