Newbie Game - Cheese Mafia! - MAFIA WIN

by **drake_259** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 4:57 pm

ace1217 wrote:Well, since I'm L-2, I'll claim. I am cottage cheese, and because I can easily stick myself onto things, I am a watcher.

well for me thats quite believable

so Unvote for now at least

by **pimpdave** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 5:25 pm

Claim? What's a claim? Is there a list of all the cheeses in the game somewhere? How would claiming make any kind of a case for him?

What if someone lied? Are there a finite number of possibilities that he could be? Meaning, can there be more than one "watcher" in a game? If that's the case, can anyone substantiate whether or not he's lying?

by **Simon Viavant** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 5:29 pm

If I was a serial killer why would I claim vig? What makes you think vig>>>>serial killer?
I could have claimed townie or doc and I'd have just as much chance of being a serial killer. If I'd claimed vanilla, would you have said "oh, he must be a serial killer"? Pro-town vig isn't any more closely related to SK than anything else is. Your whole serial killer rant seems to be to direct attention onto me and away from yourself ace. What have I done to indicate I'm a serial killer? Whereas you've jumped on every bandwagon instantly.

My vote stays. Watcher is an easy thing to claim as there probably isn't one in a smallish game like this and you could frame people easily that way.

by **ace1217** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 5:42 pm

Simon Viavant wrote:If I was a serial killer why would I claim vig? What makes you think vig>>>>serial killer?
I could have claimed townie or doc and I'd have just as much chance of being a serial killer. If I'd claimed vanilla, would you have said "oh, he must be a serial killer"? Pro-town vig isn't any more closely related to SK than anything else is. Your whole serial killer rant seems to be to direct attention onto me and away from yourself ace. What have I done to indicate I'm a serial killer? Whereas you've jumped on every bandwagon instantly.

My vote stays. Watcher is an easy thing to claim as there probably isn't one in a smallish game like this and you could frame people easily that way.

The reason I think your a serial killer is because vig = SK essentially, and as you aren't confirmed town yet, I think you are a killer.

by **animorpherv1** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 5:50 pm

pimpdave wrote:Claim? What's a claim? Is there a list of all the cheeses in the game somewhere? How would claiming make any kind of a case for him?

What if someone lied? Are there a finite number of possibilities that he could be? Meaning, can there be more than one "watcher" in a game? If that's the case, can anyone substantiate whether or not he's lying?

A claim is when someone tells everyone there, via posting in the thread.

No, no list yet. Someone may make one later, though.

Lieing is a possibility. Most people stick to something close the their roles. A watcher claim is hard to fake, too.

I guess there is a limited amount of possibilities in the game. See as we have 11 people. There may be more than one watcher, just like in some games, there more than one "vanilla townie" (plain role that does nothing).

Substanitate? Refrain from using big words. I'm still in high school.

by **Hologram** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 5:58 pm

I think you both look really scummy right now. On the one hand, simon's been acting pretty suspicious the entire game. On the other hand, ace seems to be trying really hard to get the vote off of him, even before anyone had actually voted for him.

In my eyes, you both get to make your own case now. My vote stays with simon for lack of a better choice.

by **drake_259** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:00 pm

Hologram wrote:I think you both look really scummy right now. On the one hand, simon's been acting pretty suspicious the entire game. On the other hand, ace seems to be trying really hard to get the vote off of him, even before anyone had actually voted for him.

In my eyes, you both get to make your own case now. My vote stays with simon for lack of a better choice.

maybe we should lynch one of them, i wouldn't like to come down to this but we have nothing really, if we vote someone off them maybe the next day we can figure out who could be scum

by **Hologram** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:03 pm

Well yes, it's more or less a crapshoot the first day, because we have no facts, just he said, she said. The only thing we have to go on is acting suspicious.

Basically we have me simon and ace. We just need to figure out which one to lynch.

by **ace1217** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:10 pm

Would you lynch me, a information role, or simon, a vig who will most likely hurt the town more then help it? Its pretty clear to lynch simon in this case.

by **drake_259** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:12 pm

well simon i dont want you to kill anyone tonight and if you don't then you will be proved not a SK

so people unvote simon for today

and as for ace its all down to you, now give us a reason why not to lynch you and who could be scummier than you and why

by **william18** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:12 pm

I agree, information role is safer(and usually more helpful) then a vig.

by **ace1217** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:14 pm

drake_259 wrote:well simon i dont want you to kill anyone tonight and if you don't then you will be proved not a SK

so people unvote simon for today

and as for ace its all down to you, now give us a reason why not to lynch you and who could be scummier than you and why

You shouldn't lynch because because I'm a info role, and I can find scum. As for who's scummier, I dunno, but you shouldn't let me today.

by **animorpherv1** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:15 pm

drake_259 wrote:well simon i dont want you to kill anyone tonight and if you don't then you will be proved not a SK

so people unvote simon for today

and as for ace its all down to you, now give us a reason why not to lynch you and who could be scummier than you and why

I have to agree with ace on this one. vigs hurt more then they help

by **ace1217** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:17 pm

drake_259 wrote:well simon i dont want you to kill anyone tonight and if you don't then you will be proved not a SK

so people unvote simon for today

and as for ace its all down to you, now give us a reason why not to lynch you and who could be scummier than you and why

Oh, and btw, him not killing tonight doesn't prove him either way, typically SKs can choose not to kill.

by **william18** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:18 pm

Vote simon

by **ga7** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 6:38 pm

Vote Count :

Simon Viavant (5) - Hologram, pimpdave, ace, ani, Will
ace1217 (2) - Simon, Nick
Hologram (1) - Insomnia

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch!

by **Simon Viavant** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 7:02 pm

unvote I don't think ace is scum. Right now everyone's thinking we should do the better of two bad things and lynch me. How about we actually try to figure out who's scum? As for me being a SK, why would a SK claim vig? Why does vig = SK? One wants to kill everyone and one's pro-town, that's a pretty big difference. I wasn't even planning to kill anyone anyway, and definitely not tonight when I have little or no info. So ace is a watcher. How do we know he's a pro-town watcher? He could be a watcher working for the mafia. :roll:

by **drake_259** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 7:08 pm

ace1217 wrote:
drake_259 wrote:well simon i dont want you to kill anyone tonight and if you don't then you will be proved not a SK

so people unvote simon for today

and as for ace its all down to you, now give us a reason why not to lynch you and who could be scummier than you and why

Oh, and btw, him not killing tonight doesn't prove him either way, typically SKs can choose not to kill.

oh, i thought SK's had too kill

Vote: simon

i think you might be townie but we need a lynch and we haven't got any leads on anyone else yet so im sorry

by **ga7** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 7:45 pm

Vote Count :

Simon Viavant (6) - Hologram, pimpdave, ace, ani, Will, drake
ace1217 (1) - Nick
Hologram (1) - Insomnia

Simon is lynched! Scene coming up.

by **ga7** on Fri Oct 31, 2008 7:49 pm

Simon had gotten the short end of the stick after the day's debates, the citizens feeling threatened by his claimed ability. They decided it would be safer to consume the melted cheese before it melts YOU!!

Simon Viavant - Raclette - Vigilante has been lynched!

Night 1! You have 48 hours to send your action.