Let me also clear the case with TWO (godfather) and william (cult leader). Let me also state that the following is the most probable explanation what happened there.
william was the cult leader who could recruit only during day. He tried to recruit TWO last day and was not successful because TWO was mafia. So, identifying one of mafia he tried to make a questionable (smart or stupid, I can't decide) move claiming cop hoping on doctor's protection during later phases.
I can hear you saying that william should be dead when he was not successful in recruiting a mafia member, however this differs from mod to mod. Some mods let the recruiter die on the first trial, some not.
What william didn't think about, was that there could be a night vig (mafia) or a night serial killer, who may target him. This actually happened and he was killed. At the same time TWO was targeted either by the night vig (town) or by the night Jack of all trades (town). That was a good move giving the town one more shot.
I also read posts of night players about the possibility with insane cop, recruitment of him, pm'ing each other etc etc., however this is mostly not probable because of following prerequisites:
1) there should be an insane cop in the set up (lets say 50% possible)
2) that insane cop should be a day/insomniac cop (50-60% possible)
3) that insane cop should target TWO (mathematically %5-6 possible, normally its less than this, because there are better players to investigate in this game)
4) william should target that insane cop to recruit (%5-6 possible, but normally less, he would have preferred to recruit a night or insomniac player)
The proability of such a combination is far below 1% and can be neglected.
In total, we were very lucky with the results of the first day and night.
.
