Hostel Mafia Game Over; Scum Win

[icedagger]

Ah nice to see you Clive seeing as your contributions so far have consisted of wagoning skoffin and acting drunk

So what was up with you yesterday? (As in day 3)

And why is me brinigng attention back to the lynching of the cop, where pretty much the only game related stuff happened, scummy?

EBWOP Day 2

[animorpherv1]

Maybe it's the fact that the only thing I've seen you post about is MY lynch.

[icedagger]

So you've gone from disowning cmc's actions to taking them personally.. riiiight..

[animorpherv1]

Hey, that's what you wanted.

[icedagger]

Seriously.. what are you on about?

I built a case against cmc. He defended it. You then replaced cmc.I acknowledged his defense, but thought it still wasn't reason enough to hammer a claimed cop. I then identified ga7 as someone probably even scummier in my opinion, and voted him.

Then suddenly you come in with YOU'RE OUT TO GET ME!!!1one!1

So, defend cmc, or share your thoughts on who you think should be lynched. Because what you're doing now just looks like OMGUS..

[Clive]

I was not acting drunk yesterday.

Nothing happend to me yesterday, and if something had I may not be disposed to say.

[ga7]

I always knew Kwan was a cute japanese girl deep inside

Well Ice, I appreciate the effort but that sounds like BS. To me it sounded in the previous day that you just wanted to put the blame on Cmc for hammering. To start with I'd think it'd be more likely for a town to hammer in this situation than a scum afraid of the repercussions. His arguments kinda made sense to me, obviously there were enough people on the same wavelength regarding both Skoff's shitclaim and Ace's weird, counterclaim-sounding behavior. Granted, we were way misleaded, but it made it hard for me to find someone on the wagon scummy as I saw no one sticking out, and the only argument about Cmc was his hammer.
As for the partnership bit... Hahahah. Since Animo then replaced Cmc and raised the general scuminess level to new heights, if I was scum I'd have been the first to wagon

Of course at this point Ani could perfectly be scum, but as usual with him it's kinda random. I'm more of the opinion that Cmc's hammer was a show of towniness, as strange as it may sound, and disregard Ani's antics for once.

Now, I understand you want to find scum on Skoffin's wagon, but I still find Lovo's case worth attention. Without entering a metagame argument, I called him out yesterday for a reason: he popped up, said hi, and went back to submarining without bothering to add input. Sure, he didn't vote Skoff, but more precisely he didn't vote anyone after the random day 1 votes.
Two possibilities for this submarining:
- He's town and doesn't give a shit, but is still somehow active enough to not be replaced
- He's scum, and lays low as usual to not attract attention
Basically I think the second possibility is way more likely.

On a side note, I have a little idea of what happened to Clive, heh.

[animorpherv1]

Dito. He voted me first.

[Ditocoaf]

Dito. He voted me first.

huh?

[icedagger]

Lovo's been inactive in every game I'm in with him.. he's getting/been replaced in skoffin's game. So I don't think he's using it as a tactic in this game, although a prod/replacement would be good.

I just attributed ace's strange behaviour to him being ace, but on rereading it does look a bit like a counterclaim. Which explains why you'd keep your vote on Skoffin I guess.

Unvote although I still have my suspicions

Animo, meanwhile, seems to have given up all pretense of trying to help town..

[FloresDelMal]

Cmc looked town, and I think he had solid reasons for hammering Skoff. Ace had, from my point of view, countered Skoff. He played poorly. I would have hammered if I wasn't voting her already.

And, carrying this on, I don't not find Ga7 scummy for his recent actions. However, I think ice's trying to bring attention back to ani I find very scummy.

FOS ice

i agree with clive, i think submarines are an hidrance, skoffin had a long history as submariner, and lynching her on day 1 was good fun, sadly she was the cop, and even sadder, she couldnt make a decent claim in a game based closely on a movie, which was providing names *shrugs* this shits happen, its no use getting stuck in it.

second, i do find strange the way ice is focusing so much on cmc/ace, for a day 1 lynch on skoff, but doesnt strike me so much as scummy, as just a sturborn townie being misleaded, but just in case FOS ice

and about lovo, seriously, him havent made a single post with a real contribution to the game, and him is so absent that is hard for me to remember that him is even playing in this game,a nd that is starting to seriously piss me off, so for put some pressure on him Vote Lovo
if him come up with a decent deffense and justification for his modus operandi, fix his ways and yadda yadda ill gladly unvote.

[icedagger]

Yeah really scummy how I'm focusing on the only thing that's happened all game. Much less so to pick up on someone who's not playing in any of his games and vote him.

[FloresDelMal]

Yeah really scummy how I'm focusing on the only thing that's happened all game. Much less so to pick up on someone who's not playing in any of his games and vote him.

do you have a B plan then? (i mean besides go after cmc/animo, because i am not voting him, not today at least)

[icedagger]

I've already stated that's where my suspicions lie.. if you don't agree it's up to you to have a plan a, not me to have a plan b. Unless you mean lynching lovo who probably won't even defend himself

[animorpherv1]

Dito. He voted me first.

huh?

I've only replaced a Day and a half (mafia time) ago, you think I know much?

[icedagger]

It's called reading the thread..

[animorpherv1]

I did.

[ga7]

Well, I think if Lovo wasn't using his night action he would have been replaced by now, which keeps me suspicious.

[Clive]

Ice, if you are town, are you considering what i've (we've) been saying?

You are tunneling on Cmc, insisting he is scum. I don't understand what you find scummy about the nature of his Day 1 play.

And you say you dislike a LV lynch. He is being compeltely useless. He is either town and not playing, or scum and pretending to be a town who is not playing.

I think Ga makes another good point there. LV hasn't posted in ages.

Dito, what do you think? I don't believe i've seen you post in a while...

[Clive]

I just checked the frist page and noticed Fircoal and Fireedud there. I was disappointed.

In such a small game, on Day 3, we have 3 players essentially not playing.

I'm gonna put my scum team as those 3, for the moment. Plus, out of the people who are playing, the only one i'm finding slighty scummy is Ice, but i'm getting the feeling he's jsut a town that I disagree with.

[ga7]

Fircoal should be a bit more active when he comes back, but you're right about Fireedud. I kinda doubt all scum would submarine but it does make it seem like a good time to get rid of a dead weight.

[Clive]

Well, that's just wifom really. And even if their town they're not helping.

And mili, you still got Kwan in the alive list. Just to let you know.

[icedagger]

Ice, if you are town, are you considering what i've (we've) been saying?

You are tunneling on Cmc, insisting he is scum. I don't understand what you find scummy about the nature of his Day 1 play.

And you say you dislike a LV lynch. He is being compeltely useless. He is either town and not playing, or scum and pretending to be a town who is not playing.

I think Ga makes another good point there. LV hasn't posted in ages.

Dito, what do you think? I don't believe i've seen you post in a while...

I'm not tunneling on cmc, in fact my vote was on ga7 before I unvoted. I found the skoffin bandwagon completely unconvincing at the time, although ace's strange play is a factor I hadn't taken into consideration. I'm still convinced the mafia were on that wagon. I'd rather get lovo replaced than lynch him since lynching him would just be a stab in the dark and we can't afford that with 3 townies dead already.

I'd also like to hear more from dito who's struck me as town from the little he's contributed

[Ditocoaf]

Sorry, with six games going on I'm having a hard time contributing to all of them. I have however been paying attention enough to have a general idea of what's going on. I'll post some theories after dinner, giving myself to dig up some quotes.

[fireedud]

I'm still here.