update, 16 July wrote:The master list (see below) now includes suggestions under the following 6 headings:
"attitude"
"fair play"
"teamwork"
"gameplay" - see Lack's >> Gameplay attribute for ratings thread.
"attendance" - any automation (see Lack's >> Calculate attendance outside of ratings) will not necessarily preclude the need to rate using tags also.
"other categories" - suggested by posters though not currently used in ratings.
update, 6 July wrote:The master list now includes suggestions under the following 4 headings:
"attitude"
"fair play"
"teamwork"
"gameplay" - see Lack's >> Gameplay attribute for ratings thread.
"attendance" - has been removed since it would appear this is likely to be automated - see Lack's >> Calculate attendance outside of ratings.
original post, on 1 July, wrote:In Lack's >> descriptive tags for ratings thread he proposes using tags to supplement ratings. He also suggested that people post, in that thread, their suggestions for useful tags. That thread is very busy and as a consequence the few suggestions for ratings are somewhat lost in the noise.
The aim of this thread is to collect suggestions for tags which might be useful to incorporate into any tag based rating system.
As a brainstorming exercise it's important that we all post suggestions only and stay strictly focussed ie on topic, please don't post criticism of suggestions or criticism of the thread here.
Please use the general format
<tag suggestion> - <rating category>
I will collect them all into the master list below in this first post - so please check the list before posting if you can - it'll help me out
[To get things started I've begun harvesting the suggestions made within Lack's original thread.]
Master List - updated 16 July
Attitude - single words
flirtatious, Friendly, funny, intense, mellow, Paranoid, Rude, silent, talkative
Attitude - 2 words
curses excessively, dice whiner, Pleasant player, Sore Loser, Very funny
Attitude - 3 words
Bullies other players
Attitude - phrases
highly critical of other players in chat, constant complaints about dice/drop, seemed in bad mood, Left game when losing
Fair Play - single words
Fair Play - 2 words
Balanced Play, Cheap Tactics, Secret Diplomacy
Fair Play - 3 words
broke announced truce, formed unnannounced alliance, very balanced play
Fair Play - phrases
attacked for revenge/vendetta, helped new/inexperienced player without harming overall strategies, made an announced alliance, suicided and changed game, took double turns in freestyle game, used missed turns as strategy
Teamwork - single words
follower, leader, silent, stingy, talkative
Teamwork - 2 words
Bad Teammate, bullied teammates, English poor, Good Teammate, Heeds Advice, Ignores Advice, Teammate Killer
Teamwork - 3 words
coordinates strategy well, does not communicate
Teamwork - phrases
attacked own team without cause, does not coordinate strategy well, helped teammates understand game
Gameplay - single words
Backstabber, Brave, Breaker, Builder, Clueless, Coward, Irrational, Politician, Reckless, Suicider, Trustworthy, Turtle, Vindictive, Quitter
Gameplay - 2 words
Bonus Grabber, Brilliant tactician, High Risk, Low Risk, poor strategy, Sore Loser
Gameplay - 3 words
All Guns Blazing, learn the map!
Gameplay - phrases
Attendance - single words
Deadbeat, quick, slow, Timely
Attendance - 2 words
missed turns, ever present
Attendance - 3 words
Attendance - phrases
Deadbeat but excused, missed a lot of turns or seemed to use it as strategy, Missed turns only with cause, missed 1/2 turns in a week, missed 1/2/3 turns in a month
other categories
** chat **
Bully, Complainer, Friendly, Funny, Helpful, Paranoid, Rude, Silent, Talkative
** diplomacy **
Backstabber, Trustworthy
** cooperation (diplomacy/teamwork) **
Cooperative, Uncooperative
** style **
Follower, Good Strategy, Leader, Poor Strategy
