Juan_Bottom wrote:tzor wrote:Juan_Bottom wrote:WTF???? Did that come from PSRAST???? Holy crap! That wasn't there before! Now I look like a douche....
In fact, that is probably the dumbest argument against GE foods that I have ever heard.
So if I eat a lot of GE carrots, I'll become a carrot too???? HUHHUHhuh
I don't know how dumb it is. I thought that I heard somewherer that DNA fragments from foods eaten can migrate into host cells and continue to produce whatever proteens they were originally generating. It's not that you will bcome a carrot, but some cells may start producing some proteens generally produced by carrots. Unfortunately I think this was about six months ago on NPR so I don't think I can ....
BINGO - Hold your cards please, we have a BINGO called! Oh rats. Or in this case oh mice.
Food-Ingested Foreign DNA Survives the Gastrointestinal Tract - Cancer Weekly - March 3rd, 1997 "The gastrointestinal tract of mice does not completely degrade food-ingested foreign DNA."
Personally, I find this to be amazing, though difficult to understand(as applied). Can't believe that everyone has ignored this post.
Here's the actual paper, if anyone is interested.
http://www.pnas.org/cgi/reprint/94/3/961.pdfThe implications from this might lead to what Tzor may have heard, but this is also an eleven year-old paper, so I would imagine some further research has been done. Anyhow, I imagine the odds of incorporating DNA into a cells genome are slim to none and even if it happens, it's one cell, and it can be fixed. We're requiring massive amounts of infiltration to have even a notable effect, I'd imagine.
In case anyone is curious, here are a few peer-reviewed articles I looked up.
Study of GM corn and chickens found chloroplast DNA (asserted that this occurs constantly, implying that if rogue DNA was hazardous, we'd probably see the effects). No recombinant DNA, which means that the whole process is probably a matter of luck.
Still no luck finding transgenic proteins. I suppose these aren't representative in that they are the free ones from the academic search I use, so they may be a bit dated too.
A review on GM foods from the British Medical Journal.Anyone have any requests?