LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[jnd94]

Ok, I seriously have no idea what is happeining...lemme re-read and see if I catch anything.

[/]

Come on!
Jack is the star of the whole show, no scum would ever be stupid enough to fake claim the biggest role in the whole game!
Everyone knows Jack=doctor
Just the lack of a counter claim of a role who is sure to be the only role who'd be absolutely guaranteed in this game is enough to stop any argument.
why isn't anyone here catching on to these people who are totally pushing for a, perhaps THE Doc's lynch? is this whole game just full of like five different scum factions or something and I'm the only one not invited?

[Ditocoaf]

is this whole game just full of like five different scum factions or something and I'm the only one not invited?

That sounds like an interesting premise for a game...

[Iliad]

Nag seems to be the doc, sentinel on the other hand doesn't seem so pro-town

[cmckinney]

is this whole game just full of like five different scum factions or something and I'm the only one not invited?

That sounds like an interesting premise for a game...

But unfortunately not the premise of this game

[nagerous]

When did I unvote and voted the same person? I don't remember doing that. Must be the years catching up with me.

you're still not answering fully... what did nagareous do? That seems the natural way to state the phrase, unless your query had to be as specific as "Did nag visit selin? yes/no." That's why this feels made up to me.

Maybe you don't understand the role of a watcher. I ask to watch a specific person, and the mod tells me who visited them. I watched Selin. nagerous did not visit him during the night.

Hmmm unvote vote sentinel

I've never seen a game with 2 watchers... Sounds mighty fishy. I know I protected Selin and as far as I'm aware thats what I did.
I understand the role of the Watcher completely. In fact, have that role. Ain't tha something?

Mayor FOS on Sentinel

I will leave my vote on Nagerus because of Cena's claim, but Sentinel should definetly be the next one to go.

If you guys don't believe me, I can tell you whom I watch tonight, but I would prefer not tu since, I strongly believe that person might have been the Doc (he protected Pmchugh, hence the mysterious message from the begining of Day 2).

[nagerous]

Sorry fucked that up, drunk.


Hmmm unvote vote sentinel

I've never seen a game with 2 watchers... Sounds mighty fishy. I know I protected Selin and as far as I'm aware thats what I did.

[lord voldemort]

agreed i beleive mando over selin...
though selin is by far the bes tnew player going around
mmm
fos selin and rebelman
i highly doubt this is a scum play to claim jack and out him

[nagerous]

agreed i beleive mando over selin...
though selin is by far the bes tnew player going around
mmm
fos selin and rebelman
i highly doubt this is a scum play to claim jack and out him

not selin, sentinel...

[lord voldemort]

agreed i beleive mando over setinal...
though selin is by far one of the best new players going around
mmm
fos setinal and rebelman
i highly doubt this is a scum play to claim jack and out him

ebwop
i knew wat i wanted to write lol

[Sentinel XIV]

Well, if it's possible there are two doctors, then it is also possible there are two watchers. If mandalorian's claim of being a watcher is true, then there are definitely two watchers, me being the second. I don't want to give anyone an excuse to vote for me, but lynching me will prove that I am what I say, and that I am also pro-town.

[Ditocoaf]

Well, if it's possible there are two doctors, then it is also possible there are two watchers. If mandalorian's claim of being a watcher is true, then there are definitely two watchers, me being the second. I don't want to give anyone an excuse to vote for me, but lynching me will prove that I am what I say, and that I am also pro-town.

You might just have a weird way of talking, but that sounded very scummy. Re-reading the past few pages, you're looking very scummy. I'm going to have to FoS Sentinel atm, and my finger's on the vote button.

[gimpyThewonder]

Test - Sentinel, dito, cmckinney, rebel, gimpy, /

Lynch - Mando, ditto, pmc, cena, selin, secret

Non-voters - Neo, Firc, LSU, Nag, LoVo, Illy, jnd, GT

I imagine the Aussies were asleep, and I only counted 6 for the lynch for some reason. Anyhow, here's the voters for the lynch and test. Does anyone think this should be further analyzed?

I'd like to hear from the lynch crowd on why they voted that way.

also AD could you state for the record an official count of who voted where? or do you plan on letting some do it secret-like and the rest of us out in the open. I just want to get the game dynamics nailed down b/c i think we can make use of it.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Selin is not a "new" player LV. He was playing long before you started With that said, I'll Unvote for now.

[firth4eva]

UNOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

(5) Nagerous – mandalorian2298, Sentinel XIV, GT, rebelman, SECRET VOTE
(2) Sentinel XIV - pmchugh, Fircoal, nagerous
(2) Rebelman - /, LoVo,


With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch!

OK so I will be taking over Vote Counts for the next 3 days. I can't guarantee anything because I know nothing. AD has been banned by wicked for 3 days. So I'll try to keep up these vote counts but I can't promise anything because AD hasn't even asked me.

[lord voldemort]

Selin is not a "new" player LV. He was playing long before you started With that said, I'll Unvote for now.

check th ebwop i was supposed to be refering to sentinal. i just stuffed it up massivly lol

[cmckinney]

So basically what it has come down to is Nagerous's word (That he protected Selin last night) against Sentinel's word (That nobody visited Selin last night). And then you've got Cena in the background, saying that he is confident that Nag is scum, and then revealed to us that he was Desmond, a cop (by blatantly breaking the rules i might add) And in defense of Sentinel and Cena's accusations, Nag has claimed to be Jack Shepherd, a doctor. Considering Jack is like the biggest star on the show, is it almost completely certain he is in this game, which asks the question: Why would Nag role claim Jack, a role that is certain to be counter-claimed if he's lying? The fact that nobody has counterclaimed yet, makes his role claim see more and more valid. Which turns the suspicion over to Cena and Sentinel, who were already acting scummy and pushing for a lynch on Nag.

Vote Sentinel, considering the fact that as Desmond, Cena could possibly be an insane cop, and just got a screwed up investigation, which puts the suspicion more on Sentinel.

[lord voldemort]

So basically what it has come down to is Nagerous's word (That he protected Selin last night) against Sentinel's word (That nobody visited Selin last night). And then you've got Cena in the background, saying that he is confident that Nag is scum, and then revealed to us that he was Desmond, a cop (by blatantly breaking the rules i might add) And in defense of Sentinel and Cena's accusations, Nag has claimed to be Jack Shepherd, a doctor. Considering Jack is like the biggest star on the show, is it almost completely certain he is in this game, which asks the question: Why would Nag role claim Jack, a role that is certain to be counter-claimed if he's lying? The fact that nobody has counterclaimed yet, makes his role claim see more and more valid. Which turns the suspicion over to Cena and Sentinel, who were already acting scummy and pushing for a lynch on Nag.

Vote Sentinel, considering the fact that as Desmond, Cena could possibly be an insane cop, and just got a screwed up investigation, which puts the suspicion more on Sentinel.

i think this sums it up well
also that desmond is most likely not sane....i mean who would be lol
and nag would of surely been countered. and cena does suck at lying as scum so im inclined to believe him
so my suspicion is on sentinel
unvote vote sentinel

[gimpyThewonder]

Sentinel can you confirm that in fact 'no one' visited Selin last night, or just not Nagerous?

[Sentinel XIV]

Sentinel can you confirm that in fact 'no one' visited Selin last night, or just not Nagerous?

Oh, people visited Selin last night. Just not nagerous.

Can we get a vote count, please?

[Selin]

I'm back at home again and will read the thread in a few hours after taking my turns in 40+ games

[mandalorian2298]

Sentinel can you confirm that in fact 'no one' visited Selin last night, or just not Nagerous?

Oh, people visited Selin last night. Just not nagerous.

Can we get a vote count, please?

What is your role's name, oh fake Watcher of my hart?

[firth4eva]

UNOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

(5) Nagerous – mandalorian2298, Sentinel XIV, GT, rebelman, SECRET VOTE
(5) Sentinel XIV - pmchugh, Fircoal, nagerous, cmckinney, lovo
(1) Rebelman - /,


With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch!

OK so I will be taking over Vote Counts for the next 3 days. I can't guarantee anything because I know nothing. AD has been banned by wicked for 3 days. So I'll try to keep up these vote counts but I can't promise anything because AD hasn't even asked me.

[cmckinney]

UNOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

(5) Nagerous – mandalorian2298, Sentinel XIV, GT, rebelman, SECRET VOTE
(5) Sentinel XIV - pmchugh, Fircoal, nagerous, cmckinney, lovo
(1) Rebelman - /,


With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch!

OK so I will be taking over Vote Counts for the next 3 days. I can't guarantee anything because I know nothing. AD has been banned by wicked for 3 days. So I'll try to keep up these vote counts but I can't promise anything because AD hasn't even asked me.

What'd AD do?

[dittoeevee8888]

Test - Sentinel, dito, cmckinney, rebel, gimpy, /

Lynch - Mando, ditto, pmc, cena, selin, secret

Non-voters - Neo, Firc, LSU, Nag, LoVo, Illy, jnd, GT

I imagine the Aussies were asleep, and I only counted 6 for the lynch for some reason. Anyhow, here's the voters for the lynch and test. Does anyone think this should be further analyzed?

I'd like to hear from the lynch crowd on why they voted that way.

also AD could you state for the record an official count of who voted where? or do you plan on letting some do it secret-like and the rest of us out in the open. I just want to get the game dynamics nailed down b/c i think we can make use of it.

You want to know why I voted that way? Well here's the answer.

I wanna see if you guys would figure out that im trying to get lynched. You guys are too focused ona lynch to listen so I guess there is no use in giving you guys any more info.

William even says that he won't bother giving any more info. And I wasn't sure if he could be forced into giving info, so that's why I voted to lynch him.