ROTS Day 4...Multiple Deaths....p41 (read now)

[Fircoal]

Wow......thats contributing.....

You're just pissed because he thought you were scum. Also if someone could just find out the exact time we asked illy for roleclaim and his last post he can't weasel out of it by saying "It's australia dudes"

wtf.....no......Im pissed because he contributes nothing to this game.

I contribute to the game, but I'm guessing that you haven't read any of it. Weird how I'd say that I've contributed more than you have. Now if you want to see me not contributing go to LOST mafia where I'm still behind.

(Btw your attempt to try to make me look a bit scummy without saying it right out is failing, and it makes me think more that you are scum. )

[Iliad]

Is my claim invisible or something?

[Fircoal]

You're just pissed because he thought you were scum. Also if someone could just find out the exact time we asked illy for roleclaim and his last post he can't weasel out of it by saying "It's australia dudes"

wtf.....no......Im pissed because he contributes nothing to this game.

Yes I contribute nothing to the game. By sleeping in the holidays. I'm sorry jnd I don't fit your standards, I' won't sleep in the future just for you? Not good enough? How about I move to america and won't sleep there? And then constantly post in thisthread? Will that be fucking good enough for you? Will that be contributing?

I'm sorry just really annoying to wake up, and then go to post in mafias and see this bullshit

Call down Illy he means me, but you has a good point. Jnd, I'm sorry contributing as much as you isn't good enough for you.

[Iliad]

wtf.....no......Im pissed because he contributes nothing to this game.

Yes I contribute nothing to the game. By sleeping in the holidays. I'm sorry jnd I don't fit your standards, I' won't sleep in the future just for you? Not good enough? How about I move to america and won't sleep there? And then constantly post in thisthread? Will that be fucking good enough for you? Will that be contributing?

I'm sorry just really annoying to wake up, and then go to post in mafias and see this bullshit

Call down Illy he means me, but you has a good point. Jnd, I'm sorry contributing as much as you isn't good enough for you.

Yeah it's morning and the I thought the he reffered to me

[Fircoal]

Is my claim invisible or something?

no Illy, also I'm the only one to have post so far after it in this thread and I'm more concentrated on defending myself from Jnd's idiotic claims.

[MountainLion]

I am bail organna, a mason. I will reveal who my mason is, if you guys want it.

Although I don't have a vote on you, I'm satisfied with that claim. I would suggest NOT revealing who is your mason.

[Sierra_Leon]

I believe Iliad's claim. I looked the guy up on wikipedia and a mason is a believable role for that character. Mason is also a role that scum wouldn't claim so early in the game, because he'd be found out if a real mason group exists and proclaimed he was not part of it or if the town pushes him to name his partner and he has to get one of his scumbuddies involved.

jnd94 has a few votes, but I don't see a good case against him except for the jester comment. I like nagerous' case on ga7 better. Vote ga7.

I'll repost it, so you all don't have to look back:

Toe of Innocence given to fircoal for posting sensible logic

the wierd thing is Anarkists is agreeing to Ga7's logic which is based around the idea that Kalish unvoted him to vote his scum buddy......

Other than that, what exactly is your motive for voting Kalish, AD?!

I'll tell you right quick... GA7s logic sounds good to me.

Kalish is acting... odd... I can't quite place it, but I feel like he may not be scum, but sure as hell isn't a Jedi.

Here, it did seem to me that you were trying to put some pressure on him. The kind of acting... odd comment, is the kind of comment that normally inspires n00bs to go and join the bandwagon (your vote was already on Kalish), following Anarkist "The Rebel Leader" Dream's lead and makes me cautious of you. Mandy, Sierra and Ga7 also all joined the bandwagon on Kalish so I'm wary of all you guys too, considering I thought it very weak. Especially ga7, when I initially FOSed Clive for inactivity his comment was:

Not grasping at straws, playing day 1 Fos Nag for trying to keep the attention off Kalish twice now.

Later, when the potential Clive bandwagon develops, his comments are...

Personally I still like the Kalish lynch more than these, cause he suggested a no lynch when we have so much time left. Granted, he did it in Othello and was town but it was a different context. Besides, he's cocky enough to use it again for his advantage Dunno, seems still scummier.
Clive kinda sounds honest so at this point his lynch seems a waste of time. I also agree I wouldn't put it past Lovo to do that kind of things (:lol:). As for Militant, no input... I'll switch my vote to him as a last resort.

Hence, I am forced to vote ga7

I don't trust your allegiences one bit in this game.

[MountainLion]

Reread again... nothing more to contribute... I suppose I'll check back in when you damn Aussies are awake...

Nothing to contribute? I suggest you do something

[Anarkistsdream]

Can we be gettin' a vote count..? Arrrrrgh.

[nagerous]

Unvote.

[ga7]

Well as I thought Illiad's case was the weaker one, my vote stays on Jnd. Funny how SL just jumps to another weak one btw

[Sierra_Leon]

Well as I thought Illiad's case was the weaker one, my vote stays on Jnd. Funny how SL just jumps to another weak one btw

How is jnd's any stronger than yours?

[kalishnikov]

Unvote. I agree S_L, I looked at the wookiepedia article also and it seems legit. Not that Iliad couldn't have easily done the same for the fake claim but I have no reason to doubt him at the moment. Plus, in my experience, Iliad's fake claims aren't very good (no offense intended, neither are mine) so I'd doubt this is fake. Iliad, don't reveal your partner unless you absolutely have to, no need to out him/her if most of us believe you.

Honestly, both the case against kme74 (jnd) and ga7 look kinda weak to me but with this group of players I'm not really expecting any easy scum lynches or slip-ups. If I had to choose one I'd pick ga but I'm not going to do that quite yet, at least without re-reading first for anything of value.

I got wasted last night and am pretty hung over today so I'm not sure if I'll get to the re-read soon, it might have to wait till later on tonight, just for the record. Fucking Johnny Walker, kicks my ass every time...

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Vote GA I also agree that GA not wanting to vote Clive was a bit unusual.

[Fircoal]

hey, Jnd skipping days isn't contributing, especially when you're on the block.

Also LSU Jnd was also hesitant to vote Clive.

[jnd94]

Im not on the block......that is maybe the worst evidence against someone Ive ever seen.....it' shit basically.....it's all based on my inflection, which is Bs because nobody can see that. So since Illy claimed, it's either me or ga.

[Fircoal]

Im not on the block......that is maybe the worst evidence against someone Ive ever seen.....it' shit basically.....it's all based on my inflection, which is Bs because nobody can see that. So since Illy claimed, it's either me or ga.

dude, I normally wouldn't be using it has proof as by itself it's not scummy,. but you called me on the same thing, and more or less you were trying to use it to make ME sound scummy. Now since I'm not contributing any less then you, that's why I find it scummy, and it's the only reason I'm pointing it out. Learn to do yourself before you criticize others.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Whichever one does not get lynched today probably deserves an investigation among JND and GA with Illy as a possible future investigation.

[MountainLion]

Okay guys, so I'll be going on a small vacation to visit family from (Friday) tomorrow morning until Tuesday afternoon. I'll try to get online a couple times during then.

[Sierra_Leon]

I won't be able to get online again until sunday night.

[Anarkistsdream]

Jesus, people... We can't keep running this around in circles...

Either vote JND or vote ga... I think the evidence against Ga7 is fairly strong, so that is where my vote is... If you guys think JNDs case is stronger, then vote him...

[Neoteny]

Unvote, because I don't think I did.

[nagerous]

I'm going back to my original vote which was ga7 vote ga7

[ga7]

Well as I thought Illiad's case was the weaker one, my vote stays on Jnd. Funny how SL just jumps to another weak one btw

How is jnd's any stronger than yours?

Duh, because Jnd directly tried to prevent his lynch. The difference in the cases is fucking obvious. The only thing I did regarding Clive and on which most of Nag's case is based is that when he came out and said he didn't have a WC and was supposedly third party I believed him. Of course I couldn't foresee that Clive would actually claim a scum character afterwards, but he did seem clueless about it, which I think is true considering his role included Naive. But don't worry, keep case hopping, might uncover some more roles so that you can pick your NK more easily. Peace.

[kalishnikov]

Well I never did get off to do that re-read yesterday, sorry guys. I've got a few work-type things to do then I'm gonna do it so I'll post some actual thoughts in the next few hours.