LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[Iliad]

In fact he said "I know things", which is even more speculative. I'm -4 already I think so please no-one speed lynch.

Also, in regarding to the / comment about me not voting I honestly missed that entire thing, I think it was when my internet wasn't working either that or I was asleep but when I came back I had to re-read and saw all this tests/lynch thing.

I never said anything about that, you voted for Will the first time around, which in my oppinion make it unlikely that you are an Other, or at the very least, if you are, you would be an Usurper (which would explain why Will would be after you I guess.)

no it wouldn't because a godfather wouldn't know that he is an usurper. Cause that would kinda pointless

[pmchugh]

Nag isnt an other IMO however I reckon he could be Charles Widmore which aint good for the town either or at least I would have thought so, but nobody lynch untill we hear the full story, you may as well claim now nag as you will probably have to at some point in order to clear this all up.

[/]

In fact he said "I know things", which is even more speculative. I'm -4 already I think so please no-one speed lynch.

Also, in regarding to the / comment about me not voting I honestly missed that entire thing, I think it was when my internet wasn't working either that or I was asleep but when I came back I had to re-read and saw all this tests/lynch thing.

I never said anything about that, you voted for Will the first time around, which in my oppinion make it unlikely that you are an Other, or at the very least, if you are, you would be an Usurper (which would explain why Will would be after you I guess.)

no it wouldn't because a godfather wouldn't know that he is an usurper. Cause that would kinda pointless

What about Selin's theory of a Mafia cop?
If the Will saw everyone's role but the usurpers, then he would be suspicious enoguh to have a Cop investigate them, though I'm really not sure, it seems a bit far fetched for just the first day, I think Nag is innocent enough for now. (at least not enough for me to vote)

[cmckinney]

I remember that just as we were about to lynch will, he had claimed cop, and had said that his investigations had showed that Nagerous was scum. And considering that william would have known who all the scum was, he might have decided to give Nag, a fellow scum member up so that he could appear cop. Why else would he have chosen Nag? He hadn't done anything suspicious. I'm thinking that william picked him because he knew that if they lynched Nag, he would be accepted as a cop.

[jnd94]

I remember that just as we were about to lynch will, he had claimed cop, and had said that his investigations had showed that Nagerous was scum. And considering that william would have known who all the scum was, he might have decided to give Nag, a fellow scum member up so that he could appear cop. Why else would he have chosen Nag? He hadn't done anything suspicious. I'm thinking that william picked him because he knew that if they lynched Nag, he would be accepted as a cop.

So you're saying that nag and willy were scum buddies? your thought makes sense. William is stupid enough to do something like that.

[cmckinney]

I remember that just as we were about to lynch will, he had claimed cop, and had said that his investigations had showed that Nagerous was scum. And considering that william would have known who all the scum was, he might have decided to give Nag, a fellow scum member up so that he could appear cop. Why else would he have chosen Nag? He hadn't done anything suspicious. I'm thinking that william picked him because he knew that if they lynched Nag, he would be accepted as a cop.

So you're saying that nag and willy were scum buddies? your thought makes sense. William is stupid enough to do something like that.

That's the gist of it...and yes...he does seem stupid enough to do that kind of thing

[Fircoal]

Mandalorian, quit voting and then unvoting to vote them again... One vote will suffice.

VOTE HOPPING! Even the mod knows it!!! Vote: Mandy

[Fircoal]

unvote
Where is fircoal? shouldn't he be posting as well? there are an awful lot on non-players at the moment.

Catching up to the thread...

very slowly

[Fircoal]

6 people prodded..

Sorry about that Gimpy... Missed your post... You obviously don't need to be prodded.

i had posted within those 4 pages and I got prodded -

Then the same apology goes out to you, good sir.

why didn't you prod me? XD

[Fircoal]

Well I will quit counting votes if they are not the full, correct name....

Sorry bro, but you must admit that she has an anoyingly long name. Unvote vote dittoeevee8888

it isn't annoying, if it means what I think it means. (Being what Ditto and Eevee are. )

[Ditocoaf]

Mandalorian, quit voting and then unvoting to vote them again... One vote will suffice.

VOTE HOPPING! Even the mod knows it!!! Vote: Mandy

actually, I think that was when he tried to "unvote dito" and "vote ditto"... which is why I'm going to call dittoeevee "eevee" for short.

[Fircoal]

wow, the fact that only one person wondered why I wasn't posting was surprising. Maybe I should not play more often. Also this game is dominated by n00bs who seem to get themselves into a bad spot and appear more and more scummy. First Ani, then William, and now Cena. "I know things" is on the list for one of the worse reasons to vote someone... ok not really, but it is high on one of the dumbest reasons for a bandwagon. And also you know we are talking about Cena, everyone who as played with him knows he doesn't know things. More seriously, if that was supposed to be a subtle cop investigation claim, it failed. I not only got the idea in my head but so did other people, but if you wanted to claim cop wouldn't you do it so everyone knows or actually subtle.

Also William called out Nag, I think William is dumb enough to pick a person at random and say that he investigated him. N00bs aren't the smartest, and wouldn't think about picking one of their own scum partners to make them look town, or to separate them in the future.

Unvote Vote: Cena To sum it up, Cena DOES NOT know things.

[pmchugh]

wow, the fact that only one person wondered why I wasn't posting was surprising. Maybe I should not play more often. Also this game is dominated by n00bs who seem to get themselves into a bad spot and appear more and more scummy. First Ani, then William, and now Cena. "I know things" is on the list for one of the worse reasons to vote someone... ok not really, but it is high on one of the dumbest reasons for a bandwagon. And also you know we are talking about Cena, everyone who as played with him knows he doesn't know things. More seriously, if that was supposed to be a subtle cop investigation claim, it failed. I not only got the idea in my head but so did other people, but if you wanted to claim cop wouldn't you do it so everyone knows or actually subtle.

Also William called out Nag, I think William is dumb enough to pick a person at random and say that he investigated him. N00bs aren't the smartest, and wouldn't think about picking one of their own scum partners to make them look town, or to separate them in the future.

Unvote Vote: Cena To sum it up, Cena DOES NOT know things.

I would like to hear more from cena there is no point in saying I know things and not telling us what they are, will may be a noob but it doesnt mean that he wouldnt be clever enough to accuse one of his own and he isnt the only one to do so, so nag isnt looking very pro-town to me. Why would cena risk saying this if he had no decent information.

[nagerous]

First off, what would William know, he was a godfather and he had no access to information via a cop, considering this was day one and mafia are not allowed to PM one another during the day phase. Also, his death scene said nothing about being a day cop. You put too much faith in both cena and william's mafia playing abilities, they are both complete idiots and you will learn this in time. I can't beleieve so many people are following their crap, if cena had a genuine lead then he would have posted by now, rather than the crappy I know things and disappear again.

[Anarkistsdream]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

(5) Nagerous – cena-rules, mandalorian2298, neoteny, GT, pmchugh,
(2) Cena-rules – Nagerous, fircoal


With 19 alive it takes ten to lynch!

[got tonkaed]

it would seem that upon further review a lot of the case against nagerous is pretty empty without cena revealing a lot more about what he knows. So mea culpa...

unvote

[cena-rules]

so cena reveals
Im desmond and Im a cop. Got nag as scum

[Anarkistsdream]

Hey Cena...

2. Do not quote any PMs you receive from the Mod. The only things you may post (loosely paraphrasing) are your roles (and anything associated with them) and alignment, during the active game. Once the game has concluded, feel free to post the rest of your personal information.

Everything you just posted besides the first and last sentence were quoted.

[Neoteny]

Bum bum bummmm...

[Anarkistsdream]

This is the SECOND goddamn time that someone has blatantly broken the rules of the game...

My main question is "Why the f*ck would you do that?"

From animorph, it was almost expected, because I already knew he was a tool. But cena, why would you do that?

You know better than to do shit like that, and, if you don't, read the rules on the front page... Some mods may not care but I do...

I put a lot of work into this game and if everyone just runs around posting their PMs I sent then what the f*ck is the point in playing the game?

The next person who breaks the rules from the first page will not be in one of my games, and I will also just shut this game down.

[cena-rules]

Hey Cena...

2. Do not quote any PMs you receive from the Mod. The only things you may post (loosely paraphrasing) are your roles (and anything associated with them) and alignment, during the active game. Once the game has concluded, feel free to post the rest of your personal information.

Everything you just posted besides the first and last sentence were quoted.

soory

shall I edit?

[Anarkistsdream]

Hey Cena...

2. Do not quote any PMs you receive from the Mod. The only things you may post (loosely paraphrasing) are your roles (and anything associated with them) and alignment, during the active game. Once the game has concluded, feel free to post the rest of your personal information.

Everything you just posted besides the first and last sentence were quoted.

soory

shall I edit?

Yes please.

[nagerous]

f*ck this if cena is going to cheat then modkill me please. I've had enough of idiots fucking around first william now cena. I'm out.

[nagerous]

unvote vote nagerous

[nagerous]

Cena should be modkilled for that stunt, editing won't do nothing now as you just revealed all he said must be true Nark.

Thanks a ton.