Un Mafia *Game Over* Town sucks

by **cena-rules** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 3:51 am

me and my 40 phds unvite vote diddle

by **mr. incrediball** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 8:06 am

just when i thought we have a good day 1 going, someone pulls out the wagons... :roll:

fos on the diddle-wagon.

random bandwagoning is NOT cool, people!

by **pmchugh** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 8:46 am

mr. incrediball wrote:just when i thought we have a good day 1 going, someone pulls out the wagons...

fos on the diddle-wagon.

random bandwagoning is NOT cool, people!

ok firstly how else are we ment to get the game going and secondly there was a reason behind my vote, in the last game i played with diddle he never voted anyone in the entire game (lovo's random mafia remember) so i find it strange that he has here. Oh and i was the first one who voted so i wasnt bandwagonning anyway. Not that you were accusing me just asking whats wrong with it?

by **nagerous** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 8:50 am

pmchugh wrote:
mr. incrediball wrote:just when i thought we have a good day 1 going, someone pulls out the wagons...

fos on the diddle-wagon.

random bandwagoning is NOT cool, people!

ok firstly how else are we ment to get the game going and secondly there was a reason behind my vote, in the last game i played with diddle he never voted anyone in the entire game (lovo's random mafia remember) so i find it strange that he has here. Oh and i was the first one who voted so i wasnt bandwagonning anyway. Not that you were accusing me just asking whats wrong with it?

Metagaming is not a good idea if you have little experience, following how diddle played in one other game should mean nothing.

If however, you do have a lot of experience and have played 30 or so games with diddle in the past, which I have you should know his playing style... which is actually generally being very quiet and never posting his own theories and what not... exactly the kind of guy that would be good for a day one lynch and he is unlikely to help the town too much.

unvote vote diddle.

by **pmchugh** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 9:32 am

nagerous wrote:
pmchugh wrote:
mr. incrediball wrote:just when i thought we have a good day 1 going, someone pulls out the wagons...

fos on the diddle-wagon.

random bandwagoning is NOT cool, people!

ok firstly how else are we ment to get the game going and secondly there was a reason behind my vote, in the last game i played with diddle he never voted anyone in the entire game (lovo's random mafia remember) so i find it strange that he has here. Oh and i was the first one who voted so i wasnt bandwagonning anyway. Not that you were accusing me just asking whats wrong with it?

Metagaming is not a good idea if you have little experience, following how diddle played in one other game should mean nothing.

If however, you do have a lot of experience and have played 30 or so games with diddle in the past, which I have you should know his playing style... which is actually generally being very quiet and never posting his own theories and what not... exactly the kind of guy that would be good for a day one lynch and he is unlikely to help the town too much.

unvote vote diddle.

ok so basically you are saying is im being stupid for metagaming from one game even although i correctly picked up his playing style and then you agree with the vote

by **firth4eva** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 3:11 pm

[b] vote diddle[/b] so that i don't look susiscious

by **animorpherv1** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 3:13 pm

that's supicious in and of itself so [b] unvote vote firth[/b]

by **cena-rules** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 3:20 pm

*slaps morph with his 40phds*

NEVER USE LOGIC ON DAY 1

by **Ditocoaf** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 3:22 pm

:eyeroll: yes, only mafia don't want to look suspicious.

But he's right, you should only vote if you actually think he's scum, not just to fit. I'm going to see diddles defense first; I haven't seen him in other games so I'd be only relying on hearsay to call his behavior scummy at this point. But he may well betray himself in his response (or lack of one).

by **Minister Masket** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 4:41 pm

firth4eva wrote: vote diddle so that i don't look susiscious

Not only can you not spell coherently, but you also cannot use texts properly.

by **nagerous** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 4:44 pm

I'm saying if you're going to metagame, do it properly and not based on just one game.

by **animorpherv1** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 6:33 pm

guys, my bolding is screwed, I'll try to find a way to fix it [b]test to check[/b]

by **dustn64** on Thu Apr 10, 2008 8:23 pm

by **Iliad** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 12:36 am

wow I made a joke to laugh at diddle and suddenly all these people jump on it

by **Skoffin** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 4:22 am

Iliad wrote:wow I made a joke to laugh at diddle and suddenly all these people jump on it

One word: Baaaah.

by **Iliad** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 4:26 am

Skoffin wrote:
Iliad wrote:wow I made a joke to laugh at diddle and suddenly all these people jump on it

One word: Baaaah.

sums this up perfectly

by **mr. incrediball** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 4:42 am

pmchugh wrote:
mr. incrediball wrote:just when i thought we have a good day 1 going, someone pulls out the wagons...

fos on the diddle-wagon.

random bandwagoning is NOT cool, people!

ok firstly how else are we ment to get the game going and secondly there was a reason behind my vote, in the last game i played with diddle he never voted anyone in the entire game (lovo's random mafia remember) so i find it strange that he has here. Oh and i was the first one who voted so i wasnt bandwagonning anyway. Not that you were accusing me just asking whats wrong with it?

i'm just saying, a random bandwagon on day 1 is pure gold for scum looking for a quick lynch.

i wasn't accusing you, since your vote was random, but skoff (illy? curse the esoog and their uniform avatars!) and cena know better. usually, the bandwagons that get rolling without any real evidence are aimed at townies, and the scum are the first to hop on.

so, i'd go in to vote illy (possibly skoff, whichever one it was) or cena to make my point, but

firth wrote:vote diddle so as not to look suscicious

this is ultra-scummy. unvote vote firth.

by **cena-rules** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 5:36 am

ok my 40 phds had a reason to vote diddle.

I have 40phds firc made a list with a role that had 40phds. this was presented and diddle voted me

by **pmchugh** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 6:12 am

Iliad wrote:wow I made a joke to laugh at diddle and suddenly all these people jump on it

actually i made a joke and you jumped on!

by **Iliad** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 6:32 am

Iliad wrote:
pmchugh wrote:
diddle wrote:I just started to read the first 4 pages, then I remembered it was day 1and laughed.

But then I thought I wouldn't want to look like an idiot if I made a gigantic error in my first vote, so began to read again.

Of course, it soon dawned on me that this is a Fircoal game, so why bother rereading.

Vote Cena

diddle actually voted someone?!? unvote vote diddle

oh my god! why would worry so much about making mistake if he was a pro-town

unvote vote diddle the scum

not really.

We both joked but for different reasons

by **nagerous** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 8:19 am

Firth's probably jester.

by **nagerous** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 8:20 am

by **pmchugh** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 8:36 am

nagerous wrote:Firth's probably jester.

good call, i think.

by **firth4eva** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 11:35 am

You're all stupid

by **Fircoal** on Fri Apr 11, 2008 1:51 pm

Vote Count

Militant (1) Cena,
animorpherv (2) Militant, LSU,
LSU (2) Skoff, LV,
Frenchie-chan (1) MM,
MM (1) Frenchie-chan,
LV (1) MIB,
Cena (1) Diddle,
Diddle (5) Pmchugh Illy, Cena, Nag, Firth
Pmchugh (1) Dustn,
Firth (1) animorpherv,

16 Alive, 9 to lynch, 5 to get a kick in the balls (1 for LV)

Diddle and LV get kicked in the balls