Barroom mafia. Mod is pushed off of a cliff. DRAW

[kalishnikov]

The Diddle connection looks weak at best, as firth said he was clearly just trying to keep the game going. I never noticed I was mentioned in that long ga7 quote, at the end. I'm gonna have to do some re-reading.

[ga7]

More like it should be easy to figure out if Diddle is really doc as he claims afterwards. Skoff & AD obviously skimmed the shit out of this, which at this point tells a fair bit as there's not so much to read in this game.

[got tonkaed]

i r serious business....confirming as a replacement and ill read the thread and catch up tommorow.

[The Weird One]

ANNOUNCEMENT

GT is replacing mcsnipe

[LSU Tiger Josh]

tsk tsk constant skimming = scummy especially after I had just done it a few pages before lol although at least I had the excuse of doing it between classes at school and reread it right after when I got off work.

[lord voldemort]

having read through there isnt heaps tp gp on...alot of skimming by good players is happening...which sucks.but yer...
gonna fos ad (skim) and firth (that bandwagon dealio a pag back)

[diddle]

Good point Skoffin...

Why have people not voted Diddle?

More like 'Why have people not UNvoted Diddle?'

[kalishnikov]

Well, we need a lynch. This day has been going on forever... But as already stated, there aren't many leads to go on at the moment.

I never did do that re-read, perhaps I will now.

[The Weird One]

UPDATE

Fircoal, was having a drink when, out of the ceiling, a pair of heads fell. Their faces were melted in such a way that all of their potentially identifiable features were erased.

[got tonkaed]

sucks for those guys....

in a way i think firth is currently the most dangerous guy for the town in the game. Seemingly (and its been a while since ive tried this mafia thing) day 1-3 are pretty much a mess because people by in large dont know anything of value. Ideally if you can get town to the later days with someone who can shoot osmething or investigate your probably going to start doing alright.

What inevitably screws this up, is some day 1 and 2 superhero who thinks he has cracked the game, usually on players who probably arent crafty enough to matter all that much (sorry diddle). Now every so often this works great for the town, as apparently day 1 scum random bandwagons do happen.

I just dont think diddle should be getting a whole lot of crap from ga7 for spotting a guy who was the scums on day 1 and arguing against someone patterning this game by day 3.

That doesnt mean he deserves to live though.

[The Weird One]

well, a few people have dropped and need replacing...

[dustn64]

Ok, Lets get this day over with and move on. Maybe we will strike gold at night.

[got tonkaed]

thats really not very good reasoning sir.

[The Weird One]

well, any townie (or person who wouldn't know too much) will be asked to replace someone.

[kalishnikov]

Upon re-reading I have learned 2 things: 1) the days have been really long, 2) nothing of any real relevance has happened in this game.

So should we give into the 'lets get this day over with' thinking that benefits no one but the scum? At this point I'm not even sure it matters with all the submarining.

I still think firth is the man for the lynch today. He's been playing the 'useful townie' far to well in this game, then got quiet after he got some heat. Done it myself, tried to take control to the scum side and got called out, problem is as soon as you get quiet any decent scum-player sees it for what it is. The useful townie is a hard scum tactic, but the best if you got the balls for it as you can usually get a lot of support from skimmers/dumbasses.

diddle won't get my vote till I can get a decent reason to give it to him, the only person that really looks scummy to me at the moment I've already mentioned.

[Fircoal]

I see Tonka's point.

Unvote
Vote: Firth

[dustn64]

Unvote vote firth

[firth4eva]

I'll roleclaim to liven things up. I am a bouncer, I am a vig. I killed Fircoal night one because I knew it would piss him off.

[got tonkaed]

so then the mafia got blocked night 1?

[firth4eva]

Probably. Or I could have killed Fircoal before he killed someone, if that's possible

[kalishnikov]

Hmm, seems a likely scum roleclaim to me (with only one kill last night) and a good one at that as its very doubtful he'll be countered on either the vig claim or the kill claim.

[firth4eva]

No it doesn't kalish. And why won't I be countered? Any player with a brain would swap vig for scum. I targeted you earlier in this game, in the day, to see how a good player would react to my accusations but now I really do think you are scum.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Unvote I'll believe firth for now although he might be worth buying the drinks for in the future to make sure of that. I'm unsure of who I want to vote on for this day though since Firth has bought at least a one day pass before a forced roleclaim as everyone should've sent in their round of drinks already.

[ga7]

Well, Firth might be vig or sk but I doubt he'd claim to have offed Fir if it wasn't true. I think much as Diddle it'd be best to leave the matter aside for now. Though we still have to finish this day and preferably without other unnecessary roleclaims. People don't seem ready to have a go at the scummy skimmers, so here's an alternative as all in all his claim is what convinces me the least today:

Roleclaim dustn and it might make the game more active.

fine. I am a mason. I will not say my partner yet.

Dunno if you guys noticed but every role seems to come with flavor. This looks likely to be an outright lie, and if it's not, no big loss and we'll know there is a mason that we could trust later on. Granted, it's a pretty weak approach but I think going to the next day to be able to sort the Diddle & Firth matter will be way more useful right now.
And FOS GT for defending his scum partner (just had to get it out somewhere )
Unvote Vote Dustn

[got tonkaed]

ga7 logic seems pretty reasonable to me at the moment (outside of the historic objection)

vote dustn