Jdsizzleslice wrote:Dukasaur wrote:In exchange for Trump's recognition of Moroccan mastery of the region, Morocco will become the fourth Arab nation to sign on to normalize relations with Israel. Expect some more breast-beating about how Trump "brought peace to the Middle East" because 4 out of 22 Arab League nations (almost 20% !!!) will then have signed his bogus "peace deal."
So... getting other Arab nations to normalize relations with Israel is "bogus", Duk?
Are you so filled with hatred for Trump that you can't even acknowledge a good thing that he does?
We've been through your second question before. I'll acknowledge that I hate Trump pretty intensely. It does not override truth. On those occasions when he has done something right, I have been willing to acknowlege it.
What makes Trump's Israel treaty bogus is not that it is bad. I'll acknowledge that getting Arab countries to normalize relations with Israel is a positive step. What's bogus about it is that it does not come anywhere close to meeting the hype that Trump's spin doctors have been attributing to it. They actually use phrases like "brought peace to the Middle East" and his deal does nothing of the sort. None of the four Arab nations that signed on to the deal were ever significant in the wars against Isreal. It's nice that they made peace, but they were never really at war. Morocco and Sudan did send token forces to join in the major Arab-Israeli wars, the last of which ended half a century ago. (Only the Moroccan force actually engaged in combat; the Sudanese force only arrived after the cease-fire had been signed.) Bahrain and the Emirates didn't even do that much. None of the four were really at war with Israel any more except on paper.
When Carter brokered peace between Israel and Egypt, that was a meaningful step towards peace. Israel and Egypt did actually fight several shooting wars with tens of thousands of casualties and frightening material damage. Brokering peace between them changed things dramatically for both, and although they've had some border skirmishes since then, the peace is basically solid.\
When Clinton brokered a peace between Israel and Jordan, that was a meaningful step toward peace. Jordan had fought in every single Arab-Israeli war and like Egypt it had suffered tens of thousands of casualties. 50 years of war ended with that treaty and has led to almost 25 years of peace.
This treaty between Isreal and four minor members of the Arab League who are not really fighting with it and haven't in 47 years, is just window dressing. It's nice, yes. A game changer? Absolutely not. Deserving of all the ceaseless self-congratulations the Trumpists give each other for it? No.
What's more, it's come at a frightening cost. Morocco's signature, as we discussed yesterday, was obtained at the price of rubber-stamping the Moroccan conquest of the Sahlawi people in Western Sahara, essentially ending the dream of Sahlawi independence. I would not be at all surprised if genocide is the next step. Today we learned that Trump is sending
a billion dollars' worth of military toys to Morocco. So, tacit permission to slaughter the Sahlawi, and a $1 billion pack of implements of destruction to do it with, all to get their signature on an essentially symbolic document that won't change much.