static_ice wrote:The characters of American Dad aren't that great... the alien and the fish try to be like Brian and Stewie, the "relief characters", but they fail horribly. In fact all the main characters in AD are just less-funny and more cliche versions of their respective family guy counterparts.
Actually they are entirely different from them. The whole show is different, whereas Family guy makes countless pop culture references and revolves around a bunch of retards, American dad makes fun of patriotism and politics. The characters in AD actually appear to be more realistic. The show itself is just way more intellectual and has darker humor than Family guy.
Honestly, comparing it to Family Guy is just as retarded as comparing Futurama to the Simpsons. It's the knee-jerk reaction of "hey it's written by the same people so it must be similiar" which dooms many good shows. They're all good shows and also different from eachother.
Besides, it takes a few episodes to actually get the idea behind it. I had the same thing with futurama, I didn't enjoy the first few I watched because the jokes got lost. The humor in both Futurama and American Dad is not obvious, you miss it if you're not paying attention since the jokes build up in a longer time than Family Guy, The Simpsons or South Park.
South Park is easily the best, but from this list Simpsons is totally superior. People consider it boring because they don't get the side jokes, the symbolism, while the only thing Family Guy can do is sex jokes, slap stick, and celebrity criticism.
I think people consider the Simpsons to be boring because it is in fact boring. How can strangling Bart still be funny after 10 years? Noone can keep a show interresting for more than 6 seasons, no matter how talented you are.