mrswdk wrote:I was curious about why the Korean and Taiwanese administrations have been going nuts for giving everyone face masks and from a bit of Googling it sounds like the reason they are doing so is because wearing masks will help symptom-less carriers avoid passing on COVID to other people before they carrier has been diagnosed (e.g.
this article says the Korean government are recommending only people with symptoms wear masks. Other medical experts in the country are arguing with thatand saying that healthy people should wear them too, which they are saying
because those people might be symptom-less carriers at risk of spreading the disease to other people). So yes, some governments in Asia are mass-producing masks in response to the COVID outbreak, but they're not saying masks will stop you contracting COVID.
Incidentally wearing masks to prevent yourself spreading a disease has been a practice in Japan for quite a long time as far as I'm aware. People who are sick often wear masks when they're out and about to stop them from passing their sickness on to other people.
As I said earlier, if you're in close contact with COVID carriers for extended periods of time then a mask will help you avoid contracting COVID - but only if combined with eye protection and some pretty serious and regular sterilisation on your clothes, hands etc. The virus spreads via vapour droplets, which can enter your body via your eyes just as much as they can via your mouth or nose, so a mask by itself won't do anything.
Appreciate you're just trying to look out for your wife but the mask thing is a needless distraction. There are all sorts of other things you can be doing instead.
Obviously, looking out for the wife is a major part of it.
In a broader sense, I'm looking out for our society.
If looks fairly clear that Taiwan, Singapore, and South Korea are winning the war against Covid. It does not look as if the war is being won in the West.
What Taiwan, Singapore, and South Korea have in common is that their approach is individual-based. It is using what could be called surgical strikes -- extensive testing, accurate tracking of infected individuals, selective quarantines of those who are known or suspected to be infected. Masks, in my opinion, are an important part of that individual mandate, but we can disagree about that and the rest still stands.
What the West is doing is city-based. Testing is haphazard and sloppy, tracking of infected individuals is haphazard and sloppy, and entire cities are being locked down without any clear knowledge of how many people in them are infected. It's an aggregate approach that leaves the individual out of the equation. While the Eastern nations are doing targetted surgical strikes, the Western nations are doing something akin to chopping an onion with a medieval halberd.
The Western approach is demonstrably less effective, even while it's more devastating to our economies. In South Korea, even at the height of the epidemic, most people were able to go to work. In North America we are already into double-digit unemployment numbers, and it may get a whole lot worse before it gets better. And our societies are not equipped for it. Just in the last day, I have read and/or watched news articles about people bypassing/violating/ignoring lockdowns in: Palermo, Paris, Miami, Los Angeles, Vancouver. We do, or at least we did, have the resources to do what Taiwan did, quarantining and tracking suspected carriers, shutting down large-scale gathering places but not entire cities, having moderate social distancing that doesn't prevent people from going to work. We do not, and likely never will, have the resources to enforce these large-scale lockdowns. They depend on the goodwill of the public, which so far has been remarkably strong, but won't last forever. We got lucky that it's been cold and rainy across much of the northern hemisphere. When nice weather comes, go see how many people you will find packed in to the Bois de Boulogne or Hyde Park or the National Mall.