[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[dazza2008]

Big ass claim, the Mtam lynch might not go through after all. Good.

Him being HP explains his ballsy attitude towards the game though, @ all the people questioning his tactics. If his play went south (like it did), he could just nameclaim and everyone would unvote. I think the character he claims fits his strategy very well.

So anyone gonna just sheep me now

Sheep your vote on ragian? That case is dead.

@Streaker, you mean 'right after being called out by you'. Degaston has been voting Pershy for ages due to his inactivity, he didn't respond. What makes you special?


I love how we've established that Tonk is town without any arguments. I'm guessing it's his inherent sympathy that I'm not seeing.

At the very least he isn't lynched today imo. Tonk, was very vocal about not pushing Sempai, defending him etc. To then only take the lead and steam role into tambo. Just feel a bit to much for mafia to try and do day 1, to draw that much attention. Feels more like a stubborn town pushing on mtamb.

I think mafia are more likely to wagon on either vote tbh, or vote neither / keep votes on random people.

Virus kinda comes to mind. I think he has been far to lo key this game in what he has been doing.
Dd
Dazza

feel like good places to push as well

Pershy, yeah ill give him another 12-24 hours to see whats up.

There's a shock. I vote you then you're pal then you want to vote me. Funny as f*ck

Also I would be inclined to support a push on charm. I don't think the dazza case is going anywhere today but perhaps we can revisit tomorrow.

Is there even a dazza case? Must have missed it. Is it because I voted late on? I voted late on because I read it late on. He was being a cock for pages so I would have voted much earlier if I had caught up then.

[mtamburini]

Big ass claim, the Mtam lynch might not go through after all. Good.

Him being HP explains his ballsy attitude towards the game though, @ all the people questioning his tactics. If his play went south (like it did), he could just nameclaim and everyone would unvote. I think the character he claims fits his strategy very well.

So anyone gonna just sheep me now

Sheep your vote on ragian? That case is dead.

@Streaker, you mean 'right after being called out by you'. Degaston has been voting Pershy for ages due to his inactivity, he didn't respond. What makes you special?


I love how we've established that Tonk is town without any arguments. I'm guessing it's his inherent sympathy that I'm not seeing.

At the very least he isn't lynched today imo. Tonk, was very vocal about not pushing Sempai, defending him etc. To then only take the lead and steam role into tambo. Just feel a bit to much for mafia to try and do day 1, to draw that much attention. Feels more like a stubborn town pushing on mtamb.

I think mafia are more likely to wagon on either vote tbh, or vote neither / keep votes on random people.

Virus kinda comes to mind. I think he has been far to lo key this game in what he has been doing.
Dd
Dazza

feel like good places to push as well

Pershy, yeah ill give him another 12-24 hours to see whats up.

There's a shock. I vote you then you're pal then you want to vote me. Funny as f*ck

Also I would be inclined to support a push on charm. I don't think the dazza case is going anywhere today but perhaps we can revisit tomorrow.

Is there even a dazza case? Must have missed it. Is it because I voted late on? I voted late on because I read it late on. He was being a cock for pages so I would have voted much earlier if I had caught up then.

I dont like your attitude, thats the case , I think your a big cock and you called my friend storr names early on in begining, so you should die for that as well

[dazza2008]

Now I see the dazza case

I will read back now. You can all add skimming to the case lol

[mtamburini]

Also I would be inclined to support a push on charm. I don't think the dazza case is going anywhere today but perhaps we can revisit tomorrow.

Or we can just lynch him wihtout a case because hes annoying

[mtamburini]

If Mtam is harry potter, he is possibly the worst mafia player Ive ever seen.

On a side note, Mets remark, I agree with him. I also dont think its fair that Mtam can spout off countless insults and nonsense, but mets says one thing and hye gets crap. Id post some of Mtams BS, but theres literally 100000 worthless posts to sift through.

I think Mtam is lying and is not Harry Potter.

I remmeber you from the begining of the game, still as useless as before.

What makes you so much better than I?

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

mtamburini - sempai, sempai, virus, skillful, madmitch, Pixar, BG
Ragian - mtamburini, dd
charm - HotShot, Ragian
pershy - floyd, dazza, degaston
dd- Talapus, Endgame
degaston - metsfan
dazza - Streaker, Storr

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

Deadline Friday, noon Eastern Time.

[mtamburini]

Well, I finally caught up on about 10 pages of mtam and got going back and forth to find out it's all meaningless now anyway lol. Since everyone would assume HP is in the game, I assume scum wouldn't fake claim him, so I'll assume mtam is telling the truth

Got was trying to pressure who he thought was scum (and avoidance of questions as mtam was doing can sometimes be a scum tell for some people, so it wasn't that bad of a push), so I am town reading got for now, I don't think a scum would stick themselves out quite that much. I'm iffy on daeg's late joining of the case, he's still neutral to slight scum to me.

Charm's posts on the mtam case were that we should pressure him because he wasn't answering questions but "I don't think we should lynch MTam unless he comes back with doing something very scummy. But, I have a hard time believing he is town when he throws up that he some special power."

So she wanted to pressure, but not lynch, but found it hard to think he was town... kind of a very wishy-washy position to take, so it's not changing my vote on her yet.

As for pershy, he is as good an inactivish person to pressure as any I guess, we'll see how he responds to the prod he just got before I'll add to his pressure.

Worthless post, your read on why got is town is not logical. You didnt even mention anything about aage

You don't have the monopoly on logic you know... just because you don't agree with someone's reasoning doesn't make it illogical. There is no case on aage, so didn't see a reason to mention him. My opinion is similar to what Ragian just posted, that he could be town defending you against a bad argument, or scum buddying up to a soon-to-be proven town. I'll lean town on him, but not 100% proven.

Aage had a huge impact on got explaining the reasonings why he asked the questions, thats not relevant to why you think the questions were bad in the first place?

[mtamburini]

VOTE COUNT

StorrZerg - dazza
mtamburini - sempai, sempai, virus, charm, skillful, madmitch, tonkaed, Pixar, BG, degaston (L-3) dazza voted after the vote count to make it l2 before the claim
Ragian - mtamburini, dd
charm - HotShot, Endgame, Ragian
pershy - floyd
dd- Talapus

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

Deadline Friday, noon Eastern Time.

There clearly isnt much sense in sempai being voted but i think you could make an argument for anyone after my vote plus charm. I know it is apparently pixar's meta, but not wanting a lynch seems bad. BG not believing the claim without a counter also seems scummy.

you mean to say more towny, ill just correct that for you

[got tonkaed]

no i dont. I mean to say its scummy. I dont think a scum player would have gotten a safe claim of Harry Potter.

[dazza2008]

EBWOP for messing up the quote.

Tell me how storr was being productive for town then, and how everyone else was being productive

@Dazza Not excusable you will be lynched after hotshot

Fair enough. I can save time and not read all the pish you post then. Cheers.

He's joking because everyone is on his ass for not posting after he posted what i quoted above.

I got it but thanks for explaining.

3 pages of mtamburini not answering questions is shite though. I have seen nothing from him that helps town in the slightest. He just gets offensive when anyone asks anything. I can't tell if he is scummy or just being a twat as town but either way it's f*ck all help to town.

unvote vote mtamburini

Putting dazza on the hotseat tomorrow for this. Completely ignoring the fact that the 'questions' themselves are shite.
Aage did a good job of explaining this.

Even if the questions were shite he could have done better to explain why rather than just be a complete and utter cock about it and create pages of bullshit for everyone to read. As I explained his play seemed scummy or very unhelpful townie at best.

He is referring to me storr.

Who do you think was sheeping your push then?

I had a vote on Charm before mtam. Pixar would probably have been my second guess. Lots of support for the no lynch.

Not defending it but pixie does this every game in our clan games. We have tried to explain to him that it is shit but he doesn't get it

He could still be scum but just saying he always votes no lynch day 1.

Defending the one soft pushing no lynch now?

Not really defending him just explaining something that many players here won't know as they are not in the same clan so can't see previous games in our forum. Not saying there is no case on Pix just saying a case based solely on what he always(wrongly in my opinion) does is weak.

Recapped, dazza was on both Storr's and Mtamb's wagon without pushing his own case. It's pretty much the definition of sheeping/wagoning.
This pretty much sums up his actions:

I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.

I keep hearing people say Storr may have a trick up his sleeve or he may be useful later on.

He's either a 3rd party survivor who has done nothing but draw attention to himself, claimed without pressure and made D1 suck worse than normal OR hes lying about the full extent of his role.

So, yeah. Ill lynch based on poor play or Ill lynch on Lynch all Liars...

This is pretty much exactly what I am thinking.

Vote Stor

He did the same with Mtamb as stated above. Clearly jumping on the bigger cases, all when the wagon is going full steam ahead. Not sticking head out at all. No reads on anyone.

Unvote, vote dazza.

I know deadline is coming up. We need to agree on a lynch. If you guys support my case, all the better.
Are you willing to lynch an inactive if things slow down this week? Not sure if we have any (dd comes to mind).

I totally agreed with BG about Storr. I still feel exactly the same if I am honest. If it was up to me we would have lynched Storr. Nobody else agreed so I moved on.

I've explained why I voted Mtam and I feel I gave reasons. I don't think I did just vote based on what others thought. I took their points into consideration then made up my mind. If I am not meant to listen to other peoples opinions what is the point in anyone posting anything ever?

Then after the claim I voted pershy because in my experience he is normally more active. He has since said he has been busy but I still feel he is worth pressuring.

No reads on anyone? I think I gave a few. I will again just for you. Aage and Got seem town based on their play. Mtam seems town based on his claim. Semp too. Storr still seems scummy to me he could be what he claims but I would lynch him, nobody agrees as I said so I have moved on as I said.

Everyone else I don't have a strong enough read one way or the other to make it worth saying.

[dazza2008]

Also I would be inclined to support a push on charm. I don't think the dazza case is going anywhere today but perhaps we can revisit tomorrow.

Or we can just lynch him wihtout a case because hes annoying

Awesome plan

[StorrZerg]

Tambo take a chill pill, take the dick level down 4 notches

[Metsfanmax]

BG not believing the claim without a counter also seems scummy.

We cannot even be sure of that yet; there are some players who haven't checked in for a while and probably don't know about the claim.

[Metsfanmax]

BG not believing the claim without a counter also seems scummy.

We cannot even be sure of that yet; there are some players who haven't checked in for a while and probably don't know about the claim.

Also scummy is definitely the wrong word here. If BG was scum then the smart thing to do would be to go along with everyone else; openly questioning a solid claim that hasn't been counter-claimed is bound to get you noticed (proof right here). Scum don't like getting noticed. Being skeptical of such a thing I'd say is a pretty towny action and it boosts his town cred in my eyes, certainly.

[got tonkaed]

Fair enough. Both posts make sense.

[StorrZerg]

@Dazza you have 0 case against me for scummy play other than my claim. Get real

Fp by mets,
others pushed first. He could be following.

[dazza2008]

@Dazza you have 0 case against me for scummy play other than my claim. Get real

I find your play scummy. If I feel it is am I not allowed to say so? Shall i just give you my password and you can play for me?

There was a case made against me and i just answered each part. What else can i do? I see no fucking point posting anything when I do all I get it told to get real.

[dazza2008]

Part of the case against me is that I just hopped on wagons without adding anything. Which I think is untrue. But surely Stor is doing exactly that. This was his contribution to the case.

vote dazza2008

That add fucking loads. Well played stor

[StorrZerg]

@Dazza you have 0 case against me for scummy play other than my claim. Get real

I find your play scummy. If I feel it is am I not allowed to say so? Shall i just give you my password and you can play for me?

There was a case made against me and i just answered each part. What else can i do? I see no fucking point posting anything when I do all I get it told to get real.

Please keep describing my play in most vague way you can. I've given reads, I've given opinions on why, you comment on none of it. The only point you really address is sheeping bg on "bad play or scum to be claiming survivor so early"

I'm asking you to explain my scummy actions that have no relation to my claim. It shouldn't be hard if you do find my play scummy.

And my contribution to the case against you is on going.

[dazza2008]

Big ass claim, the Mtam lynch might not go through after all. Good.

Him being HP explains his ballsy attitude towards the game though, @ all the people questioning his tactics. If his play went south (like it did), he could just nameclaim and everyone would unvote. I think the character he claims fits his strategy very well.

So anyone gonna just sheep me now

Sheep your vote on ragian? That case is dead.

@Streaker, you mean 'right after being called out by you'. Degaston has been voting Pershy for ages due to his inactivity, he didn't respond. What makes you special?


I love how we've established that Tonk is town without any arguments. I'm guessing it's his inherent sympathy that I'm not seeing.

At the very least he isn't lynched today imo. Tonk, was very vocal about not pushing Sempai, defending him etc. To then only take the lead and steam role into tambo. Just feel a bit to much for mafia to try and do day 1, to draw that much attention. Feels more like a stubborn town pushing on mtamb.

I think mafia are more likely to wagon on either vote tbh, or vote neither / keep votes on random people.

Virus kinda comes to mind. I think he has been far to lo key this game in what he has been doing.
Dd
Dazza

feel like good places to push as well

Pershy, yeah ill give him another 12-24 hours to see whats up.

There's a shock. I vote you then you're pal then you want to vote me. Funny as f*ck

Also I would be inclined to support a push on charm. I don't think the dazza case is going anywhere today but perhaps we can revisit tomorrow.

Is there even a dazza case? Must have missed it. Is it because I voted late on? I voted late on because I read it late on. He was being a cock for pages so I would have voted much earlier if I had caught up then.

I dont like your attitude, thats the case , I think your a big cock and you called my friend storr names early on in begining, so you should die for that as well

lol missed this one earlier. Must have been fastposted and it never said.

Brilliant case. I don't much like my attitude either but it's the only one I have so I just go with it. I called Storr names? If we were 5 you should tell the teacher. We're not so get a fucking grip buddy. If you want to lynch a townie for calling your friend a name then crack on pal. Probably be a relief more than anything not to read this shite for days.

fastposted. Storr I think the sooner you realise I play my way and not how you want the better. Every game you try to tell me how to play and it's getting boring bud. The case on me is f*ck all. It's a case based on me voting you then your friend. I have friends in this game but surely basing play on play rather than friendship is the way to go.

I class pershy as a friend. Should I unvote?

[StorrZerg]

I'm sorry, was reading tambo as town wrong? Was goading a reaction out of him friendly?

Drop the crap. And stop delaying a case on me.

Like Nike
"Just do it"

[dazza2008]

I'm sorry, was reading tambo as town wrong? Was goading a reaction out of him friendly?

Drop the crap. And stop delaying a case on me.

Like Nike
"Just do it"

BG posted his thoughts. I agreed to them. Still do. Nobody else agreed so I moved on(as I said).

What does anyone gain by us going over it again and again?

[StorrZerg]

I'm sorry, was reading tambo as town wrong? Was goading a reaction out of him friendly?

Drop the crap. And stop delaying a case on me.

Like Nike
"Just do it"

BG posted his thoughts. I agreed to them. Still do. Nobody else agreed so I moved on(as I said).

What does anyone gain by us going over it again and again?

W/e I don't care.

who besides pershy would you try for a lynch today.
(Yes besides me being "scummy")

[dazza2008]

I already posted this pal. Can't tell if you never read it or you are just being a cock. Either way it is annoying as f*ck.

[StorrZerg]

I already posted this pal. Can't tell if you never read it or you are just being a cock. Either way it is annoying as f*ck.

I'm asking a legitimate question.

You are pushing pershy, and i don't see you calling anyone else scummy.

Defending pixar based on his actions regarding no lynch and claims. Which I agree with.

Got /aage town reads etc.