Moderator: Community Team
pmchugh wrote:Given the rules, he dies anyway.
Ragian wrote:No, he's saying that the rules in this game are that the one with the most votes at deadline is lynched.
fusibaseball wrote:I've been following the thread and haven't have too much to add. Just to follow up on my long post from earlier with clearer thoughts on my arguments:
We have a lot of Vanillas this game (#VanillaLivesMatter). In these cases, if you're voting for someone, you should be legitimately interested in lynching said person. They can just claim Vanilla and then just "pressure" doesn't really accomplish much.
In games where everyone has a power role, I feel bandwagons and forcing out claims is more useful in comparison, especially really early like Day 1 or 2, because you force a Scum to follow the same thread throughout the entire game. Oftentimes discrepancies will arise by the time you reach final 5 or whatever and you can weed out whose story hasn't really added up through all the night results.
------------------------
Regarding the PMC lynch contract with the groups, I guess you could put me on a Selective Lynchers list. There's about half the group I would not be interested in lynching anytime soon because I'm fairly sure they're town. PMC and LC are at the top of my list for Town because they contribute independent, objective thoughts to how they're approaching this Matrix setup. That to me is the hallmark of Towniness...being investigative. It's similar to my thoughts on Sonic for many games before this...I PERSONALLY just have a hard time believing a Mafia player would write so much and in all that text never say something self-incriminating. Sure enough, he was Town pretty much every game even though he was constantly FOS'ed. I see the same thing happening to PMC and LC here. I'd like to see an actual Scum take the time to come up with a plan as elaborate as LC's just for the sake of "looking Town". I don't care if I get FOS'ed for writing my own thoughts...people seem to love doing that. I'm usually on the right track which is part of why I get chronically night killed early.
-----------------------
I see a lot of people have jumped on my Swang train, so the question is, am I legitimately interested in lynching Swang? I assume he'll just claim Vanilla if he's scum, as any PR will just be counterclaimed and a 1:1 trade town for Scum at this stage is always worth. I am, for a few reasons people seem to be missing since I initially voted, primarily relating to the intel it generates:
1) If Swang is Scum, myself, Kong, and Vot should be virtually confirmed Townies for people actively reading the thread. No way would fellows Scums A) start the vote against him when he had no prior heat (myself), B) actively jump on a bandwagon with no supporting evidence (Kong), or C) strongly agree with my argument within 24 hours and later join the vote (Vot). That's a huge amount of intel that can weed out a lot of Townies and wasted time and votes to help hone targets.
2) If Swang is Scum, I feel Max is probably Scum as well, and my plan has been to go after him Day 2 should my Swang vote happen to materialize. I think within 5 minutes of me posting, Max just said "FOS Fusi" when all I was doing was sharing my thoughts on the Matrix and he seemed to have zero interest in giving Swang any attention. That to me was pretty noticeable.
3) If Swang is Scum, Dev is virtually confirmed Townie because Swang's brief attention to the game resulted in him voting for Dev. I don't think Scum votes for Scum Day 1 under all but the most extreme circumstances, of which this is not
4) If Swang is Town, later vote bandwagoners become slightly incriminated for me, as I think Scum would probably send 1 (maybe 2) people from their group out to the vote and leave the others in reserves. So if 8 people end up voting for him, I'd say there's almost certainly 1 Scum (maybe 2) in the last 4 or 5 voters, while the rest of Scum likely did not participate in the vote. I hesitate to say that, because legitimate Townies should be interesting in joining the vote considering the above reasoning and I don't want to scare people off, but it's an important thought that I feel should be shared
SoN!c wrote:Ragian wrote:No, he's saying that the rules in this game are that the one with the most votes at deadline is lynched.
Well i missed that somehow, where is that stated?
PMC is already popping the champagne here and your making excuses for it?
Rules should be in opening post if deviant and there is nothing there about this?
Extreme Ways wrote:SoN!c wrote:Ragian wrote:No, he's saying that the rules in this game are that the one with the most votes at deadline is lynched.
Well i missed that somehow, where is that stated?
PMC is already popping the champagne here and your making excuses for it?
Rules should be in opening post if deviant and there is nothing there about this?
this is correct
Extreme Ways wrote:My time to host, after having subbed, specced, and subbed out!
Depending on the amount of signups, I will be running a 15p mountainous (12 Vanilla Town, 3 Mafia Goon) or a semi-open setup which fits the playercount. Most likely Mafia will have 24/7 access to chat. I'm going to host things slightly different, so pay attention! In addition to the basic rules below, If no majority is reached at the end of the day, the player with the most votes is lynched instead. In the case of ties, a random player between the tied players will be eliminated.
Rules:
Game will start once previous one ends.
Signups:
1. Strike Wolf
2. Devante
3. pmchugh
4. Votanic
5. Swang918
6. Loose Cannon
7. DirtyDishSoap
8. Kingm
9. kongming3
10. *Pixar*
11. Maxleod
12. Ragian
13. Charle
14. fusibaseball
15. Trafalgarlaw01
Subs:
1. ghxstfolk
2. Son!c
SoN!c wrote:And on another note i gave Max a gamechat today at "2024-07-07 17:10:32 - SoN!c: hey man, say your thoughts in the mafia game" but seems like he ran away from it.
Maxleod wrote:SoN!c wrote:And on another note i gave Max a gamechat today at "2024-07-07 17:10:32 - SoN!c: hey man, say your thoughts in the mafia game" but seems like he ran away from it.
No, I was busy... Anyway it's too late.
Extreme Ways wrote:max died, he Vanilla Town.
I expect next day to start in ~48hours
SoN!c wrote:@Max, you can still say whatever it is you want to say
Users browsing this forum: No registered users