[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[dazza2008]

Tell me how storr was being productive for town then, and how everyone else was being productive

@Dazza Not excusable you will be lynched after hotshot

Fair enough. I can save time and not read all the pish you post then. Cheers.

He's joking because everyone is on his ass for not posting after he posted what i quoted above.

I got it but thanks for explaining.

3 pages of mtamburini not answering questions is shite though. I have seen nothing from him that helps town in the slightest. He just gets offensive when anyone asks anything. I can't tell if he is scummy or just being a twat as town but either way it's f*ck all help to town.

unvote vote mtamburini

@Tambo cause this right here is a very reasonable accusation against you lol?

I get wanting to look at people who stayed out of the lime light, or soft defended you.

I still stand by why I voted. Is it my fault his defence was to be a complete bell end? His play seemed to me to be scummy or unhelpful town. Still does if I am honest but he just claimed Harry Potter so obviously I have to believe it and just put it down to retarded play.

Fastposted. I bet a few people in here are wishing the same pal

[dazza2008]

He is referring to me storr.

Who do you think was sheeping your push then?

I had a vote on Charm before mtam. Pixar would probably have been my second guess. Lots of support for the no lynch.

Not defending it but pixie does this every game in our clan games. We have tried to explain to him that it is shit but he doesn't get it

He could still be scum but just saying he always votes no lynch day 1.

[mtamburini]

Explain how your play has been better than mine.

[dazza2008]

Explain how your play has been better than mine.

Explain where I said it was. I said I thought your play was shit not that mine was awesome or anything. I can't remember avoiding any questions though or soft claiming and being forced to claim.

I believe your claim though and I think debating this for 4 or 5 pages is going to add f*ck all though so I will stop now.

[degaston]

Unvote
Vote Pershy
WTF - Why would you start the game that way if you were HP?

Explain how your play has been better than mine.

He wasn't forced to claim - you were.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

mtamburini - sempai, sempai, virus, charm, skillful, madmitch, Pixar, BG
Ragian - mtamburini, dd
charm - HotShot, Endgame, Ragian
pershy - floyd, dazza, degaston
dd- Talapus

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

Deadline Friday, noon Eastern Time.

pershy has been prodded

[mtamburini]

Unvote
Vote Pershy
WTF - Why would you start the game that way if you were HP?

Explain how your play has been better than mine.

He wasn't forced to claim - you were.

Says the guy with admits to only playing one game

Info I can bring to the town, I can never die in the night because if I do it makes Voldemort vulernarable to night actions (probably means night vigi shots) As long as Im alive Voldemort can only be lynched. Keep that in mind if there is another vigi whos shot does not go through it may not be because there was a medic save or a protection role and could just be voldemort you attacked.

[sempaispellcheck]

As long as Im alive Voldemort can only be lynched.

Neither can live while the other survives.

Makes sense.

Keep that in mind if there is another vigi whos shot does not go through it may not be because there was a medic save or a protection role and could just be voldemort you attacked.

Hmm...if there is another vig, and we lynch you, our other vig can kill Voldemort at night.
It's the type of plan that might just be crazy enough to work, but probably isn't really worth trying.
I'll try to come up with something better tomorrow, when I'm more awake.

sempai

[sempaispellcheck]

EBWOP - quoted the wrong section of the prophecy.

...either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other survives...

Source

sempai

[HotShot53]

Well, I finally caught up on about 10 pages of mtam and got going back and forth to find out it's all meaningless now anyway lol. Since everyone would assume HP is in the game, I assume scum wouldn't fake claim him, so I'll assume mtam is telling the truth

Got was trying to pressure who he thought was scum (and avoidance of questions as mtam was doing can sometimes be a scum tell for some people, so it wasn't that bad of a push), so I am town reading got for now, I don't think a scum would stick themselves out quite that much. I'm iffy on daeg's late joining of the case, he's still neutral to slight scum to me.

Charm's posts on the mtam case were that we should pressure him because he wasn't answering questions but "I don't think we should lynch MTam unless he comes back with doing something very scummy. But, I have a hard time believing he is town when he throws up that he some special power."

So she wanted to pressure, but not lynch, but found it hard to think he was town... kind of a very wishy-washy position to take, so it's not changing my vote on her yet.

As for pershy, he is as good an inactivish person to pressure as any I guess, we'll see how he responds to the prod he just got before I'll add to his pressure.

[Metsfanmax]

I don't believe mtam. My guess is that he knows who HP actually is and is aligned with him, but since he had to claim and is town-aligned, he claimed HP to deflect attention away from the actual HP.

vote degaston

At some point, "I've only played one game" stops being a defense and starts being a scum tell after you've posted it like 30 times in as many pages.

[charm]

That was awesome, I was ROFL through all those pages and then we had that big ass claim from MTAM...wow, my jaw just totally dropped!

Charm's posts on the mtam case were that we should pressure him because he wasn't answering questions but "I don't think we should lynch MTam unless he comes back with doing something very scummy. But, I have a hard time believing he is town when he throws up that he some special power."

So she wanted to pressure, but not lynch, but found it hard to think he was town... kind of a very wishy-washy position to take, so it's not changing my vote on her yet.

I really like playing with MTAM, he makes me laugh and entertains us. I thought he was going to be some type of evil 3rd party, never did I expect him to be town, especially not HP. Even if he was mafia, I'd be bummed that we lynched him on day 1, just because he is such a good player. I think his Day 1 play was a bit reckless, but hopefully with the information that came out will actually help the town since it looks like it would be bad for mafia to lynch him.

[charm]

Oh, and unvote

[Streaker]

quote="dazza2008"]

Tell me how storr was being productive for town then, and how everyone else was being productive

@Dazza Not excusable you will be lynched after hotshot

Fair enough. I can save time and not read all the pish you post then. Cheers.

He's joking because everyone is on his ass for not posting after he posted what i quoted above.

I got it but thanks for explaining.

3 pages of mtamburini not answering questions is shite though. I have seen nothing from him that helps town in the slightest. He just gets offensive when anyone asks anything. I can't tell if he is scummy or just being a twat as town but either way it's f*ck all help to town.

unvote vote mtamburini[/quote]

Putting dazza on the hotseat tomorrow for this. Completely ignoring the fact that the 'questions' themselves are shite.
Aage did a good job of explaining this.

Dazza, is this really all you have to comment on this? I mean Tonka is equally guilty in what you are saying here...

He is referring to me storr.

Who do you think was sheeping your push then?

I had a vote on Charm before mtam. Pixar would probably have been my second guess. Lots of support for the no lynch.

Not defending it but pixie does this every game in our clan games. We have tried to explain to him that it is shit but he doesn't get it

He could still be scum but just saying he always votes no lynch day 1.

Defending the one soft pushing no lynch now?

Recapped, dazza was on both Storr's and Mtamb's wagon without pushing his own case. It's pretty much the definition of sheeping/wagoning.
This pretty much sums up his actions:

I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.

I keep hearing people say Storr may have a trick up his sleeve or he may be useful later on.

He's either a 3rd party survivor who has done nothing but draw attention to himself, claimed without pressure and made D1 suck worse than normal OR hes lying about the full extent of his role.

So, yeah. Ill lynch based on poor play or Ill lynch on Lynch all Liars...

This is pretty much exactly what I am thinking.

Vote Stor

He did the same with Mtamb as stated above. Clearly jumping on the bigger cases, all when the wagon is going full steam ahead. Not sticking head out at all. No reads on anyone.

Unvote, vote dazza.

I know deadline is coming up. We need to agree on a lynch. If you guys support my case, all the better.
Are you willing to lynch an inactive if things slow down this week? Not sure if we have any (dd comes to mind).

[Streaker]

EBWOP for messing up the quote.

Tell me how storr was being productive for town then, and how everyone else was being productive

@Dazza Not excusable you will be lynched after hotshot

Fair enough. I can save time and not read all the pish you post then. Cheers.

He's joking because everyone is on his ass for not posting after he posted what i quoted above.

I got it but thanks for explaining.

3 pages of mtamburini not answering questions is shite though. I have seen nothing from him that helps town in the slightest. He just gets offensive when anyone asks anything. I can't tell if he is scummy or just being a twat as town but either way it's f*ck all help to town.

unvote vote mtamburini

Putting dazza on the hotseat tomorrow for this. Completely ignoring the fact that the 'questions' themselves are shite.
Aage did a good job of explaining this.

Dazza, is this really all you have to comment on this? I mean Tonka is equally guilty in what you are saying here...

He is referring to me storr.

Who do you think was sheeping your push then?

I had a vote on Charm before mtam. Pixar would probably have been my second guess. Lots of support for the no lynch.

Not defending it but pixie does this every game in our clan games. We have tried to explain to him that it is shit but he doesn't get it

He could still be scum but just saying he always votes no lynch day 1.

Defending the one soft pushing no lynch now?

Recapped, dazza was on both Storr's and Mtamb's wagon without pushing his own case. It's pretty much the definition of sheeping/wagoning.
This pretty much sums up his actions:

I've claimed 3rd party survivor, yet that's not obvious I guess. I'm under no post Restriction other than having fun and being sad I'm not with anyone.

I keep hearing people say Storr may have a trick up his sleeve or he may be useful later on.

He's either a 3rd party survivor who has done nothing but draw attention to himself, claimed without pressure and made D1 suck worse than normal OR hes lying about the full extent of his role.

So, yeah. Ill lynch based on poor play or Ill lynch on Lynch all Liars...

This is pretty much exactly what I am thinking.

Vote Stor

He did the same with Mtamb as stated above. Clearly jumping on the bigger cases, all when the wagon is going full steam ahead. Not sticking head out at all. No reads on anyone.

Unvote, vote dazza.

I know deadline is coming up. We need to agree on a lynch. If you guys support my case, all the better.
Are you willing to lynch an inactive if things slow down this week? Not sure if we have any (dd comes to mind).[/quote]

[mtamburini]

Well, I finally caught up on about 10 pages of mtam and got going back and forth to find out it's all meaningless now anyway lol. Since everyone would assume HP is in the game, I assume scum wouldn't fake claim him, so I'll assume mtam is telling the truth

Got was trying to pressure who he thought was scum (and avoidance of questions as mtam was doing can sometimes be a scum tell for some people, so it wasn't that bad of a push), so I am town reading got for now, I don't think a scum would stick themselves out quite that much. I'm iffy on daeg's late joining of the case, he's still neutral to slight scum to me.

Charm's posts on the mtam case were that we should pressure him because he wasn't answering questions but "I don't think we should lynch MTam unless he comes back with doing something very scummy. But, I have a hard time believing he is town when he throws up that he some special power."

So she wanted to pressure, but not lynch, but found it hard to think he was town... kind of a very wishy-washy position to take, so it's not changing my vote on her yet.

As for pershy, he is as good an inactivish person to pressure as any I guess, we'll see how he responds to the prod he just got before I'll add to his pressure.

Worthless post, your read on why got is town is not logical. You didnt even mention anything about aage

[mtamburini]

I don't believe mtam. My guess is that he knows who HP actually is and is aligned with him, but since he had to claim and is town-aligned, he claimed HP to deflect attention away from the actual HP.

vote degaston

At some point, "I've only played one game" stops being a defense and starts being a scum tell after you've posted it like 30 times in as many pages.

This is one of the big reasons I dont want to read the shit thats been going on because I might just throw my laptop at my wall if this is the shit I gotta read.

If you think I know who Harry is, you would have to assume Harry knows that I know who he is. Now if you can tell me 1 person who might know that I know what they know, Ill send you on a trip anywhere in the world.

[mtamburini]

That was awesome, I was ROFL through all those pages and then we had that big ass claim from MTAM...wow, my jaw just totally dropped!

Charm's posts on the mtam case were that we should pressure him because he wasn't answering questions but "I don't think we should lynch MTam unless he comes back with doing something very scummy. But, I have a hard time believing he is town when he throws up that he some special power."

So she wanted to pressure, but not lynch, but found it hard to think he was town... kind of a very wishy-washy position to take, so it's not changing my vote on her yet.

I really like playing with MTAM, he makes me laugh and entertains us. I thought he was going to be some type of evil 3rd party, never did I expect him to be town, especially not HP. Even if he was mafia, I'd be bummed that we lynched him on day 1, just because he is such a good player. I think his Day 1 play was a bit reckless, but hopefully with the information that came out will actually help the town since it looks like it would be bad for mafia to lynch him.

Probably the only honest thing youve said this game is that you enjoy playing with me.

[mtamburini]

So anyone gonna just sheep me now

[Ragian]

Read through. No time to post. Must work. Will post this afternoon.

[Endgame422]

Wow.
Alot of shit happened today.
If tonka is town and just outed mtam...ouch.
Im not sure i believe mtam is the one but i certainly am not risking it D1.
We gotta lynch someone by friday y'all.
UNVOTE
VOTE DD
One of the less active players and also gave me kinda scummy vibe earlier.

[Streaker]

Wow.
Alot of shit happened today.
If tonka is town and just outed mtam...ouch.
Im not sure i believe mtam is the one but i certainly am not risking it D1.
We gotta lynch someone by friday y'all.
UNVOTE
VOTE DD
One of the less active players and also gave me kinda scummy vibe earlier.

Please explain scummy vibe on DD.
Also, why reference tonka and the outing of Mtamb (which is great), but then don't do anything with it?

[Endgame422]

Storr seems to know a lot, and if he won't tell us then I will vote Storr

Don't see anyone else as a better target (yes I know it's still early)

This was the dd post that made me suspicious earlier.
I believed storrs claim at this point(still do)and this is just poor logic.
He knows things/lets kill him.

[pershy]

What now? Pershy is too quiet. I have played lots of games with him and he normally posts a lot. I dunno if he is busy in real life but either way he is far too quiet.

Vote Pershy

Fastposted. Will read it now.

Yup - been working 12 hour days. Barely keeping up with my turns. Wanted to catch up at the weekend but at the theatre all weekend working too. Anyway, I've got a few pages to read up b4 I cast my vote. Will do so this evening.

[Streaker]

What now? Pershy is too quiet. I have played lots of games with him and he normally posts a lot. I dunno if he is busy in real life but either way he is far too quiet.

Vote Pershy

Fastposted. Will read it now.

Yup - been working 12 hour days. Barely keeping up with my turns. Wanted to catch up at the weekend but at the theatre all weekend working too. Anyway, I've got a few pages to read up b4 I cast my vote. Will do so this evening.

It does make me wanna lynch you, actually. If you had posted somewhere in the weekend with 'busy irl, will catch up whenever', I'd let you off the hook. But posting right after being called out is just...